Page 28 of 41
Re: What is morality?
Posted: Fri Nov 06, 2026 5:48 am
by MikeNovack
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Fri Nov 06, 2026 5:05 am
So no, evolution doesn't breed "cooperative behaviour," except when it is to the advantage of the individual organism. It really would be conducive to "radical neutral" pseudo-morals, so that same organism can seize survival advantages beyond the norm.
BIOLOGICAL evolution is based on the individual organism, any survival/reproduction advantage of the individual.
SOCIAL evolution is based on the group/society (which up to very recently, a band of 50-100 individuals). So it is the relative advantage for the culture to survive.
You are correct, biological evolution does not (usually*) favor cooperation. But it is SLOW compared to cultural evolution. And if cooperation is favorable to the group, mechanisms will also evolve to deal with non-cooperative individuals.
The type game you described ENDS --- so yes, there is the game theory question of when to defect from cooperation (and thereby win the game). Try versions of the game that don't end, rounds keep on going. Look, experiments have been conducted with these games, for cooperation/defection think "prisoner's dilemma". Best strategy is known (cooperate with cooperators and punish defectors tit-for tat).
* Only usually ---- consider chimpanzees. No matter how powerful that head male chimp is, a pair of males able to cooperate would defeat him. Cooperation can also evolve where close kin are involved since it is not actually the individual but the genes of the individual.
Re: What is morality?
Posted: Fri Nov 06, 2026 6:33 am
by Immanuel Can
MikeNovack wrote: ↑Fri Nov 06, 2026 5:48 am
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Fri Nov 06, 2026 5:05 am
So no, evolution doesn't breed "cooperative behaviour," except when it is to the advantage of the individual organism. It really would be conducive to "radical neutral" pseudo-morals, so that same organism can seize survival advantages beyond the norm.
SOCIAL evolution
Give me an example of "social evolution" that does not actually break down into biological, individual evolution.
Which are your "evolved" societies, and which have some "evolving" they need to be doing?
Re: What is morality?
Posted: Fri Nov 06, 2026 11:20 am
by promethean75
Hmm... that would be strange because organized religion wasn't around during the first eighty-thousand years of our evolution... so it had to be something else that kept folks from killin' each other, right?
How can you claim that religion is the source of morals if people were acting morally thousands of years before it even existed?
(Oh dear)
Re: What is morality?
Posted: Fri Nov 06, 2026 11:24 am
by promethean75
But you can't speculate about what evolution would or wouldn't do, anyway, because you believe humans were spontaneously created as they are now only a few thousand years ago. This whole argument is a non-starter.
Re: What is morality?
Posted: Fri Nov 06, 2026 2:43 pm
by Walker
promethean75 wrote: ↑Fri Nov 06, 2026 11:24 am
But you can't speculate about what evolution would or wouldn't do, anyway, because you believe humans were spontaneously created as they are now only a few thousand years ago. This whole argument is a non-starter.
A link from a recent posting posits that human beings became human when endowed with consciousness (the knowledge of good and evil). Before that, humans were around with all the other creatures, and since animals aren't specifically named in the holy bible, dinosaurs could have been in that mix of creatures lacking knowledge of good and evil, long before humans arose from the dust* with their lack of consciousness.
Interesting. It's outside the box rebel thinking that fits what's known, and that's so hard to do despite everyone's claim to the cliché.
* dust being the origin of the process rather than a scientific mud puddle.
Re: What is morality?
Posted: Fri Nov 06, 2026 3:05 pm
by Immanuel Can
promethean75 wrote: ↑Fri Nov 06, 2026 11:20 am
Hmm... that would be strange because organized religion wasn't around during the first eighty-thousand years of our evolution...
Well, that assumes to unnecessary things: first, that it's only "organized" religion (whatever that is supposed to mean here) that is capable of generating moral conclusions -- which is manifestly not the case. Ancient polytheistic and animistic societies certainly did produce their own versions of "morality," and many different ones. The problem is not whether a society can produce a code...it's whether or not it can justify it, over and against all the alternatives.
And secondly, this comment requires us to believe that the human race "evolved," and "evolved" in regard to morality, as well...for which there is no good evidence at all, given our last couple of centuries of behaviour. That's an assumption we cannot simply grant. You'd have to produce your evidence for moral evolution.
Re: What is morality?
