Page 40 of 41

Re: What is morality?

Posted: Sat Nov 21, 2026 1:07 am
by Immanuel Can
MikeNovack wrote: ↑Sat Nov 21, 2026 12:20 am
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Fri Nov 20, 2026 10:51 pm
There's all the proof you're going to need, that living matter did not come from non-living, that meaning doesn't arise from randomness, and that impersonal, unguided forces did not create a world.

Now, what does the other side have?
That intelligent design/creationism does not get you to a "god".
It sure gets you something like God. It gets you a Supreme Being, intelligently and purposefully creating the world.

The purpose of that argument is not to explain WHICH God. It's only to show you that there IS a God. There are other, better arguments to exposit His character.
But IC, back to those questions:
1) Do you believe in Oshun, Chnago, Yemejah, et.do not exist ? WHY?
The argument is that God exists. It will take further arguments to show WHICH God, it's true; but that doesn't damage the value of the argument for the purpose it's offered.
2) Do you feel it necessary to give reasons for your belief they do not exist? Reasons based upon the material realm?
See above. That's not the question the argument is answering.
3) Why are you asking something different from the atheist?
I've explained that. The Atheist has nothing, and the Theist has lots of evidence. The Atheist is claiming he can prove a negative; the Theist only has to show a positive. The Atheist cannot meet his own burden of proof; the burden on a Theist is only to show one single genuine evidence. It's by no means equivalent.
4) If faced with an initiate of Santeria, who tells you "I have evidence. I have danced and experienced the gods in my body" what do you say?
He's not claiming a God. He's claiming gods. They're quite different predications, you'll find. And all I'd ask him is what makes him think these "gods" are good?
...the atheist says "But I see the Muslim in the other corner of the room saying the same thing. Why should I believe you and not him?
The Atheist actually is insisting he won't believe in ANY God, whether mine or the Muslim's. But once again, the Atheist has misunderstood the purpose of the argument: it's not to show which God is being asserted; just that some Supreme Being and First Cause actually exists.

Beyond that, the Atheist can't ask about that, because he's rendered his own question stupid. He's believing there's no God or gods; so he's essentially asking, "What kind of God doesn't exist?" :shock:

Dumb question: things that (he assumes) cannot exist cannot have characteristics, either. He's in no position to pose the question.

Re: What is morality?

Posted: Sat Nov 21, 2026 6:38 am
by Walker
MikeNovack wrote: ↑Fri Nov 20, 2026 6:55 pm
Uh no, that's not a correct understanding of what happens when two sub-species of a species meet and interbreed to become one species.
That's interesting, however, I never asserted that two species became one. I said that everyone has some Neanderthal DNA, enough to cause folks to have allergies these days. The effects of that upon morality are speculative, as is the cause of their extinction, as is their personalities, as is the scientific explanation for the origin of human life. It's not so far-fetched to speculate that Homo sapiens killed them all off. It's doubtful that the weather or critters did them in since apparently they were more physically suited to the same conditions as Homo sapiens.

All modern humans have Neanderthal DNA, new research finds
https://edition.cnn.com/2020/01/30/afri ... al-dna-scn

Re: What is morality?

Posted: Sat Nov 21, 2026 9:39 am
by Gary Childress
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Fri Nov 20, 2026 10:51 pm
Gary Childress wrote: ↑Fri Nov 20, 2026 9:25 pm
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Fri Nov 20, 2026 7:47 pm
Of course. It's called "argument to the best explanation." It means that, all else being equal, you're wisest to go with the most credible explanation of the available evidence.

There is no more adequate or obvious explanation for the world as we find it, with all its complexity and interdependence, than that an intelligent Designer is behind it. Such complexity does not come from accidents, as we see every day.
Keep repeating it, and I guess it will stick. Where are you getting the notion that a world of complexity and interdependence cannot possibly have come into being without an "intelligent designer"?
Try it. Try, using nothing but chance and time, to make anything just "pop" into existence. Take the staples out of your stapler, and throw them on the floor -- how long until they become living matter? How long until they spell out "To be, or not to be"? How long until they become a cat?

