Page 38 of 41

Re: What is morality?

Posted: Wed Nov 18, 2026 8:23 pm
by Immanuel Can
MikeNovack wrote: ↑Wed Nov 18, 2026 6:49 pm
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Wed Nov 18, 2026 5:02 pm
But suppose the atheist said "here's the evidence". Would you be able to judge whether evidence or not?
Of course. The evidence would have to be commensurate with the claim. That is how we can know, even before he speaks, that the Atheists is not capable of having that evidence.

Ask yourself: what would the evidence for "no-God" be? Then ask yourself this: what would be the commensurate evidence for the EXISTENCE of God? And which of the two is even potentially doable?
But suppose we haven't gotten as far as the atheist's answer. Just as far as you asking for it.
We haven't. The very fact that a man announces himself as an Atheist invites the next question: "An Atheist for only yourself, or an Atheist who expects others to care?"

As for "evidence," you're missing the point. A private Atheist doesn't owe any to anybody. The evangelical Atheist does, but can't produce it, because his view isn't rational...as you have pointed out, you can't disprove the "non-existence" of an infinite Supreme Being. There is no test for that.

But let me ask you again, and this time, maybe you answer: what evidence would suffice to show the existence of God?

Hint: it's very, very easy.

Re: What is morality?

Posted: Wed Nov 18, 2026 9:27 pm
by MikeNovack
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Wed Nov 18, 2026 8:23 pm But let me ask you again, and this time, maybe you answer: what evidence would suffice to show the existence of God?

Hint: it's very, very easy.
It is? I know you think very, very easy. But you mean by that something YOU would consider "evidence". Not anything the atheist would consider evidence, or for that matter, a believer like Occam.

I am saying you can't any more than the rationalist can show you evidence in support of evolution. By which I mean "evidence that you will accept s being evidence" because not in agreement with your religious beliefs.

When the atheist says "I cannot give you evidence that gods do not exist" he/she means by that "what I myself would consider evidence". Not saying could not give you the sort of nonsense you consider evidence (for the existence of gods).

You have a fundamental disagreement about "what is evidence".

Re: What is morality?

Posted: Wed Nov 18, 2026 9:43 pm
by Immanuel Can
MikeNovack wrote: ↑Wed Nov 18, 2026 9:27 pm
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Wed Nov 18, 2026 8:23 pm But let me ask you again, and this time, maybe you answer: what evidence would suffice to show the existence of God?

Hint: it's very, very easy.
It is?
It is.

I'll tell you, since you don't seem to know. One genuine miracle...from the parting of the Red Sea to the lights that stayed on in the Temple, to a personal miracle only you have experienced. Just one. Or one prophecy, where the speaker genuinely knew beforehand what would happen. Or one true divine revelation of any kind...Torah, the New Testament, the Koran, the Gita, the Dhammapada, the Tao, or any other. One genuine epiphany. One genuine incarnation. One genuine answer to prayer. One Creation event. One miracle of healing or inspiration. One salvation.

In fact, one of any genuine religious manifestation, be it in any tradition, at any time, any place, to anybody...that's all it would take for Atheism to be proved completely untrue, and the existence of God to be manifest. Just one.

Have there been more? I would say so. But either way, the Atheists is in no position at all to assert -- as if he ever could -- that he has reason to believe no such things have ever taken place, are taking place, or ever could take place. And that's what it would take for Atheism to be proved right.
When the atheist says "I cannot give you evidence that gods do not exist" he/she means by that "what I myself would consider evidence".
Then I'm pointing out he's bluffing. There is simply no way that a finite creature like an Atheist ever has the possibility of producing the requisite evidence to say, "I know there's no God," or "Because I don't believe in God, you can't either."

The Atheist has NO evidence. None of any kind. All Theists think they have at least some: creation, revelation, intelligent design, the human consciousness, morality, history, logic, mathematics, astronomy, personal revelation, prophecy...

Now, you may refuse the Theists' evidence. A person can choose to do that. But you can't pretend they don't have it. And you don't have to refuse any of the Atheist's evidence, because he has none. In fact, many of them are proud of the claim that they don't even need any, and say -- well, I just disbelieve, so I don't need to produce any.