Posted: Fri Nov 06, 2026 3:39 pm
by promethean75
Bro. Homos S. was feeding and sharing and grooming and protecting and cuddling other homos before they even had any language. These creatures were the mental equivalents of people with Downs Syndrome, so it sure as shit wasn't a class on Kant that made them wanna be nice to each other.
I think you've been reading the wrong books all your life, sir, and it's very concerning to me.
Re: What is morality?
Posted: Fri Nov 06, 2026 6:32 pm
by MikeNovack
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Fri Nov 06, 2026 6:33 am
Give me an example of "social evolution" that does not actually break down into biological, individual evolution.
You are joking, yes?
HOW are we communicating? By a LANGUAGE. Do you imagine a language can be broken down to individual evolution?
That you will have a language, that as a human baby you were able to learn one, that is biological evolution, individual. What that language is, how a language evolves, is social evolution.
Re: What is morality?
Posted: Fri Nov 06, 2026 8:25 pm
by Immanuel Can
MikeNovack wrote: ↑Fri Nov 06, 2026 6:32 pm
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Fri Nov 06, 2026 6:33 am
Give me an example of "social evolution" that does not actually break down into biological, individual evolution.
You are joking, yes?
No.
HOW are we communicating? By a LANGUAGE. Do you imagine a language can be broken down to individual evolution?
You're
assuming your conclusion, not proving it. The fact that we have language does not suggest Evolutionism, at least to anybody who's not already presuming Evolutionism.
Learning is not "evolution." It's just learning. Not transformation of one species into another is happening: the same individual is simply learning to be what he/she already has the latent potential to be. And the fact that languages morph is not "evolution," but merely change. There is no certainty that languages get better; often, they simply degrade or disappear. Where is Latin today? How about Sanskrit? Or how is ghetto slang an "evolution" upon Standard English?
Re: What is morality?
Posted: Fri Nov 06, 2026 8:35 pm
by Immanuel Can
promethean75 wrote: ↑Fri Nov 06, 2026 3:39 pm
Bro. Homos S. was feeding and sharing and grooming and protecting and cuddling other homos before they even had any language.
Well, that's your Evolutionist tale, for sure; it's not one for which you have any evidence, of course. But even were it the case, it does not have anything to do with morality. All it shows is reciprocity in picking fleas. Whether or not practicing reciprocity is moral, well, that has to be decided on the basis of some moral metric: and what metric shall we employ, since they disagree?
The moral metrics of Islam are that infidels like yourself are wrong, and deserving of being murdered -- to the point of self-immolation or slitting throats. The moral metric of Hinduism is that Islamists are evil. But the moral metric of Sikhism is that the moral metric of Hindus is warped. None of them agree with the moral metrics of Judaism or Christianity, which disagree with the moral metrics of Santeria, or Confucianism, or Shinto, or paganism. And Atheism, by its own profession, offers no moral metrics at all.
So how is this great decision about the moral urgency of cooperation to be established? What is your superior metric, which you are invoking in making the claim that "shared grooming" is moral?
Re: What is morality?
Posted: Fri Nov 06, 2026 10:40 pm
by MikeNovack
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Fri Nov 06, 2026 8:25 pm
Learning is not "evolution." It's just learning. Not transformation of one species into another is happening: the same individual is simply learning to be what he/she already has the latent potential to be. And the fact that languages morph is not "evolution," but merely change. There is no certainty that languages get better; often, they simply degrade or disappear. Where is Latin today? How about Sanskrit? Or how is ghetto slang an "evolution" upon Standard English?
Whan that Aprill with his shoures soote
The droghte of March hath perced to the roote,
Yeah, our modern English is sure degradation from that, yes?
Look, you don't even believe in biological evolution, why bother to argue evolution means biological evolution*. And even biological evolution has nothing to do with "getting better". It is merely change. Where is Latin today? French, Spanish, Portuguese, Italian, Occitan, Romanian, Romansh, etc.
Mutual grooming is common to all social PRIMATES. You define "morality" as given by the Great Pink Unicorn so of course by that DEFINITION can't be from anywhere else. I assure your, I have met atheists who conducted themselves morally. So apparently directives from the Great Pink Unicorn cannot be the only source.
* It does NOT mean just biological evolution. Evolution applies to any "system". And by the way, biological evolution does not apply to individual biological organisms. The individual organism does not change. The SPECIES changes (system of biological individuals).