There's all the proof you're going to need, that living matter did not come from non-living, that meaning doesn't arise from randomness, and that impersonal, unguided forces did not create a world.

Now, what does the other side have?
No one can possibly conduct an experiment to see if complex and interdependent worlds must necessarily come from intelligent designers. It's logically and physically impossible, and doesn't seem theoretically possible either, for human beings to conduct such an experiment. We know of 1 world in existence, and we don't know a great deal about the ultimate reality of it, if there is something beyond our ability to perceive, deduce or experimentally determine. So saying that complex and interdependent worlds can only have an intelligent designer does not logically follow from anything humans reliably know with certainty about the world. Do you disagree?

Re: What is morality?

Posted: Sat Nov 21, 2026 1:26 pm
by promethean75
More energy is spent on questions that can't be answered than on problems staring you directly in the face. That is what philosophy has done to mankind. One look at Elon Musk or Donald Trump, and you should feel not the least bit interested in where we came from or what 'objective morality' means. None of this matters until these two and their type are wiped out of existence. Until then, all intellectualism is useless floundering.

What does this entail? It entails total disregard of law and order and active rebellion against it and everything it protects. This comes before we bother ourselves with figuring out what 'right' and 'wrong' are.

Re: What is morality?

Posted: Sat Nov 21, 2026 1:31 pm
by promethean75
Speaking of Musk... I wish somebody would bring his ugly ass here so I can gut em in front of the whole world. Sometimes, it takes that. People often won't let go of their heroes until they see how easily they fall.

Re: What is morality?

Posted: Sat Nov 21, 2026 1:55 pm
by phyllo
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Fri Nov 20, 2026 7:47 pm
phyllo wrote: ↑Fri Nov 20, 2026 4:46 pm Can you show a cause and effect relationship between what he sees in the morning and a God?
Of course. It's called "argument to the best explanation." It means that, all else being equal, you're wisest to go with the most credible explanation of the available evidence.

There is no more adequate or obvious explanation for the world as we find it, with all its complexity and interdependence, than that an intelligent Designer is behind it. Such complexity does not come from accidents, as we see every day.
You jump from "God could have done it" to "God must have done it" in a heartbeat. God is a possible explanation but nothing indicates that it is the "most credible explanation".

All the explanations for the existence of the world have fatal flaws, including the God explanation. Which indicates that currently humans do not have sufficient understanding to explain it. The best answer is "we don't know".

There is no reason for an atheist to accept the existence of God based on the "evidence" of the world. It just doesn't follow.

Re: What is morality?

Posted: Sat Nov 21, 2026 3:38 pm
by MikeNovack
Walker wrote: ↑Sat Nov 21, 2026 6:38 am All modern humans have Neanderthal DNA, new research finds
https://edition.cnn.com/2020/01/30/afri ... al-dna-scn
a) And the gradient in percentage is as expected (thus percent Neanderthal lowest in southern Africa, highest remote from Africa like eastern Asia)
b) Because mitochondrial DNA just from mother. we now know that the mixing was mainly female Sapiens and male Neanderthal

To think of Neanderthals as being extinct misunderstands the situation. Thus the population of pure F. sylvestris that still remains as "pure" in remote Scotland is disappearing because being swamped by domestic cat genes. F. sylvestris sylvestris once occupied all of Britain, etc.. But their genes remain (so we have domestic cat breeds like Norwegian Forest Cat and Maine Coon Cat)

My reference to Neanderthal culture surviving is really still unproven in the sense that MAYBE Sapiens did things like treat the dead with ceremony or treat the sick or injured and we just haven't found the evidence. But essentially there are a number of these things we now find common in the cultures of the (re)unified species that we have evidence for in Neanderthal cultures but not Sapiens cultures. << my "re" is because not a single event, contact/mixing --- by the time of the final mixing there had already been several prior, so the Neanderthals of the final mixing already had a lot of Sapiens in them >>

You want to keep up with (human paleontology/archeology) in the Middle East where the mixing took place. And the studies in genetics.

Re: What is morality?

Posted: Sat Nov 21, 2026 5:22 pm
by Walker
MikeNovack wrote: ↑Sat Nov 21, 2026 3:38 pm
Humans must have had some knowledge of fermentation and botany early on because mating with a Neanderthal would likely require both, at two in the morning at the Flintstone Inn and Tavern.

