I can't for the life of me imagine a why you'd think I need telling that. The sarcastic subtext in what I wrote wasn't something subtly hidden. Even the worst American should not respond to it the way you are. Do I need to write differently to help you to comprehend? To be explicit, I am asking here if you are autistic and do I need to write in a way that would help an autist to follow the reasoning?MikeNovack wrote: ↑Sun Nov 15, 2026 1:57 pmYou really don't get it. I am arguing against "morality comes from commands of some Great Pink Unicorn".FlashDangerpants wrote: ↑Sun Nov 15, 2026 12:12 amWhat other reason do you have to offer?MikeNovack wrote: ↑Sat Nov 14, 2026 11:38 pm How do you know wrong to shit on the floor?
My mommy taught me that was wrong when I was very little.
How did she know wrong to shit on the floor?
Her mommy taught her that it was wrong when she was very little.
How did grandma know it was wrong to shit on the floor?
.........
Are you arguing that at any point the knowledge "wrong to shit on the floor" was for a pragmatic reason?
Is Grandma's word on the matter equivalent to a divine command?
Or is it your claim that the only reason you aren't shitting on your floor right this minute is mere obedience to a custom?
Or is the problem here that you aren't autistic, just the clumsiest reader in the world?
I don't need lecturing about evolution. Pragmatic doesn't particularly mean that.MikeNovack wrote: ↑Sun Nov 15, 2026 1:57 pm You really don't understand evolution (as it would apply to cultures). OF COURSE there had to have been a real benefit gradient. But "pragmatic" means knowing of and consciously choosing to change in the direction of this gradient.
If you chose to poop in your potty because your parents give you rewards for that, that choice was pragmatic. In Kantian terms it was a hypothetical imperative, a Goal Derived Ought, an instrumental reason for action, or a matter of prudential concern. There are so many phrases to describe this sort of thing because it has been considered millions of times already and you are not presenting some new thing we've never thought about here.
That renders morality into a mere Pavlovian response. That is worse than just an arbitrary convention. You can't call this 'feeling' a knowing, that's insane. You are on the verge of arguing that morality not only doesn't exist but also isn't worth worrying about.MikeNovack wrote: ↑Sun Nov 15, 2026 1:57 pm And no, I deny that you are simply "following custom", choosing to follow or disobey. I am saying that the way you learned/were taught instilled a FEELING "wrong to do that".
Do you remember me telling you I am an atheist? Obviously I don't believe in DC. When I raised the issue it was to point out that you had no foundation for your morals all the way down theory. It seems you weren't able to pick up on that for some reason.MikeNovack wrote: ↑Sun Nov 15, 2026 1:57 pm But let me propose something to those of you who insist "divine command" ------ if you choose to obey this the dictates of this Great Pink Unicorn because if you do will be rewarded with some heaven and if not punished by banishment to some hell is that decision moral or pragmatic?
IC isn't a divine command theorist either. At least in his own mind he isn't. I consider him a total moron who just can't tell that his attempt to get out of DC theory is a complete self-defeating failure, but I explained that to him a couple of weeks ago and he lost his shit instantly.
So who is the divine command theorist you would address that challenge towards? I can tell you that they will all answer "both".
Sorry, that passage is irredeemably disjointed. I can't decipher any sort of meaning from it.MikeNovack wrote: ↑Sun Nov 15, 2026 1:57 pm PS --- Another reason I introduced "behaviors related to shitting" is that I could derive as divine command (I know the Biblical command I would use as my starting point). I am surprised that none who argue "commands from some Great Pink Unicorn" have not done so.