What is morality?

Should you think about your duty, or about the consequences of your actions? Or should you concentrate on becoming a good person?

Moderators: AMod, iMod

MikeNovack
Posts: 1453
Joined: Fri Jul 11, 2025 1:17 pm

Re: What is morality?

Post by MikeNovack »

Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Tue Nov 10, 2026 3:01 pmIs your claim of Atheism a claim made for yourself, or a recommendation for others as well?
I do not understand your persistence with that question. While there are SOME Atheists who are militant proponents of their disbelief in gods MOST don't give a damn abut religious believers provided they keep out of the atheist's way. And if they are in the way, trying to ram their religion down the throats of the atheists, it isn't a matter of the atheists trying to convince the believers but force.

Understand? Were I speaking as an atheist I'd tell you I don't care what stupid nonsense you believe in. I see no point wasting my time correcting your stupidity. Just don't try to ram your superstitious nonsense down my throat.
User avatar
Immanuel Can
Posts: 30600
Joined: Wed Sep 25, 2013 4:42 pm

Re: What is morality?

Post by Immanuel Can »

phyllo wrote: ↑Wed Nov 11, 2026 1:26 pm You ask for a reason for a secularist's "moral obligation". I say it's conscience.
How do you know that a secularist has a moral duty to obey his conscience? Where is that written? Who declared it? What happens if he chooses not to? What about when his conscience is wrong?
User avatar
Immanuel Can
Posts: 30600
Joined: Wed Sep 25, 2013 4:42 pm

Re: What is morality?

Post by Immanuel Can »

Will Bouwman wrote: ↑Wed Nov 11, 2026 1:54 pm What you don't seem to grasp is that in my world, there is no such thing as capitalised 'Atheism'
"In your world." Yes, quite.

There is such a thing. It's a one-statement ideology, in fact.
When I say I am an atheist, I mean only that I do not believe in any god.
Are you recommending that to anybody else, or just making a claim for yourself?

Why won't you answer that question?
User avatar
Immanuel Can
Posts: 30600
Joined: Wed Sep 25, 2013 4:42 pm

Re: What is morality?

Post by Immanuel Can »

MikeNovack wrote: ↑Wed Nov 11, 2026 3:50 pm While there are SOME Atheists who are militant proponents of their disbelief in gods MOST don't give a damn abut religious believers provided they keep out of the atheist's way.
You've never heard of Dawkins, or Hitchens, or Harris, or Dennett, or Nietzsche, or Hume, or Freud, or Russell, or...? I would say that a great many Atheists are quite strident evangelists for their bad faith. But if you don't care, then don't bother to tell anybody IF you're ever inclined to become an Atheist...it has nothing to do with them, according to you. So keep it to yourself, I guess...unless you also want to evangelize for it... :?
MikeNovack
Posts: 1453
Joined: Fri Jul 11, 2025 1:17 pm

Re: What is morality?

Post by MikeNovack »

Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Wed Nov 11, 2026 11:12 pm
You've never heard of Dawkins, or Hitchens, or Harris, or Dennett, or Nietzsche, or Hume, or Freud, or Russell, or...? I would say that a great many Atheists are quite strident evangelists for their bad faith. But if you don't care, then don't bother to tell anybody IF you're ever inclined to become an Atheist...it has nothing to do with them, according to you. So keep it to yourself, I guess...unless you also want to evangelize for it... :?
Prominent writers and philosophers arguing for atheism -- are you suggesting that THEY are not giving reasons? But Freud is NOT considering religion useless (even if gods not real) and Russell was not anti woo-woo (even though you discount "religion" without what YOU call God) -- if you make that the criteria, Buddhists might be considered "atheist".
Will Bouwman
Posts: 1645
Joined: Sun Sep 04, 2022 2:17 pm

Re: What is morality?

Post by Will Bouwman »

Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Wed Nov 11, 2026 11:06 pm
Will Bouwman wrote: ↑Wed Nov 11, 2026 1:54 pm What you don't seem to grasp is that in my world, there is no such thing as capitalised 'Atheism'
"In your world." Yes, quite.