And again, that's fine if they keep themselves private about that. But the very second they say, "You shouldn't believe in God," they're putting themselves back on the hook for evidence...evidence they simply do not have.

As you can see, one of these is not like the other.

Re: What is morality?

Posted: Wed Nov 18, 2026 11:12 pm
by mickthinks
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Wed Nov 18, 2026 9:43 pm
MikeNovack wrote: ↑Wed Nov 18, 2026 9:27 pmWhen the atheist says "I cannot give you evidence that gods do not exist" he/she means by that "what I myself would consider evidence".
Then I'm pointing out he's bluffing.
lolwat?

Re: What is morality?

Posted: Wed Nov 18, 2026 11:53 pm
by MikeNovack
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Wed Nov 18, 2026 9:43 pm
I'll tell you, since you don't seem to know. One genuine miracle...from the parting of the Red Sea to the lights that stayed on in the Temple, to a personal miracle only you have experienced. Just one. Or one prophecy, where the speaker genuinely knew beforehand what would happen. Or one true divine revelation of any kind.........
I'll repeat, the materialist would not consider any of that evidence (accounts of miracles). And as you possibly know, Jewish tradition does not consider them EVIDENCE (a basis for BELIEF, yes) In the Talmud there is a discussion in which one sage asked for (and got miracles) to back his interpretation of some point of law but the others said not EVIDENCE.

This is exactly the point I am trying to make. You and the secularist are disagreeing about what is EVIDENCE.

Re: What is morality?

Posted: Thu Nov 19, 2026 1:09 am
by Immanuel Can
MikeNovack wrote: ↑Wed Nov 18, 2026 11:53 pm
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Wed Nov 18, 2026 9:43 pm
I'll tell you, since you don't seem to know. One genuine miracle...from the parting of the Red Sea to the lights that stayed on in the Temple, to a personal miracle only you have experienced. Just one. Or one prophecy, where the speaker genuinely knew beforehand what would happen. Or one true divine revelation of any kind.........
I'll repeat,
Don't. It only shows you're completely missing the point.

Say something smart, instead. Consider that one authentic anything will validate the existence of X; but as you've already recognized, the same is not true of proving the non-existence of X. For example, if I say there is a beast called a "kudu," then what do you have to do in order to prove there are no kudus in the world?

That's right: go everywhere, check every possibility, all at the same time (so kudus don't slip past you), and eliminate every place they could be. Then you can say, "There are no kudus in the world." Fair enough. Of course, that won't even be enough for God, since God, unlike the kudu, is a transcendent being that is not bound by time and not subject to human commands; He can show himself to those He wishes to, and withhold the same from those who are cynics. And, of course, since God is timeless, beyond space, and imminent in Creation, there are no tests that can eliminate him from possibility.

If the Atheist could perform the set of tests required to prove the non-existence of God, he'd have proved instead that a god actually exists -- and it would be the Atheist himself, since nothing less than an actual God could run the set of tests capable of proving the non-existence of God.

So the Atheist's proposal is just that dumb: he'd have to BE God to prove God doesn't exist.

But back to the kudu: what do I have to do, in order to prove that the kudu exists? Yep, that's right: I show you one kudu. Just one. Or maybe even a hair from one, if we use DNA. Or maybe just a photo, as long as it's authentic. Just one. And if I have one, I, the "kuduist" am proved right, and you, the a-kudu-ist, are proved wrong. Conclusively. Absolutely.

So you see, the Atheist has put himself in a situation in which no evidence at all is sufficient for the task he's set to himself. Not so, the Theist: he has only one thing to do -- to find one genuine action of divine providence, of any kind, any time, anywhere. And if he can do that, whether to your satisfaction or not, he's just fine: he's rational, he's evidentiary, and he's right.

Re: What is morality?

Posted: Thu Nov 19, 2026 12:25 pm
by promethean75
".... is a transcendent being that is not bound by time and not subject to human commands; He can show himself to those He wishes to, and withhold the same from those who are cynics. And, of course, since God is timeless, beyond space, and imminent in Creation, there are no tests that can eliminate him from possibility."

