Philosophy Explorer wrote:It seems this question has no solution. Scientists say that since the Big Bang, the universe has been expanding. Okay I can buy that one. But then the question turns on inside of what? Another universe possibly? Or nothingness?
What do you think?
PhilX
PhilX,
This is a remarkably perspicacious question.
You won't like my thoughts on it because they are derived from a theory you have yet to explore, Beon Theory.
It proposes that at least two things must interact in order for an event to occur, as per Newtonian mechanics. One of them provides a force, the other a counter-force. Again, basic Newtonian stuff.
At our level of reality, interactions and their consequent events occur and are confined within a 3-D space. There is an obscure mathematical theorem that I've learned about but cannot find, anywhere, which states that events can only take place in a space one dimension higher than the space in which they exist.
For example, imagine a theoretical 2-D sheet of paper resting upon the flat surface of a table. Imagine that you lift one end of the paper off the table. This can only happen if a 3-D space exists into which you can lift the 2-D sheet.
It would seem that 3-D objects such as particles would require, according to this theorem, another dimension in which to operate. Ergo, there must exist a fourth dimension.
BTW, forget about time. It is not a dimension in the same sense as space is a dimension. IOW there must be a 4th
spatial dimension.
According to the aforementioned Beon Theory, there are two 3-D spaces (mathematicians would call them "manifolds") confined within the 4th spatial dimension, each offering a counterforce to the other. Modern physics has identified one of these, the dark-energy space of the universe we know, but does not refer to it as I've done here.
The other space (manifold) contains the entities responsible for consciousness, with the appropriate counterforce properties.
If (and this could be a very large IF) classical physics principles apply to the very beginnings of the universe, a 4-D space would accommodate two (or more) potentially interactive 3-D spaces.