Page 4 of 4

Re: ANNOUNCEMENT FROM IC

Posted: Thu Nov 19, 2026 3:15 pm
by Immanuel Can
phyllo wrote: ↑Thu Nov 19, 2026 3:12 pm You repeat yourself and you avoid answering questions directed to you.
I answered. What didn't you understand?

I said that anybody who really believed there was no God would, of course, be more attracted to amorality than anything. That would just make sense, from his perspective.

However, I know God exists, so the point is entirely moot.

Re: ANNOUNCEMENT FROM IC

Posted: Thu Nov 19, 2026 3:19 pm
by phyllo
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Thu Nov 19, 2026 3:15 pm
phyllo wrote: ↑Thu Nov 19, 2026 3:12 pm You repeat yourself and you avoid answering questions directed to you.
I answered. What didn't you understand?

I said that anybody who really believed there was no God would, of course, be more attracted to amorality than anything. That would just make sense, from his perspective.

However, I know God exists, so the point is entirely moot.
Okay, you can't see that's not answering the questions.

We can leave it at that.

Re: ANNOUNCEMENT FROM IC

Posted: Thu Nov 19, 2026 3:32 pm
by Immanuel Can
phyllo wrote: ↑Thu Nov 19, 2026 3:19 pm
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Thu Nov 19, 2026 3:15 pm
phyllo wrote: ↑Thu Nov 19, 2026 3:12 pm You repeat yourself and you avoid answering questions directed to you.
I answered. What didn't you understand?

I said that anybody who really believed there was no God would, of course, be more attracted to amorality than anything. That would just make sense, from his perspective.

However, I know God exists, so the point is entirely moot.
Okay, you can't see that's not answering the questions.

We can leave it at that.
I can answer. I can't help you understand the answer.

Or maybe you can ask your question in some way that's clearer. One can hope.

Re: ANNOUNCEMENT FROM IC

Posted: Thu Nov 19, 2026 5:52 pm
by Greatest I am
phyllo wrote: ↑Thu Nov 19, 2026 8:57 am
So we'll see who is right: is God mean and incapable? Or is God just and merciful? If, eventually, He does judge, as He says He will, then I'm right. If He does not, then you would have your case.

But then, exactly what would you win? :shock:
The prize is truth.

The winner lived according to the truth and the loser lived according to a lie.
You used the word "just", in referring to God.

Yahweh says the just reward for sin is one thing and Jesus says it is another. The reverse in fact.

Whom do you name in the first commandment?

It should be Yahweh, but most have rejected his justice for an immoral messianic doctrine that Jesus sells to the immoral.

Re: ANNOUNCEMENT FROM IC

Posted: Thu Nov 19, 2026 6:02 pm
by MikeNovack
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Thu Nov 19, 2026 3:15 pm
I said that anybody who really believed there was no God would, of course, be more attracted to amorality than anything. That would just make sense, from his perspective.

However, I know God exists, so the point is entirely moot.
WHY? You are mixing two things.
a) You believe in God
b) You believe morality comes from God
Therefore:
Those who do not believe in God could not believe in morality. Would act amorally.

c) He does not believe in God
d) He does not believe morality comes from any god -- comes from somewhere else
Therefore:
He does not believe in morality, would be amoral <WRONG CONCLUSION>

What this other believes about where morality comes from determines what this other believes about morality and whether should act morally. It doesn't matter what YOU believe is the true source of morality. You are arguing AS IF this other person were saying

e) Morality comes from a god.
f) I believe there are no gods
Therefore:
I do not believe in morality, free to act amorally.
BUT -- he does NOT believe in "e". That is YOU pretending your belief about where morality comes from is in his head. Or thinking the truth of where morality comes from plays a role in his beliefs. It doesn't matter whether your belief of the source of morality is true or not. It is HIS beliefs that will determine whether he thinks morality exists and whether he should ct morally or amorally.

That YOU believe "if there were no God, I would be free to act amorally" has nothing to do with HIS beliefs.

Re: ANNOUNCEMENT FROM IC

Posted: Thu Nov 19, 2026 6:26 pm
by Greatest I am
MikeNovack wrote: ↑Thu Nov 19, 2026 6:02 pm

That YOU believe "if there were no God, I would be free to act amorally" has nothing to do with HIS beliefs.
I love to do a spontaneous laughter while zipping by.

First. There is not really a thing like free will. Everything we will is conditional.

As to any of us being free to to think immorally and act unethically from it, think again.

The lessons begins with spankings and ends in jail or worse.

Who is so stupid as to think we are not born with a template that tells us to default to our love side and not our hate side, that we hold back unless what we love is in jepardy.

Have you see those baby experiments showing babies defaulting to their love or good sides instead of their evil sides?

Re: ANNOUNCEMENT FROM IC

Posted: Thu Nov 19, 2026 7:39 pm
by Immanuel Can
MikeNovack wrote: ↑Thu Nov 19, 2026 6:02 pm Those who do not believe in God could not believe in morality. Would act amorally.
That's a misrepresentation. The argument's not about what somebody who called himself an Atheist "would do." I have pointed out that much that they "do" is not related to Atheism. They are often better than their creed warrants.

The question is, "What will Atheism itself warrant the Atheist to do?" And that's quite a different question.

Let's talk about what the ideology will warrant, since what people sometimes choose to do is often so irrational relative to that.

Re: ANNOUNCEMENT FROM IC

Posted: Sat Nov 21, 2026 6:32 pm
by Greatest I am
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Thu Nov 19, 2026 7:39 pm
MikeNovack wrote: ↑Thu Nov 19, 2026 6:02 pm Those who do not believe in God could not believe in morality. Would act amorally.
That's a misrepresentation. The argument's not about what somebody who called himself an Atheist "would do." I have pointed out that much that they "do" is not related to Atheism. They are often better than their creed warrants.

The question is, "What will Atheism itself warrant the Atheist to do?" And that's quite a different question.

Let's talk about what the ideology will warrant, since what people sometimes choose to do is often so irrational relative to that.
On ideology.

Is an ideology that promotes a God who puts the needs of the few above the needs of the many a moral ideology?

Christianity seems to offer that and "genocidal" up as a holy trait.

I can show where Moses rejected that a hole God, --- not that Moses ever existed in reality.

Re: ANNOUNCEMENT FROM IC

Posted: Sun Nov 22, 2026 5:35 am
by promethean75
You do realize that declaring the world a product of an evil fake god and that there is an even greater god presiding over all this mess is just as, if not more, kookie than the judaistic belief that there is no demiurge but only two dudes... Jesus H. C. vs the devil.

I can give you that Gnosticism is much cooler philosophically than judaism, but I can't give any greater probability of it being true, sir.