There is such a thing. It's a one-statement ideology, in fact.
Well, you can broadly identify ideologies by one statement, but only in your creationist/Christian apologetics bubble could that constitute an entire ideology.
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Wed Nov 11, 2026 11:06 pm
Will Bouwman wrote: ↑Wed Nov 11, 2026 1:54 pmWhen I say I am an atheist, I mean only that I do not believe in any god.
Are you recommending that to anybody else, or just making a claim for yourself?

Why won't you answer that question?
Does it relate to atheism or Atheism?
User avatar
phyllo
Posts: 3425
Joined: Sun Oct 27, 2013 5:58 pm
Location: Victory in Ukraine

Re: What is morality?

Post by phyllo »

Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Wed Nov 11, 2026 11:03 pm
phyllo wrote: ↑Wed Nov 11, 2026 1:26 pm You ask for a reason for a secularist's "moral obligation". I say it's conscience.
How do you know that a secularist has a moral duty to obey his conscience? Where is that written? Who declared it? What happens if he chooses not to? What about when his conscience is wrong?
Oh I see that you are answering my questions ("I say it's conscience. Do you have a reason why that is not a valid reason? What would be a valid reason? ") by asking me a bunch of questions.

Well, if a person does not obey their conscience then their conscience keeps bugging them. They feel guilty.

This does not have to be written down or declared. Conscience is internal.

If their conscience is wrong then they do wrong things. But that happens in any moral system if the morals of the system are wrong and people do what is prescribed.
User avatar
Immanuel Can
Posts: 30600
Joined: Wed Sep 25, 2013 4:42 pm

Re: What is morality?

Post by Immanuel Can »

MikeNovack wrote: ↑Thu Nov 12, 2026 12:54 am
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Wed Nov 11, 2026 11:12 pm
You've never heard of Dawkins, or Hitchens, or Harris, or Dennett, or Nietzsche, or Hume, or Freud, or Russell, or...? I would say that a great many Atheists are quite strident evangelists for their bad faith. But if you don't care, then don't bother to tell anybody IF you're ever inclined to become an Atheist...it has nothing to do with them, according to you. So keep it to yourself, I guess...unless you also want to evangelize for it... :?
Prominent writers and philosophers arguing for atheism -- are you suggesting that THEY are not giving reasons?
Not at all. But reasons are not all equal. Some are better reasons than other reasons. And what I'm advocating is that we not believe anybody --Atheist or Theist -- merely because he/she gives "reasons." Rather, I advocate a vigorous contesting of the quality of the reasons offered, in order to isolate the best reasons, and then believe what we believe for the best reasons available.

Is there anything more common-sensical than that?
User avatar
Immanuel Can
Posts: 30600
Joined: Wed Sep 25, 2013 4:42 pm

Re: What is morality?

Post by Immanuel Can »

Will Bouwman wrote: ↑Thu Nov 12, 2026 11:15 am
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Wed Nov 11, 2026 11:06 pm
Will Bouwman wrote: ↑Wed Nov 11, 2026 1:54 pm What you don't seem to grasp is that in my world, there is no such thing as capitalised 'Atheism'
"In your world." Yes, quite.

There is such a thing. It's a one-statement ideology, in fact.
Well, you can broadly identify ideologies by one statement, but only in your creationist/Christian apologetics bubble could that constitute an entire ideology.
Not so. For though it is thin and negative, it's not without it's own very, very sweeping implications.

If Atheism were true, then an awful lot of beliefs would have to be set aside as fictional -- and not merely Christian ones, but ones of every other metaphysical belief as well. Atheism offers practically nothing by way of positive guidance; but it implies a horrendous amount of bad news for everybody else. Atheism, if actually believed and applied (as it almost never is) would strip away not only all belief in religious things, but also all confidence in such realities as the soul, identity, mind, morals, human rights, love, hope, the afterlife...and even reason and science themselves, since an "accidentally-composed" kind of brain cannot be trusted to yield any aptitude to truth, even by way of the discipline of a "reasoning" faculty which Atheism also assumes was accidentally generated.

