Philosophy Now Forum

rantal wrote:So, it you do then understand correctly what a concrete example is, why did you pretend that the naive theory you spouted was a concrete example?

all the best, rantal

My friend, you're hung up on "concrete examples" for some reason. Exactly what the hell are you trying to prove?

rantal wrote:Please just answer the question

all the best, rantal

Ask me the question again, whatever it was, and please try to stay on the subject, and please try to avoid the Bill Wiltrack syndrome of italics and color on every one of your goddamn posts!

rantal wrote:Here is the question again, actually for the third time! So, it you do then understand correctly what a concrete example is, why did you pretend that the naive theory you spouted was a concrete example?

all the best, rantal

I've got many theories, and the only people who are naive are those who make vacuous attacks on them.

bobevenson wrote:

rantal wrote:Here is the question again, actually for the third time! So, it you do then understand correctly what a concrete example is, why did you pretend that the naive theory you spouted was a concrete example?

all the best, rantal

I've got many theories, and the only people who are naive are those who make vacuous attacks on them.

I see you are still abiding the question Bob, now surely all will now know you are afraid to answer it

all the best rantal

rantal wrote:I meant of course, 'avoiding the question'

I wish I knew what the hell you were talking about. If you've got a question, ask the goddamn question right here! No, you'd rather play your little semantic games!

rantal wrote:I see you are afraid to answer my question, now all know that

all the best, rantal

What's your question?

[edited by iMod]

bobevenson wrote:

rantal wrote:I see you are afraid to answer my question, now all know that

all the best, rantal

What's your question?

[edited by iMod]

So, it you do then understand correctly what a concrete example is, why did you pretend that the naive theory you spouted was a concrete example?

all the best, rantal

I certainly am getting tired of your refusal to discuss the actual issues at hand. You can play all the semantic games you want, but excuse my refusal to participate.

bobevenson wrote:I certainly am getting tired of your refusal to discuss the actual issues at hand. You can play all the semantic games you want, but excuse my refusal to participate.

You asked me what my question was and then decline to answer it, seems it is you that is playing silly games

all the best, rantal

rantal wrote:

bobevenson wrote:I certainly am getting tired of your refusal to discuss the actual issues at hand. You can play all the semantic games you want, but excuse my refusal to participate.

You asked me what my question was and then decline to answer it, seems it is you that is playing silly games

all the best, rantal

I'm talking about real questions on real issues, not your semantic games.