Page 36 of 41
Re: What is morality?
Posted: Sun Nov 15, 2026 11:33 pm
by FlashDangerpants
MikeNovack wrote: ↑Sun Nov 15, 2026 1:57 pm
FlashDangerpants wrote: ↑Sun Nov 15, 2026 12:12 am
MikeNovack wrote: ↑Sat Nov 14, 2026 11:38 pm
How do you know wrong to shit on the floor?
My mommy taught me that was wrong when I was very little.
How did she know wrong to shit on the floor?
Her mommy taught her that it was wrong when she was very little.
How did grandma know it was wrong to shit on the floor?
.........
Are you arguing that at any point the knowledge "wrong to shit on the floor" was for a pragmatic reason?
What other reason do you have to offer?
Is Grandma's word on the matter equivalent to a divine command?
Or is it your claim that the only reason you aren't shitting on your floor right this minute is mere obedience to a custom?
You really don't get it. I am arguing against "morality comes from commands of some Great Pink Unicorn".
I can't for the life of me imagine a why you'd think I need telling that. The sarcastic subtext in what I wrote wasn't something subtly hidden. Even the worst American should not respond to it the way you are. Do I need to write differently to help you to comprehend? To be explicit, I am asking here if you are autistic and do I need to write in a way that would help an autist to follow the reasoning?
Or is the problem here that you aren't autistic, just the clumsiest reader in the world?
MikeNovack wrote: ↑Sun Nov 15, 2026 1:57 pm
You really don't understand evolution (as it would apply to cultures). OF COURSE there had to have been a real benefit gradient. But "pragmatic" means knowing of and consciously choosing to change in the direction of this gradient.
I don't need lecturing about evolution. Pragmatic doesn't particularly mean that.
If you chose to poop in your potty because your parents give you rewards for that, that choice was pragmatic. In Kantian terms it was a hypothetical imperative, a Goal Derived Ought, an instrumental reason for action, or a matter of prudential concern. There are so many phrases to describe this sort of thing because it has been considered millions of times already and you are not presenting some new thing we've never thought about here.
MikeNovack wrote: ↑Sun Nov 15, 2026 1:57 pm
And no, I deny that you are simply "following custom", choosing to follow or disobey. I am saying that the way you learned/were taught instilled a FEELING "wrong to do that".
That renders morality into a mere Pavlovian response. That is worse than just an arbitrary convention. You can't call this 'feeling' a knowing, that's insane. You are on the verge of arguing that morality not only doesn't exist but also isn't worth worrying about.
MikeNovack wrote: ↑Sun Nov 15, 2026 1:57 pm
But let me propose something to those of you who insist "divine command" ------ if you choose to obey this the dictates of this Great Pink Unicorn because if you do will be rewarded with some heaven and if not punished by banishment to some hell is that decision moral or pragmatic?
Do you remember me telling you I am an atheist? Obviously I don't believe in DC. When I raised the issue it was to point out that you had no foundation for your morals all the way down theory. It seems you weren't able to pick up on that for some reason.
IC isn't a divine command theorist either. At least in his own mind he isn't. I consider him a total moron who just can't tell that his attempt to get out of DC theory is a complete self-defeating failure, but I explained that to him a couple of weeks ago and he lost his shit instantly.
So who is the divine command theorist you would address that challenge towards? I can tell you that they will all answer "both".
MikeNovack wrote: ↑Sun Nov 15, 2026 1:57 pm
PS --- Another reason I introduced "behaviors related to shitting" is that I could derive as divine command (I know the Biblical command I would use as my starting point). I am surprised that none who argue "commands from some Great Pink Unicorn" have not done so.
Sorry, that passage is irredeemably disjointed. I can't decipher any sort of meaning from it.
Re: What is morality?
Posted: Sun Nov 15, 2026 11:46 pm
by MikeNovack
Maybe this would go better if we discussed morality in the terms some of the others think correct. And see what might be wrong.
Here, in this corner of the room are people of culture A who believe there is a Great Pink Unicorn who defined what is right and what is wrong. Who created morality. These people believe in morality, they feel "wrong" when they do not act rightly.
