MikeNovack wrote: ↑Tue Nov 17, 2026 4:52 pm
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Tue Nov 17, 2026 4:39 am
MikeNovack wrote: ↑Tue Nov 17, 2026 2:20 am
No IC, because evidence (real evidence) can be produced that (biological) evolution works NOW,
Actually, the opposite is true: there's no demonstration of evolutionary change "working now." That is precisely why proponents insist on long time-frames; to explain why they can't produce such evidence. They need millions of years, and extreme gradualism, so that the theory looks plausible at all.
There is evidence of evolution working now. This is perfectly easy to demonstrate and it does not take millions of years. A common organism used for such demonstrations is a species from the genus Drosophila because the life cycle of fruit flies is short. Easy to have a generation per month.
Yes, I know about these attempts to make a proof. But I'll point out the obvious problem, after you explain.
It will not be many generations (not much time at one per month) before you would observe that the population is now mostly type B. It has "evolved".
You're blending two conceptions of "evolution" without noting the difference.
Intraspecies "evolution" -- is really no more than biological adaptation within a single species. As such, it's not genuinely "evolution" at all, but merely change of a superficial sort. The species continues to have all the essential features of its own kind, and remains interfertile with its own kind, and does not transition species.
I can provide you with an even more graphic example: dogs. No creature on earth has been bred more intensively and deliberately to produce distinctive dog features. From the massive Newfoundland to the tiny chihuahua, dogs have been developed in an intraspecies way to the point where some breeds hardly resemble others at all. Yet they all remain interfertile, and all remain dogs.
But then there's this:
Interspecies evolution -- and this is quite a different thing. This theory holds that it should not only be possible for generations of fruit flies to be bred into different configurations of fruit flies, but that fruit flies, if bred rigorously, should be able to turn into birds, or fish, or men, or some other species -- no longer genetically the same, no longer interfertile with its base species, and completely different, when evolution is complete.
Which one is it that Evolutionism requires? Can Evolutionism be demonstrated on an intraspecies basis, when no substantive change in species is involved? Or does the Theory of Evolutionism ask us to believe that fish can become frogs, frogs can become monkeys, and monkeys can become men?
Which sort is it? One can be done in a lab, and even sometimes happens outside the lab. The other has never been done anywhere, by any number of generations of fruit flies, or dogs, or anything.
Your claim "no complete fossil record for the evolution of any organism" is true.
Thank you. Yes, it's true. But it's less than I actually said, though it's in quotes. I said the record as a whole is so incomplete as to be rife with "missing links." The fossil record does not reveal at all what the Evolutionist should expect, given gradualism -- namely, thousands or even millions of transitional forms, each one only minutely different from the last, for every single "modern" species we have.
THAT, we definitely don't find.
But there are intervals of fossil records showing THAT part of the record. So you would be arguing "works now, and worked during intervals in the past, but somehow stopped working during other intervals".
No, I'd merely be reciting the attempted rescue-strategy some Evolutionists have used. But the truth is that the fossil record is SO spotty that I don't argue it counts for any evidence of Evolutionism, whether graduated or punctuated.
Now about those pink, tutu wearing unicorns.
Let's send them dancing. They're silly. I have no need to respond to such obvious r
eductios as that, beyond the response I've already given.
Then stop demanding the atheist provide evidence for "no gods exist".
To do so would be to stop being scientific. For it is a basic scientific axiom that that which should be believed, at least within the confines of the subjects science can address, must be accompanied by evidence, logic or proof.
So what we are saying is this: that the Atheist pretence to be "scientific" or "rational" is unsubstantiated by any evidence at all. And if we realize that, I have no further objection, until the point when the Atheist begins to recommend his disbelief to others, or to evangelize for it; at which point, he surely owes his listeners some reason to believe him. And since he has none, we are left with a simple question: why should we believe the Atheist knows anything at all about the subject, and why should we listen to him?