Under any other circumstances, anyone reading that would be terrified and want nothing to do with whatever it is you just described. It's like reading the profile for the supermutant Apocalypse from the x-men.

Re: What is morality?

Posted: Thu Nov 19, 2026 9:46 pm
by MikeNovack
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Thu Nov 19, 2026 1:09 am
But back to the kudu: what do I have to do, in order to prove that the kudu exists? Yep, that's right: I show you one kudu. Just one. Or maybe even a hair from one, if we use DNA. Or maybe just a photo, as long as it's authentic. Just one. And if I have one, I, the "kuduist" am proved right, and you, the a-kudu-ist, are proved wrong. Conclusively. Absolutely.

So you see, the Atheist has put himself in a situation in which no evidence at all is sufficient for the task he's set to himself. Not so, the Theist: he has only one thing to do -- to find one genuine action of divine providence, of any kind, any time, anywhere. And if he can do that, whether to your satisfaction or not, he's just fine: he's rational, he's evidentiary, and he's right.
You really don't get it.

STRAIGHT ANSWERS PLEASE --- Do you disbelieve in the existence of a pink, totu wearing unicorn in the realm of the the immaterial?
If not, why not?
Are your reasons for disbelief in the pink, tut, wearing unicorn justified in spite of the fact you cannot
produce evidence of non-existence?
If somebody says to you, the pink, tutu wearing unicorn exists, it existence has been revealed to me, how do you respond?

Now, IC, why do you think the atheist has to answer different than you just did? Is it not because YOU think the existence of God is (far) less preposterous than the existence of the pink, tutu wearing unicorn? A Judgement on your part. Isn't the atheist entitled to making his/her own judgement of the relative preposterousness of gods and pink, tutu wearing unicorns.


I do understand, IC. You believe you have EVIDENCE that God exists. But the atheist does NOT believe you have EVIDENCE, and your repeated attempts to show the atheist, "see, evidence A, evidence B, ......" reinforces that belief << to the atheist, just indications you haven't a clue about what evidence is >>

Re: What is morality?

Posted: Thu Nov 19, 2026 10:02 pm
by Immanuel Can
MikeNovack wrote: ↑Thu Nov 19, 2026 9:46 pm
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Thu Nov 19, 2026 1:09 am
But back to the kudu: what do I have to do, in order to prove that the kudu exists? Yep, that's right: I show you one kudu. Just one. Or maybe even a hair from one, if we use DNA. Or maybe just a photo, as long as it's authentic. Just one. And if I have one, I, the "kuduist" am proved right, and you, the a-kudu-ist, are proved wrong. Conclusively. Absolutely.

So you see, the Atheist has put himself in a situation in which no evidence at all is sufficient for the task he's set to himself. Not so, the Theist: he has only one thing to do -- to find one genuine action of divine providence, of any kind, any time, anywhere. And if he can do that, whether to your satisfaction or not, he's just fine: he's rational, he's evidentiary, and he's right.
You really don't get it.

STRAIGHT ANSWERS PLEASE
It's all I've been giving you.
--- Do you disbelieve in the existence of a pink, totu wearing unicorn in the realm of the the immaterial?
You're comparing an imaginary concrete object to the transcendent Supreme Being? Just how is that supposed to work? It looks like a raving category error, at first glance.

But to answer your question, none of us has reason to believe in things for which there's no evidence. But that's certainly not comparable, because there's abundant evidence for God, and none for the pink unicorns of your imagining.

You know, Dawkins tried this stunt years ago. He called it "the celestial teapot." It was just as stupid then as the pink unicorns now -- which he intended it to be, of course. And it's been answered by multiple respondents, since then. I'm not even the first to point out either the category error or the false analogy.
Now, IC, why do you think the atheist has to answer different than you just did?
Because the Atheist has no evidence, and since he's trying to prove a negative, has put himself far behind the eight ball. The Theist has abundant evidence, and is only burdened to find any evidence of a positive.