There, in that corner of the room are people of culture B who believe there is a Great Orange Unicorn who defined what is right and what is wrong. Who created morality. These people believe in morality, they feel "wrong" when they do not act rightly.
There, in the third corner of the room are people of culture C who believe there is a Great Purple Wombat who defined what is right and what is wrong. Who created morality. These people believe in morality, they feel "wrong" when they do not act rightly.
And in the fourth corner we have people of culture D, atheists, who believe neither unicorns of any color not purple wombats exist. They too seem to have belief in morality and feel "wrong" when they do not act rightly.
Now I am going to say we can ignore the idea that one of these three, the Pink Unicorn, the Orange unicorn, the Purple Wombat is the one true God and the others false gods. Why do I say can be ignored? Because let's say it's the Pink Unicorn that is the true God. It explains why the people of A have morality, this access to objective morality. But it doesn't explain the people of B and C believing in morality, feeling "wrong" when they do not do right, etc. You can argue all you want that theirs is a false morality BUT WHERE DID IT COME FROM? There will almost certainly be some differences in what is right and what is wrong comparing the moralities of A, B, and C but you would find the amount of agreement rather great.
Does that make sense? That belief in a false god, non-existent and so unable to be a basis of objective morality, could nevertheless more than half the time lead to correspondence with the moral dictates of the true God. The people of B and C are getting their moral judgements SOMEWHERE, but we know can't be "from belief in the one true God". Same is true for the people of culture D who believe in no gods (that does NOT mean necessarily secularists).
I would say, finding no cultures without morality, regardless of what gods they believe in or not, means can not be coming from belief in the one true God. If you argue the others are just acting prudently, etc. well then it becomes irrelevant to consider A also getting from somewhere else (this one true god) because just as prudential for them.
Re: What is morality?
Posted: Sun Nov 15, 2026 11:57 pm
by FlashDangerpants
MikeNovack wrote: ↑Sun Nov 15, 2026 11:46 pm
Maybe this would go better if we discussed morality in the terms some of the others think correct.
Did the rest of that post count as an effort to do the thing quoted here?
Re: What is morality?
Posted: Mon Nov 16, 2026 12:00 am
by FlashDangerpants
MikeNovack wrote: ↑Sun May 24, 2026 4:24 pm
Morality is KNOWING in a specific situation what is the "right" choice of action and what the "wrong" choice of action.
Thread title:
What is morality?
Initial answer provided:
Morality is KNOWING in a specific situation what is the "right" choice
Whatever this unicorns thing is supposed to be about. Does it work to help just the suggestion that
Morality is KNOWING in a specific situation what is the "right" choice of action and what the "wrong" choice of action. ... or does it suggest that you should abandon that?
Re: What is morality?
Posted: Mon Nov 16, 2026 3:15 pm
by Will Bouwman
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Fri Nov 13, 2026 7:31 pm
Will Bouwman wrote: ↑Fri Nov 13, 2026 3:11 pm
'Atheism' does not have its own implications...
Oh, it certainly does. To banish everything that is not "materials" or "nature" is bound to have consequences.
That is you saddling your version of 'Atheism' with physicalism. Neither 'I don't believe in any god', nor 'I believe there are no gods' imply anything more.
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Thu Nov 12, 2026 4:33 pmThere's no evidence that the human brain ever "evolved."
That is one example that demonstrates why, in my view, it is unwise to invest too much in any given belief. It is one thing to look at the evidence that the human brain evolved and interpret it so that it fits an alternative narrative, but to insist the evidence doesn't exist is batshit fanaticism.
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Fri Nov 13, 2026 7:31 pmIf you would think others
ought to believe it, and not just be confessing your own view, then you've become an
Atheist, and not merely privately
atheistic.
So now you lumber your 'Atheist' with evangelism.
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Fri Nov 13, 2026 7:31 pmBut then, another question arises: on what basis do you suppose others "ought" to believe your Atheism?
Mr Can I do not think you ought to be an atheist, I think instead you ought to have a more compelling hypothesis to account for the evidence of evolution other than 'It does not exist.'