Re: What is morality?
Posted: Fri Nov 06, 2026 10:54 pm
by Immanuel Can
MikeNovack wrote: ↑Fri Nov 06, 2026 10:40 pm
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Fri Nov 06, 2026 8:25 pm
Learning is not "evolution." It's just learning. Not transformation of one species into another is happening: the same individual is simply learning to be what he/she already has the latent potential to be. And the fact that languages morph is not "evolution," but merely change. There is no certainty that languages get better; often, they simply degrade or disappear. Where is Latin today? How about Sanskrit? Or how is ghetto slang an "evolution" upon Standard English?
Whan that Aprill with his shoures soote
The droghte of March hath perced to the roote,
Yeah, our modern English is sure degradation from that, yes?
In some ways, yes...Anglo Saxon had particular cadences and expressions which modern English lacks. However, modern English has many more words from which to draw, having added the Latin, French and other influences from all over the world that have developed the language. However, that's also just change, not evolution. The language has not transformed into another "species" of being.
Mutual grooming is common to all social PRIMATES.
So are rape, tribalism, infanticide and cannibalism. So...what's your point?
I assure your, I have met atheists who conducted themselves morally.
So have I. But "morally" by what standard? Not by Atheistic standards, since there are none. So what standard were they responding to? That's what you should be asking. And you'll find that in the West, it is almost always the Judeo-Christian standard -- minus whatever elements of it they personally opted to remove, of course.
But Atheism itself tells them nothing about morality. So they've borrowed it from somewhere. So where?
Re: What is morality?
Posted: Fri Nov 06, 2026 11:28 pm
by MikeNovack
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Fri Nov 06, 2026 10:54 pm
In some ways, yes...Anglo Saxon had particular cadences and expressions which modern English lacks. .........
But Atheism itself tells them nothing about morality. So they've borrowed it from somewhere. So where?
That was Middle English, you can mostly understand it. That was not Anglo-Saxon. This is Old English:
Hwæt! We Gardena in geardagum,
þeod-cyninga þrym gefrunon,
hu ða æþelingas ellen fremedon.
Oft Scyld Scefing sceaþena þreatum,
monegum mægþum, meodo-setla ofteah
egsode eorlas.
NOT believing in the Great Pink Unicorn itself should not tell you anything about "morality". Just because the Atheist doesn't believe in any great Pink Unicorn doesn't mean the Atheist has no beliefs about anything. For all you know the Atheist even has RELIGIOUS beliefs << disbelief in any deities does not necessarily mean disbelief that there is a divine/sacred/holy -- not ALL Atheists are "secular materialists" >>
Re: What is morality?
Posted: Sat Nov 07, 2026 12:21 am
by Immanuel Can
MikeNovack wrote: ↑Fri Nov 06, 2026 11:28 pm
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Fri Nov 06, 2026 10:54 pm
In some ways, yes...Anglo Saxon had particular cadences and expressions which modern English lacks. .........
But Atheism itself tells them nothing about morality. So they've borrowed it from somewhere. So where?
That was Middle English,
Yes, Chaucer. But so what?
NOT believing in the Great Pink Unicorn
That's everybody. So you can save yourself that worry.
For all you know the Atheist even has RELIGIOUS beliefs
No, then, by definition, he's no longer acting as an Atheist. He's become a hypocrite, perhaps, for not believing his own claimed worldview, but he's definitely left the field of true Atheism in order to acquire values that his claimed worldview would deny him.
Re: What is morality?
Posted: Sat Nov 07, 2026 12:37 am
by MikeNovack
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Sat Nov 07, 2026 12:21 am
For all you know the Atheist even has RELIGIOUS beliefs
No, then, by definition, he's no longer acting as an Atheist. He's become a hypocrite, perhaps, for not believing his own claimed worldview, but he's definitely left the field of true Atheism in order to acquire values that his claimed worldview would deny him.
No, ATHEISM means not believing in any gods. It does not necessarily mean disbelieving in the holy/sacred/divine.
Yes, some atheists are secular materialists. But not all. If you know somebody is a secular materialist, you know they are an atheist. But if you know somebody is an atheist, you do not know that they are a secular materialist. And you have no good reason to believe that even that the secular materialist does not have values.
It is YOU who assumes "religion" necessarily involves belief in God. But what then do you consider Buddhism to be? (that is just an example).