Of course, if Atheism isn't true, the opposite happens: something else claims the high ground of truth, and Atheism is exposed for a kind of folly of cynicism, one with disastrous consequences for everybody...including the Atheist.

It's true that Atheism isn't much of an ideology. But it's massive in implications.
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Wed Nov 11, 2026 11:06 pm
Will Bouwman wrote: ↑Wed Nov 11, 2026 1:54 pmWhen I say I am an atheist, I mean only that I do not believe in any god.
Are you recommending that to anybody else, or just making a claim for yourself?

Why won't you answer that question?
Does it relate to atheism or Atheism?
Of course. It shows what you are asking us to believe about your kind of belief: are you expecting us, assuming we are rational, to share it, or are you merely making a statement about a personal quirk you say you have. We don't know, unless you tell us.

When you answer, we know exactly whether you're advocating for "Atheism" of the proscriptive kind, or "atheism" as a mere descriptive term. The two are by no means identical.
User avatar
Immanuel Can
Posts: 30600
Joined: Wed Sep 25, 2013 4:42 pm

Re: What is morality?

Post by Immanuel Can »

phyllo wrote: ↑Thu Nov 12, 2026 1:08 pm
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Wed Nov 11, 2026 11:03 pm
phyllo wrote: ↑Wed Nov 11, 2026 1:26 pm You ask for a reason for a secularist's "moral obligation". I say it's conscience.
How do you know that a secularist has a moral duty to obey his conscience? Where is that written? Who declared it? What happens if he chooses not to? What about when his conscience is wrong?
Oh I see that you are answering my questions ("I say it's conscience. Do you have a reason why that is not a valid reason? What would be a valid reason? ") by asking me a bunch of questions.
As did Socrates, and as did Jesus Christ. I'm neither, but I think their models will stand us in good stead. In exploring a complex question, more questions often illuminate the terrain.
Well, if a person does not obey their conscience then their conscience keeps bugging them. They feel guilty.
To a limited extent, of course.

Let us exclude psychopaths and sociopaths from our sample, since they don't seem to have conventional consciences at all, in deference to your response. But even if a person is neither of these, it's very clear that human conscience is rather limited...and sometimes even fraudulent. That is to be expected, when it is the emotional response of a fallen creature, of course. But more importantly, it's not very durable, as numerous psychological studies have shown. It tends to dissolve in groups, for one thing. For another, it often dissipates if the infraction in question or the praiseworthy action is repeated. Moreover, we know that it can be rationalized away, so that even the most wicked things can be reinterpreted as "virtuous" by those who have other motivations for wanting them done.

So conscience does not compel moral action. It invites it, in those instances in which it is rightly directed already, but it is not very powerful or very durable...and the conscience of one person has no inherent motivational value for a different person.
If their conscience is wrong then they do wrong things.
Wait: "wrong" by which account? :shock:

If all consciences are equal in moral efficacy or value, and everybody has one, then what do we do when they are different? And by which conscience do we judge the consciences of others, so as to be able to say what you say, namely, that they could be "wrong"? :shock:
MikeNovack
Posts: 1453
Joined: Fri Jul 11, 2025 1:17 pm

Re: What is morality?

Post by MikeNovack »

Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Thu Nov 12, 2026 4:33 pm
If Atheism were true, then an awful lot of beliefs would have to be set aside as fictional -- and not merely Christian ones, but ones of every other metaphysical belief as well. Atheism offers practically nothing by way of positive guidance; but it implies a horrendous amount of bad news for everybody else. Atheism, if actually believed and applied (as it almost never is) would strip away not only all belief in religious things, but also all confidence in such realities as the soul, identity, mind, morals, human rights, love, hope, the afterlife...and even reason and science themselves, since an "accidentally-composed" kind of brain cannot be trusted to yield any aptitude to truth, even by way of the discipline of a "reasoning" faculty which Atheism also assumes was accidentally generated.
Let's dissect your list:
a) belief in religious things
No, just beliefs about "gods". By and large secular atheists would disallow all religious things, but not all atheists. You are perhaps limited by your own religious beliefs into necessarily associating "religions" with "gods".