Re: What is morality?
Posted: Mon Nov 16, 2026 4:11 pm
by Immanuel Can
Will Bouwman wrote: ↑Mon Nov 16, 2026 3:15 pm
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Fri Nov 13, 2026 7:31 pm
Will Bouwman wrote: ↑Fri Nov 13, 2026 3:11 pm
'Atheism' does not have its own implications...
Oh, it certainly does. To banish everything that is not "materials" or "nature" is bound to have consequences.
That is you saddling your version of 'Atheism' with physicalism.
Atheism "saddles" itself with some sort of Naturalism, Physicalism or Materialism. It has no logical alternative, because to choose any metaphysics would mean that the no-gods hypothesis would be undermined.
...to insist the evidence doesn't exist is batshit fanaticism.
This is my objection to Atheism. There's plenty of evidence for the existence of God, such that the hypothesis that no God exists is simply absurd. One could argue, "I don't accept the evidence," or even "I don't find the evidence compelling of my belief." That would be fine. But to say that God does NOT exist, and to add, as many Atheists do, that no evidence exists for His existence, is, as you put it "batshit fanaticism."
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Fri Nov 13, 2026 7:31 pmIf you would think others
ought to believe it, and not just be confessing your own view, then you've become an
Atheist, and not merely privately
atheistic.
So now you lumber your 'Atheist' with evangelism.
Not at all. I merely ask the Atheist what he wants to do -- to preach only to himself, or recommend to others.
If you want to keep your Atheism 100% private, then you can, and you're not evangelizing for it. But if you recommend it to others, then you've crossed that line yourself. The choice is being made by the Atheist, not by me.
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Fri Nov 13, 2026 7:31 pmBut then, another question arises: on what basis do you suppose others "ought" to believe your Atheism?
Mr Can I do not think you ought to be an atheist,... I
Then you are not an evangelist for it. I still think your belief is nonsense, but you're perfectly free to hold it. I'd never take your option to choose away from you.
As for evidence against Evolutionism, the burden of proof is on the Evolutionist. But certainly the red shift effect, the laws of entropy, and things like triadic symbiosis, to say nothing of the lack of a credible continuum of fossils should count as just that sort of evidence. And much more can be produced, too. But the Evolutionist is likely to ignore that evidence, and pretend it doesn't exist.
"Batshit fanaticism"? Maybe. Or maybe just unwillingness to look.
Re: What is morality?
Posted: Mon Nov 16, 2026 5:33 pm
by MikeNovack
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Mon Nov 16, 2026 4:11 pm
Atheism "saddles" itself with some sort of Naturalism, Physicalism or Materialism. It has no logical alternative, because to choose any metaphysics would mean that the no-gods hypothesis would be undermined.
This is my objection to Atheism. There's plenty of evidence for the existence of God, such that the hypothesis that no God exists is simply absurd. One could argue, "I don't accept the evidence," or even "I don't find the evidence compelling of my belief." That would be fine. But to say that God does NOT exist, and to add, as many Atheists do, that no evidence exists for His existence, is, as you put it "batshit fanaticism."
As for evidence against Evolutionism, the burden of proof is on the Evolutionist. But certainly the red shift effect, the laws of entropy, and things like triadic symbiosis, to say nothing of the lack of a credible continuum of fossils should count as just that sort of evidence. And much more can be produced, too. But the Evolutionist is likely to ignore that evidence, and pretend it doesn't exist.
A) I will repeat, the atheist need not be materialist. Metaphysics that includes the sacred, holy, divine does not necessarily include gods. You could of course be clearer about what you mean by answering the simple question "Does Spinoza's One Substance qualify as God"
Yes, the atheist cannot produce evidence to disprove the existence of a god. It is normally difficult/impossible to prove non-existence. But if you are talking to an atheist stop saying "I have evidence for the existence of God" because you don't. The issue here is that you and the atheist disagree on what "evidence" is.
And no, the burden of proof is not on the evolutionist in the way you mean. EVOLUTION (in its general sense) is easy to prove, including by experiment. But at that level we are usually talking about "systems" in general. Of course, can use biological entities as the components of the system. Instead of 100 white beads and 100 red beads could be plants of the same species, those that flower white and those that flower red.
