MikeNovack wrote: ↑Wed Nov 18, 2026 9:27 pm
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Wed Nov 18, 2026 8:23 pm
But let me ask you again, and this time, maybe you answer:
what evidence would suffice to show the existence of God?
Hint: it's very, very easy.
It is?
It is.
I'll tell you, since you don't seem to know. One genuine miracle...from the parting of the Red Sea to the lights that stayed on in the Temple, to a personal miracle only you have experienced. Just one. Or one prophecy, where the speaker genuinely knew beforehand what would happen. Or one true divine revelation of any kind...
Torah, the New Testament, the
Koran, the
Gita, the
Dhammapada, the
Tao, or any other. One genuine epiphany. One genuine incarnation. One genuine answer to prayer. One Creation event. One miracle of healing or inspiration. One salvation.
In fact, one of any genuine religious manifestation, be it in any tradition, at any time, any place, to anybody...that's all it would take for Atheism to be proved completely untrue, and the existence of God to be manifest. Just one.
Have there been more? I would say so. But either way, the Atheists is in no position at all to assert -- as if he ever could -- that he has reason to believe no such things have ever taken place, are taking place, or ever could take place. And that's what it would take for Atheism to be proved right.
When the atheist says "I cannot give you evidence that gods do not exist" he/she means by that "what I myself would consider evidence".
Then I'm pointing out he's bluffing. There is simply no way that a finite creature like an Atheist ever has the possibility of producing the requisite evidence to say, "I know there's no God," or "Because I don't believe in God, you can't either."
The Atheist has NO evidence. None of any kind. All Theists think they have at least
some: creation, revelation, intelligent design, the human consciousness, morality, history, logic, mathematics, astronomy, personal revelation, prophecy...
Now, you may refuse the Theists' evidence. A person can choose to do that. But you can't pretend they don't have it. And you don't have to refuse any of the Atheist's evidence, because
he has none. In fact, many of them are proud of the claim that they don't even need any, and say -- well, I just
disbelieve, so I don't need to produce any.
And again, that's fine if they keep themselves private about that. But the very second they say, "You shouldn't believe in God," they're putting themselves back on the hook for evidence...evidence they simply do not have.
As you can see, one of these is not like the other.