And as we proceed down the list, remember, it is YOU who considers these realities. The atheist is denying the reality.

b) the soul
Probably denying this but again, not necessarily. It is GODS the atheist is denying. Again a purely secular atheist will likely be denying the soul. But not inconsistent to disbelieve in gods but believe in souls. An animist might not believe in any gods.

c) identity and mind
Nonsense --- feel free to provide evidence of atheists who deny they have an identity, a mind. I don't think you can.

d) morals
Nonsense -- few atheists, even among the secular ones, deny morality. The problem here is that YOU define morality as something given from a god. They do not.

e) human rights
Nonsense in general (you might be able to find some atheists denying absolute human rights)

f) love, and hope
Total nonsense -- I challenge you to provide evidence of atheists who deny love, who deny hope

g) the afterlife
Correct in general, though not necessarily the case. Remember, we are discussing ATHEISTS (disbelief in gods). Also note that theism does not necessarily imply belief in an afterlife. You can believe in a god and still believe that death is death.

h) ..and even reason and science themselves
Again I challenge you to produce the atheist who does not accept reason and science. What does a god have to do with those?
Your reason is faulty --- you are confusing hardware with software at the abstract level . That the hardware implementing the neural net that is our brain randomly evolved has nothing to do with the question whether the neural net can learn.
I will repeat to try to make it clearer to you --- that a reasoning facility either works or does not, how it came into being, whether by design of some creator deity or by accident/chance is irrelevant to whether works or not.

Let me give you an example --- there is a brook, and there are LARGE trees alongside it. Suppose some men come along, and with axes/saws fell one of these trees so that it falls across the brook. It can be used as a bridge to cross dry shod, yes. Now suppose instead, because of a windstorm, one of these trees is uprooted to fall across the stream (there are about a dozen examples of that within half mile upstream and downstream of my house). Can that also be used as a bridge to cross dry sod? You say that if not by design won't work the same?
User avatar
Immanuel Can
Posts: 30600
Joined: Wed Sep 25, 2013 4:42 pm

Re: What is morality?

Post by Immanuel Can »

MikeNovack wrote: ↑Thu Nov 12, 2026 6:57 pm
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Thu Nov 12, 2026 4:33 pm
If Atheism were true, then an awful lot of beliefs would have to be set aside as fictional -- and not merely Christian ones, but ones of every other metaphysical belief as well. Atheism offers practically nothing by way of positive guidance; but it implies a horrendous amount of bad news for everybody else. Atheism, if actually believed and applied (as it almost never is) would strip away not only all belief in religious things, but also all confidence in such realities as the soul, identity, mind, morals, human rights, love, hope, the afterlife...and even reason and science themselves, since an "accidentally-composed" kind of brain cannot be trusted to yield any aptitude to truth, even by way of the discipline of a "reasoning" faculty which Atheism also assumes was accidentally generated.
Let's dissect your list:
Okay: but while we do, and while I'm remembering your caveat, remember also one of mine. That what I am talking about is not what some particular individual who calls himself Atheist might happen to do (be it rational or irrational for him to do it, because it can be either), but what Atheism itself -- the belief system -- will warrant him to do. That's key.
a) belief in religious things
No, just beliefs about "gods".
Well, no "religious things" can survive Atheism, because Atheism denies the existence of metaphysics. It has to, because its own warrant derives from some form of Physicalism, Naturalism or Materialism. If it doesn't, it stops being Atheism because it re-opens the door to the possibility that there's something substantial behind religious ritual...and then it's agnostic, at most, and not Atheistic at all.
The atheist is denying the reality.
Exactly so.
b) the soul
Probably denying this but again, not necessarily.
No, necessarily, if "soul" is to designate anything transcending the physical. And that is what it most often is used to designate, of course.
It is GODS the atheist is denying. Again a purely secular atheist will likely be denying the soul. But not inconsistent to disbelieve in gods but believe in souls. An animist might not believe in any gods.
This is a good example of the funiture of metaphysics with which the Atheist metanarrative cannot cope. The ultimate truth must be body and brain-chemistry, not soul or mind...and certainly nothing can be distinct or separable from the physical, according to the worldviews that can sponsor the Atheist faith.
c) identity and mind
Nonsense --- feel free to provide evidence of atheists who deny they have an identity, a mind. I don't think you can.
This is the Atheist problem: they cannot deny they have these things, coherently. And experientially, they know they do. And practically, they rely on them for their own arguments. But Atheism (and remember my caveat -- it is the ideology we are speaking about) itself denies to them any basis for such belief.

