daniel j lavender wrote: ↑Sun Apr 06, 2025 3:33 am
Age wrote: ↑Sat Apr 05, 2025 11:57 pm
daniel j lavender wrote: ↑Sat Apr 05, 2025 7:02 am
However I am not attributing a reason or a why to existence retroactively.
Because you do not yet know THE REASON NOR THE WHY.
As expressed existence itself has no reason or why. Those are complexities concerning conscious beings and particular things.
ONCE AGAIN, 'this' is your OWN UNDERSTANDING, and your OWN MEANING, which 'you' ARE PLACING ON 'things', here.
And, if by your OWN so-called 'logic', 'things' on their own do NOT have 'reason' nor 'why', then 'your reason', here, is NOTHING MORE than 'your OWN personal reason and/or CLAIM'.
Just because you 'reasoned out' that Existence, Itself, has NO 'reason' NOR 'why', based on NOTHING MORE than your OWN 'past experiences' where you NEVER LEARNED, UNDERSTOOD, NOR KNEW the REASON WHY Existence, Itself, IS HERE-NOW.
And, WHEN, and IF, you EVER DO LEARN, then 'you' WILL ALSO UNDERSTAND and KNOW the REASON WHY.
ONCE AGAIN, just because these people's BELIEFS, which are based upon their OWN VERY TINY and LITTLE 'experiences', IN Life/Existence, NEVER EVER MEANS that what they BELIEVE is even remotely CLOSE to the ACTUAL and IRREFUTABLE Truth of things.
daniel j lavender wrote: ↑Sun Apr 06, 2025 3:33 am
Reason is an aspect of existence, not a cause of existence or something beyond existence.
Is 'this' what you have 'reasoned out', TO "yourself", FULLY?
daniel j lavender wrote: ↑Sun Apr 06, 2025 3:33 am
Reason could not cause or initiate existence when reason itself is existence.
What you are 'TRYING TO' SAY and CLAIM, here, is some thing like, 'reason', itself, could NOT cause nor initiate 'the sun', which OBVIOUSLY EXISTED BEFORE you human beings did. Therefore, the 'reason' FOR or WHY the sun exists can NOT be FOUND, nor GIVEN, by you human beings. Which is OBVIOUSLY ABSOLUTELY ABSURD, RIDICULOUS, ILLOGICAL, and UNREASONABLE.
daniel j lavender wrote: ↑Sun Apr 06, 2025 3:33 am
To reiterate there is no reason or why for existence.
LOL
LOL
LOL
'I' ALREADY KNOW what the REASON and the WHY FOR 'Existence', Itself.
AND, if 'you' EVER COME TO ALSO KNOW thy 'Self', then 'you' WILL ALSO UNDERSTAND and KNOW the REASON WHY Existence, Itself, EXISTS.
Can you YET COMPREHEND and UNDERSTAND that 'I' AM SAYING that 'I' ALREADY KNOW the REASON WHY FOR Existence, which 'you' BELIEVE and CLAIM there is NO reason NOR why for Existence?
daniel j lavender wrote: ↑Sun Apr 06, 2025 3:33 am
Existence simply is. Reason and why concern conscious beings and particular or specific things.[/quote
You claim I “do not yet know the reason nor the why”.
OF COURSE 'this' is WHAT I CLAIM. you are 'the one' who SAYS and STATES that 'you do not yet know the reason nor the way', correct?
daniel j lavender wrote: ↑Sun Apr 06, 2025 3:33 am
I’m interested to know what you think those are.
I WILL, AGAIN, SUGGEST that when and if ANY one REALLY HAS INTEREST IN KNOWING ANY thing, here, then JUST ASK 'the question' in regards to what 'it' IS, EXACTLY, that you WANT TO KNOW.
Now, if you really are 'interested in knowing' what I SAY and CLAIM is 'the REASON WHY' Existence, Itself, EXISTS, then JUST ASK.
But, instead of WAITING FOR 'you' 'I' WILL, AGAIN, say what is the REASON WHY Existence, Itself, TO me.
The REASON Existence, Itself, exists is so that 'I' can BEAR WITNESS TO the beauty that 'I' AM Creating, HERE-NOW.
daniel j lavender wrote: ↑Sun Apr 06, 2025 3:33 am
Age wrote: ↑Sat Apr 05, 2025 11:57 pm
daniel j lavender wrote: ↑Sat Apr 05, 2025 7:02 am
Provide examples of “reason” and “why” which do not involve conscious beings or particulars. Then your statement may have merit.
AGAIN, your two sentences and CLAIMS, here, do NOT make ACTUAL SENSE.
This could easily be interpreted as an attempt to evade my request for examples.
YES, OBVIOUSLY it COULD. But, it was NOT an attempt to evade your request for examples.
OBVIOUSLY it is an ABSOLUTE IMPOSSIBILITY to provide examples of 'reason' or 'why' for absolutely ANY thing, which does not involve conscious human beings.
ONLY conscious human beings can 'make up' reasons or whys, and only conscious human beings can express and receive reasons and whys. So, again, it is IMPOSSIBLE to provide examples of 'reason' and 'why', which do not involve conscious human beings. So, it does NOT MAKE ACTUAL SENSE to ASK FOR examples that could NEVER be provided.
To you maybe. But, to me, asking for examples of what can NOT be given does NOT make ACTUAL SENSE.
daniel j lavender wrote: ↑Sun Apr 06, 2025 3:33 am
You seem to claim existence itself has or had some reason for being. I’m asking that you provide an example of such reason not involving conscious beings or particular things to illustrate such reason for existence itself. Illustrate your point.
LOL ONCE MORE NO one can PROVIDE you of what you are ASKING FOR, here, BECAUSE it is, OBVIOUSLY, an IMPOSSIBILITY.
you are CONFLATED TWO DIFFERENT things, and then 'TRYING TO' CLAIM that because one can NOT BE DONE, therefore, the other does EXIST.