They say Neanderthal made jewelry. Why, can only be an assumption, but beauty was likely part of the reason.

Then again, perhaps back in the cave days all humans were animals without knowledge of good and evil, until that consciousness manifested later under the right conditions and they came to know beauty, and shame.

Re: What is morality?

Posted: Sat Nov 21, 2026 6:47 pm
by Immanuel Can
phyllo wrote: ↑Sat Nov 21, 2026 1:55 pm
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Fri Nov 20, 2026 7:47 pm
phyllo wrote: ↑Fri Nov 20, 2026 4:46 pm Can you show a cause and effect relationship between what he sees in the morning and a God?
Of course. It's called "argument to the best explanation." It means that, all else being equal, you're wisest to go with the most credible explanation of the available evidence.

There is no more adequate or obvious explanation for the world as we find it, with all its complexity and interdependence, than that an intelligent Designer is behind it. Such complexity does not come from accidents, as we see every day.
You jump from "God could have done it" to "God must have done it" in a heartbeat.
There's no "jump." The procedure of argument to the best explanation is not to obtain absolute certainty, which is impossible to humans anyway, but the highest probability certainty.
God is a possible explanation but nothing indicates that it is the "most credible explanation".
Actually, much does. But again, only somebody open to the possibility of evidence is going to be willing to recognize it.
The best answer is "we don't know".
That won't do. Because we are beings-toward. That is, you and I have lives to lead, projects to undertake, goals to reach...things that require us to organize our lives to achieve what is good or desirable for us. And we cannot shrug off that fact. We are going to make our decisions based on something: isn't it better that we make our decisions based on the highest probability of correct information?
There is no reason for an atheist to accept the existence of God based on the "evidence" of the world. It just doesn't follow.
Actually there's plenty of reason. But the Atheist won't sit still for any of it. His mind's made up. He's already declared that it is. And it was made up on nothing.

Re: What is morality?

Posted: Sat Nov 21, 2026 7:15 pm
by MikeNovack
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Sat Nov 21, 2026 6:47 pm
Actually there's plenty of reason. But the Atheist won't sit still for any of it. His mind's made up. He's already declared that it is. And it was made up on nothing.
Are you SURE you want to argue based on "his mind is made up"?

For some reason you want somebody to show you a set is empty BEFORE deciding the criteria necessary for some "x" to be member of the set. Look, we CAN demonstrate a set (of things in the realm of the immaterial) empty even though an infinite number of things to consider.

There is no integer between the natural number 2 and 3 (the set of such natural numbers is empty). But to do that we need to understand the properties of natural numbers. WE don't do that by saying "4 is not between 2 and 3, 5 is not in between 2 and 3, ........" << because that would be infinite >>

My questions (which you refuse to answer) have to do with how YOU decide an "x" is (or is not) a god. What reasons YOU consider valid. So please, answer those questions for Chango, Yemejah, et al (that deity set).

I also want you to consider the non-theists (therefore "atheists") because that is part and parcel of "what qualifies as God/gods" according to you. Too much to ask you to consider this in terms of "Eastern" religions, so do it in terms of Spinoza. Yes or no, is Spinoza's "One Substance" a way to look at God. Or is anything like that, no separation between the material realm and this ONE something fundamentally different from what you mean by God/gods?

Re: What is morality?

Posted: Sat Nov 21, 2026 7:38 pm
by Immanuel Can
MikeNovack wrote: ↑Sat Nov 21, 2026 7:15 pm
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Sat Nov 21, 2026 6:47 pm
Actually there's plenty of reason. But the Atheist won't sit still for any of it. His mind's made up. He's already declared that it is. And it was made up on nothing.
Are you SURE you want to argue based on "his mind is made up"?
He's already declared it. He's said that he knows there's no God. That's pretty much done, isn't it?

But if all he's saying is "I don't know God," then he's said nothing at all...except confessing his personal lack of knowledge or experience.

Re: What is morality?