Yet another indication that Atheism is wrong.
d) morals
Nonsense -- few atheists, even among the secular ones, deny morality.
My caveat again. I remind you.

Atheists often do all sorts of irrational things -- even more irrational than Atheism itself. They often do things that do not even fit their Atheism. So they may celebrate Christmas, or sentimentally drone on about afterlife at a friend's funeral, merely because they cannot stand the implications of their own worldview, or because they like Christmas pudding. It does not argue for the cogency of Atheism...just for the inconsistency of the Atheist in question.
e) human rights
Nonsense in general (you might be able to find some atheists denying absolute human rights)
Same caveat. If they believe their own Atheism, they'd have to believe there are no human rights. That they do not, tells you that they are finding the implications of their Atheism intolerable, once again.
f) love, and hope
Total nonsense -- I challenge you to provide evidence of atheists who deny love, who deny hope
The caveat, again.
g) the afterlife
Correct in general, though not necessarily the case.
Necessarily. Logically. From Atheism itself. Those that do not are again afoul of their own belief system.
h) ..and even reason and science themselves
Again I challenge you to produce the atheist who does not accept reason and science.
The caveat. Remember the caveat.

What you need to show, if you can, is how a person who believes that the human brain and its processes came into existence by pure random accident, without intention, without design, without ultimate purpose, and unframed by any kind of rationality, can believe that the brain can be trusted. He cannot...not logically.
...that a reasoning facility either works or does not, how it came into being, whether by design of some creator deity or by accident/chance is irrelevant to whether works or not.
Not at all. Show me a computer that came into being by pure randomness, accident or chance. And if you find that request absurd, then ask yourself how a computer immeasurably more complex and subtle than that...namely, the human brain...just popped into existence out of nothing. And if it did, let me ask you to explain why we should ever trust it.
Can that also be used as a bridge to cross dry sod?
You've already supposed the existence of woodsmen...and of trees...and of sod...and a world...and physical laws...and rivers... Moreover, your "bridge" is composed of a mere one item, whereas all of the above are vastly more complex than a mere unit. So you've supposed far too much in your analogy...things that need their own explanation.

Let us call one tree a "molecule." (Yes, I know molecules are far from our smallest known particles, but let me make the problem absurdly easy for you). How many such "trees" would have to fall by accident, in what sort of configuration, with what order and sequence, to accidentally compose a
Mike Novak?
popeye1945
Posts: 3263
Joined: Sun Sep 12, 2021 2:12 am

Re: What is morality?

Post by popeye1945 »

Morality is humanity's self-interest in its common biology, its survival, and well-being; any other source is at least one step removed from reality.
User avatar
Immanuel Can
Posts: 30600
Joined: Wed Sep 25, 2013 4:42 pm

Re: What is morality?

Post by Immanuel Can »

popeye1945 wrote: ↑Thu Nov 12, 2026 7:46 pm Morality is humanity's self-interest in its common biology, its survival, and well-being; any other source is at least one step removed from reality.
Well, you're one person. When your self-interest is no longer invested in cooperating with others (say, when you're competing with them for resources, opportunities or survival...) why should you continue to cooperate, instead of pursuing your own self-interest and survival? :shock: How is that adaptive or evolutionary for you? What good is it to you, if the race goes on, but you and yours simply die? Why should you prioritize these unknown "thems" of the human race over yourself and your family and friends?
mickthinks
Posts: 2006
Joined: Thu Oct 18, 2007 1:10 am
Location: Augsburg

Re: What is morality?

Post by mickthinks »

popeye1945 wrote: ↑Thu Nov 12, 2026 7:46 pm Morality is humanity's self-interest in its common biology, its survival, and well-being; …
I am interested in my and my family’s well-being. But why do you think I would be interested in yours?
Post Reply