<< Historical fact: Mendel's results were better than they should have been (too exact given the size of his plant population) because his lay gardeners knew what was expected and made it so >>
What you mean is "just because we could demonstrate evolution using systems with biological individuals as components of the system is NOT directly evidence this is what shaped the species we see now". But IC, the "gaps in the fossil record don't matter now. If the record good enough to show worked (the species altered) 10 million years ago to 7 million years ago and then (after a gap in the fossil record) from 5 million years ago to 3 million years ago and (after another gap in the record) from 2 million years ago to now the burden of proof has shifted to you to explain why the laws of the natural world differed 7 million years ago to 5 million years ago and again 3 million years ago to 2 million years ago (the gaps). Especially since this law change would be species by species (the gaps in the record for one not the same time as the gaps for another)
Look --- I don't care if you don't believe in evolution but deny you can use that personal belief in argument with another who is basing something on evolution.
Re: What is morality?
Posted: Mon Nov 16, 2026 7:08 pm
by Immanuel Can
MikeNovack wrote: ↑Mon Nov 16, 2026 5:33 pm
A) I will repeat, the atheist need not be materialist. Metaphysics that includes the sacred, holy, divine does not necessarily include gods.
But it opens up the field to the possibility of God, which for the Atheist, is just as fatal. All it does is ADD
possible metaphysical entities, but removes any grounds for supposing one has
eliminated any.
Atheism requires that there are, and are known to be, no Gods. If it
cannot be known, then one is an agnostic, at the most.
Yes, the atheist cannot produce evidence to disprove the existence of a god.
That is what makes Atheism itself non-evidentiary, non-scientific, and inconclusive. In other words, it boils down to the claim, "I want to disbelieve there are any gods." And that's all.
Re: What is morality?
Posted: Mon Nov 16, 2026 7:40 pm
by MikeNovack
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Mon Nov 16, 2026 7:08 pm
Yes, the atheist cannot produce evidence to disprove the existence of a god.
That is what makes Atheism itself non-evidentiary, non-scientific, and inconclusive. In other words, it boils down to the claim, "I want to disbelieve there are any gods." And that's all.
It is impossible to prove non-existence of the non-material in the sense you mean. You can do things like prove thee is no integer between 2 and 3 (neither of which are material)
That is not reason to claim the atheist does not have good reason to disbelieve. Your claim that he/she does not is equivalent t claiming the atheist has no good reason to disbelieve in Seven Purple Uncorns wearing tutus. Why do YOU disbelieve in the Seven Purple Unicorns wearing tutus? Are you "agnostic" about their existence?
Re: What is morality?
Posted: Mon Nov 16, 2026 7:45 pm
by Immanuel Can
MikeNovack wrote: ↑Mon Nov 16, 2026 7:40 pm
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Mon Nov 16, 2026 7:08 pm
Yes, the atheist cannot produce evidence to disprove the existence of a god.
That is what makes Atheism itself non-evidentiary, non-scientific, and inconclusive. In other words, it boils down to the claim, "I want to disbelieve there are any gods." And that's all.
It is impossible to prove non-existence of the non-material in the sense you mean.
"..in the sense THEY mean," you mean. It's
they who are claiming it. I wouldn't.
Why are the evangelically-inclined Atheists going around telling other people that there are no Gods, when in fact, they have no proof, no evidence, no possibility, even, of demonstrating this "non-existence"? If they were honest at all, they'd just be saying, "I don't like the idea of there being a God." And if that were it, that's fine...their choice, their problem.
That is not reason to claim the atheist does not have good reason to disbelieve.
You mean, the fact that they have no proof, no evidence and no logical possibility of having such, is not a good reason to say they don't have good reason?
Yes, yes, it's the BEST reason to say that.

Re: What is morality?
Posted: Tue Nov 17, 2026 1:35 am
by MikeNovack
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Mon Nov 16, 2026 7:45 pm
That is not reason to claim the atheist does not have good reason to disbelieve.