Posted: Sat Nov 21, 2026 8:10 pm
by Will Bouwman
Will Bouwman wrote: ↑Fri Nov 20, 2026 11:40 am...I do not assert that there is no god, nor do I preach that others should. A complete moron would read the above and insist the exact opposite.
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Fri Nov 20, 2026 3:26 pm...do you preach to others, as you are doing at the present moment? :shock:
Will Bouwman wrote: ↑Fri Nov 20, 2026 11:40 amA weasely little twat would insert new conditions to their definition so that all atheists are 'Atheists'.
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Fri Nov 20, 2026 3:26 pmAtheism is a chain of ideas.
You are an open book Mr Can and somewhere on every page, the words fücking idiot appear.

Re: What is morality?

Posted: Sat Nov 21, 2026 8:39 pm
by phyllo
There's no "jump." The procedure of argument to the best explanation is not to obtain absolute certainty, which is impossible to humans anyway, but the highest probability certainty.
Discussing God in one thread it's absolute ontological truth and the excluded middle and in another thread it's impossible to obtain absolute certainty. You say whatever scores you points, right?
Actually, much does.
Just asserting it does not make it true.
But again, only somebody open to the possibility of evidence is going to be willing to recognize it.
Hilarious, since you are one of the most close minded people imaginable.
The best answer is "we don't know".
That won't do. Because we are beings-toward. That is, you and I have lives to lead, projects to undertake, goals to reach...things that require us to organize our lives to achieve what is good or desirable for us. And we cannot shrug off that fact. We are going to make our decisions based on something: isn't it better that we make our decisions based on the highest probability of correct information?
I don't need to know how the universe got started in order to live my life. On a list of priorities of what I need to know, that's way at the bottom.

Claiming that there is an answer when there is not enough information to formulate the answer is just foolishness.
But the Atheist won't sit still for any of it. His mind's made up. He's already declared that it is. And it was made up on nothing.
Your mind is made up.

All the criticism you level at the atheist applies to you.

Re: What is morality?

Posted: Sat Nov 21, 2026 10:46 pm
by Immanuel Can
phyllo wrote: ↑Sat Nov 21, 2026 8:39 pm
There's no "jump." The procedure of argument to the best explanation is not to obtain absolute certainty, which is impossible to humans anyway, but the highest probability certainty.
Discussing God in one thread it's absolute ontological truth and the excluded middle and in another thread it's impossible to obtain absolute certainty. You say whatever scores you points, right?
Category error on your part. God's existence is an ontological issue. Man's absolute certainty is an epistemological one.

I say again: no amount of belief or skepticism on man's part changes anything about ontological reality. Truth is truth. Man's knowledge is only man's knowledge.
The best answer is "we don't know".
That won't do. Because we are beings-toward. That is, you and I have lives to lead, projects to undertake, goals to reach...things that require us to organize our lives to achieve what is good or desirable for us. And we cannot shrug off that fact. We are going to make our decisions based on something: isn't it better that we make our decisions based on the highest probability of correct information?
I don't need to know how the universe got started in order to live my life. On a list of priorities of what I need to know, that's way at the bottom.
Actually, it's not. You're going to have to make some assumption: that you're here by intention -- good intention or evil intention, or here by chance. And whichever you take as your tacit assumption, it's going to determine a whole lot about your priorities and beliefs.

Just because a person maybe hasn't examined his assumptions wouldn't mean he doesn't have them. He just has them, but is unconscious of what they are.
Claiming that there is an answer when there is not enough information to formulate the answer is just foolishness.
Claiming there is no evidence is a whole lot bigger folly than that. One has to deny what's right before one's eyes.

Re: What is morality?

Posted: Sat Nov 21, 2026 11:06 pm
by phyllo
Category error on your part. God's existence is an ontological issue. Man's absolute certainty is an epistemological one.
You realize the discussion is about an atheist deciding if god exists based on some evidence. The blind Jains were describing god based on some evidence. It's all the same soup.
You're going to have to make some assumption: that you're here by intention -- good intention or evil intention, or here by chance.
My life is exactly the same for all 3 options.

How does good or bad intention or no intention change anything?

If I was structuring my life around god and religions, then sure, I might go spread the good word about god or warn people about god. My messaging would change. But that's not my life. It's probably yours.