Re: All Human-Based FSKs are 4 Billion Years Old
Posted: Tue Apr 11, 2023 9:04 am
1) Abiogenesis is the idea that organic organisms arose from inorganic matter. ALL current versions - that is any that are conditioned upon the FSKs VA mentions above - include steps between inorganic matter -----> building blocks (whatever, amino acids, nucleic acids)-------->the first simple organisms.The theory of Abiogenesis is conditioned to a BioChemistry human-based FSK which is conditioned upon the biology-FSK, the Chemistry-FSK, the Physics-FSK and the individual's-FSK.
But his antirealism says that without observers there are no things which would eliminate the possibility of those building block stages. They were not conscious. However every abiogenesis hypothesis currently considered possible right now does include that building block stage in development. We have organic chemicals or chemicals that will be part of organisms, but no living organisms yet.
VA can only have some kind of spontaneous generation hypothesis, which is NOT abiogenesis.
IOW part of VA's general argument here has abiogenesis as support. But it does NOT support his hypothesis. He cannot accept there were these building block stages. He has the sudden appearance of whole organism (and part of the planet and the sun and nutrients) which is NOT abiogenesis.
2) And then regardless of where/when VA decides that consciousness/perception arose, what we have a the sudden appearance of something very complex and specific (compared to the prior undifferentiated quantum foam). How did it arise AND create the conditions for it's survival? which would include at least a portion of the earth (would the other posrtions of the earth exist since these were not perceivable to the first organism?), the Sun and so on. This is a miracle on the order of Jesus' return from the dead.
It's not just abiogenesis. Meaning life arose out of non-living matter. It would be a-anything-genesis. Life arose instantly out of the void and cocreated it's environment.
It's a kind of Creationism, but one not attributed to a deity, but by a microbe.