You mean, the fact that they have no proof, no evidence and no logical possibility of having such, is not a good reason to say they don't have good reason?
Yes, yes, it's the BEST reason to say that.

[/quote]
Then are you saying that they have no proof that pink unicorns wearing tutus do not exist in some non-material realm they should not say that they don't. They would argue, there are countless preposterous thing that I do not believe exist (in some non-material realm) even though unable to produce evidence of non-existence.
Do YOU disbelieve in the existence of pink unicorns wearing tutus in some non-material realm? If so, WHY?
They are treating the God you believe exists exactly the same a pink tutu wearing unicorns. Equally preposterous.
Re: What is morality?
Posted: Tue Nov 17, 2026 1:52 am
by Immanuel Can
MikeNovack wrote: ↑Tue Nov 17, 2026 1:35 am
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Mon Nov 16, 2026 7:45 pm
That is not reason to claim the atheist does not have good reason to disbelieve.
You mean, the fact that they have no proof, no evidence and no logical possibility of having such, is not a good reason to say they don't have good reason?
Yes, yes, it's the BEST reason to say that.
Then are you saying that they have no proof that pink unicorns wearing tutus...
It's a silly example, but I'll ignore the obvious attempt at
reductio.
The existence of "pink unicorns wearing tutus," or their non-existence in a given place would be rather easy to prove. They would be physical, finite entities. And, on the other side, there would have to be evidence for their existence...which there is not.
But what is the required test for "no gods"? God is said to be infinite, unbounded, transcendent, timeless, omnipresent...?
And there is evidence for God's existence, too, including this world, mathematics, science, rationality and your own self. For your unicorns, there is none.
You call that comparable? Then you haven't thought very much about it.
Re: What is morality?
Posted: Tue Nov 17, 2026 2:20 am
by MikeNovack
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Mon Nov 16, 2026 4:11 pm
As for evidence against Evolutionism, the burden of proof is on the Evolutionist.
"Batshit fanaticism"? Maybe. Or maybe just unwillingness to look.
No IC, because evidence (real evidence) can be produced that (biological) evolution works NOW, will cause change in a species, the burden is actually the other way.
The anti-evolutionist has to explain why holds the belief, sure, it works now (I can see the results with short life cycle organisms like those of the Drosophila genus (easy to run one generation per month) but it didn't work back then. It worked during the intervals for which we have a fossil record but didn't work in the gaps.
Re: What is morality?
Posted: Tue Nov 17, 2026 4:39 am
by Immanuel Can
MikeNovack wrote: ↑Tue Nov 17, 2026 2:20 am
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Mon Nov 16, 2026 4:11 pm
"Batshit fanaticism"? Maybe. Or maybe just unwillingness to look.
No IC, because evidence (real evidence) can be produced that (biological) evolution works NOW,
Actually, the opposite is true: there's no demonstration of evolutionary change "working now." That is precisely why proponents insist on long time-frames; to explain why they can't produce such evidence. They need millions of years, and extreme gradualism, so that the theory looks plausible at all.
But the "batshit fanaticism" on the Atheist side is this: no evidence, no proof, and (according to you, as well) no ability to confirm the non-existence that forms their sole firm claim, posed against all the visible evidence of intelligent creation.
So even with refusing all the evidence for intelligent design, the Atheist still has nothing for his own side.
But from an Atheist perspective, all of this is moot anyway. However this earth was created, he's got nothing with regard to explaining or grounding morality. And it's so easy to prove that, you can't miss it. Just ask yourself:
what is one moral standard that every Atheist is obligated to meet? You can think for a thousand years, and never find a moral injunction that Atheism can ground. Atheism is a moral eunuch.
Re: What is morality?
Posted: Tue Nov 17, 2026 7:47 am
by promethean75
"Actually, the opposite is true: there's no demonstration of evolutionary change "working now."
On the contrary, every time one of your cells uses damaged DNA as instructions for copying itself, evolution is happening. In fact, before you are done reading this, evolution will have happened hundreds of millions of times in your own body.
Neat, eh?
(p.s. stop trying to save god, Mannie. You look silly.)