It's really not at all hard...you said it yourself, actually...and then forgot, I think.
the atheist does NOT believe you have EVIDENCE,
No, he knows: he just refuses to accept anything AS evidence for God. That's quite a different thing.

Again, if he only wants to confess his own ignorance, I have no problem with him. But when he evangelizes to others, or recommends his view, then he burdens himself to provide warrant...which he cannot do.

Re: What is morality?

Posted: Thu Nov 19, 2026 11:59 pm
by MikeNovack
MikeNovack wrote: ↑Thu Nov 19, 2026 9:46 pm
STRAIGHT ANSWERS PLEASE ---
1) Do you disbelieve in the existence of a pink, totu wearing unicorn in the realm of the the immaterial?
2) If not, why not?
3) Are your reasons for disbelief in the pink, tut, wearing unicorn justified in spite of the fact you cannot
produce evidence of non-existence?
4) If somebody says to you, the pink, tutu wearing unicorn exists, it existence has been revealed to me, how do you respond?
Let's try again, no ducking. There were multiple questions to answer. Answer each question, but because of what you included in your ducking answers, NO, you cannot use "the pink, tutu wearing unicorn" is something material in the material realm. It was specified "in the realm of the immaterial". Reread "1" if you doubt that.

Remember -- the atheist has NOT been presented with any EVIDENCE if God's existence. That is what "4" is all about.

Nor am I just interested in the way you are responding to atheists. You seem to be responding to believers of other religions in the same way. Again, not of concern your belief that yours is the true religion and theirs the false one but that you do not recognize the symmetry. You seem to respond as if THEY should be believing what you do.

Re: What is morality?

Posted: Fri Nov 20, 2026 12:34 am
by Immanuel Can
MikeNovack wrote: ↑Thu Nov 19, 2026 11:59 pm
MikeNovack wrote: ↑Thu Nov 19, 2026 9:46 pm
STRAIGHT ANSWERS PLEASE ---
1) Do you disbelieve in the existence of a pink, totu wearing unicorn in the realm of the the immaterial?
2) If not, why not?
3) Are your reasons for disbelief in the pink, tut, wearing unicorn justified in spite of the fact you cannot
produce evidence of non-existence?
4) If somebody says to you, the pink, tutu wearing unicorn exists, it existence has been revealed to me, how do you respond?
One question at a time. Number 1 is already answered. So it number 2. So is number three. Didn't you even read my answers?

Answer to number 4: see your therapist. Or stop smoking that stuff.
Remember -- the atheist has NOT been presented with any EVIDENCE if God's existence.
The only way somebody hasn't been presented with evidence for God, is that he's been living on another planet. See Romans 1.

Re: What is morality?

Posted: Fri Nov 20, 2026 3:46 am
by phyllo
The atheist has not been presented sufficiently convincing evidence.

Re: What is morality?

Posted: Fri Nov 20, 2026 5:31 am
by Immanuel Can
phyllo wrote: ↑Fri Nov 20, 2026 3:46 am The atheist has not been presented sufficiently convincing evidence.
He has. He just doesn't like it.

Re: What is morality?

Posted: Fri Nov 20, 2026 5:40 am
by MikeNovack
OK IC, I have made this too difficult for you by being flip using pink, tutu wearing unicorns as the placeholder for gods. Maybe you will be able to answer the questions if we substitute the Orishas of Santeria, Oshun, Chango, Yameja, et al. instead of pink, tutu wearing unicorns. I am just as certain you disbelieve in their existence.

So try again, answer those questions.

And for "4" -- Do you REALLY want to say that anybody who claims to have experienced evidence of the existence of God/gods is in need of therapy? The atheist might agree with that, but perhaps you might want to reconsider your answer.

Re: What is morality?

Posted: Fri Nov 20, 2026 6:39 am
by phyllo
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Fri Nov 20, 2026 5:31 am
phyllo wrote: ↑Fri Nov 20, 2026 3:46 am The atheist has not been presented sufficiently convincing evidence.
He has. He just doesn't like it.
That's nonsense which you believe about atheists.