Page 3 of 4

Re: ANNOUNCEMENT FROM IC

Posted: Tue Nov 17, 2026 2:48 pm
by Immanuel Can
Gary Childress wrote: ↑Tue Nov 17, 2026 2:11 pm
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Mon Nov 16, 2026 1:01 am
Gary Childress wrote: ↑Thu Oct 22, 2026 1:55 am If you "reject God", then IC thinks you are either "mentally ill" or "deranged" or on your way to it.
This is no announcement I ever made. Gary's making stuff up...again.
You told me that in your experience, people who reject God are prone to mental illness? Are you saying that I misunderstood you?
Well, in the first place, I didn't "announce" anything at all. You turned it into an "announcement. And secondly, all I did was point out to you what the Scriptures themselves say is the case, in Romans 1 -- namely, that one cause of mental confusion and derangement can be that the person in question has rejected the knowledge of God.

Now, if you want to take that as some sort of blanket diagnosis on the cause of mental illness in all cases, you're saying more than the Word of God says. It leaves open the possibility that mental illness has multiple causes; and I think it does.

Some mental illness is caused by a history of abuse by other wicked persons, rather than by an individual's rejection of God. Some may be precipitated by bio-chemical imbalances. Some may be the residual effect of drug abuse. And some may be ideological, induced by a mania derived from excessive devotion to an idea or to a toxic self-image. Some may be spiritual in origin. But also, some mental derangement is clearly caused by a distorted worldview, one distorted by an obdurate refusal to reckon with the existence of God.

And that's pretty easy to demonstrate, too. Rejection of God, or Atheism, subjects its "faithful" to additional beliefs that, while not specified in Atheism's one basic claim, follow like an avalanche from that basic commitment. For instance, if one is an Atheist, one cannot find even one single moral precept that Atheism requires of one. This blinds the Atheist to the possibility of any grounds for moral belief. And not surprisingly, this also inclines the Atheist to a further logical entailment: namely, that all morals are merely "subjective," which further entails that none is real or binding at all. Thus Dostoevsky said that "If God is dead, everything is permitted": and the very Atheistic Nietzsche agreed with him entirely, claiming that the wise, the ubermenschen, are inevitably "beyond good and evil." Thus, one who really believes Atheism must also believe there is not moral imperative in this world, and no ultimate consequence for living amorally.

In the same way, Atheism implies necessarily that the universe has no teleology. It is not create FOR anything, nor does it tend TOWARD any meaningful goal. Not only does it have no afterlife, it has no judgment entailed. Nor can the universe itself mean anything by its existence; it cannot succeed or fail at any goal, precisely because accidental causation by definition HAS no goal, and cannot possibly be ascribed any. The universe, according to Atheism, came into existence by sheer accident, and tends only toward final entropy, the famous "heat death."

Having no teleology, then the universe also has no inherent meaning. But human beings cannot live without a sense of meaning, because they must guide their choices toward some objective or goal. How else are they to make choices of what is better or worse, more functional or less, or more inclined to produce a desired outcome or less so? Absent any objective meaning in their universe, the Atheist is force to substitute delusion into the role of making meaning and organizing a life. There is no alternative, because he believes the universe offers him no insight on the matter. So he must make it up, and then cling to it, like a drowning man to a bit of gradually-sinking debris. But it can, according to Atheism, never be real, no matter how much he desires it.

We could go on. There are further stages of such derangement, and they are outlined in Romans 1. But these were no announcement from me; they are a declaration of God. And they are an observable fact in our world, as well.

Re: ANNOUNCEMENT FROM IC

Posted: Wed Nov 18, 2026 11:29 am
by Gary Childress
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Tue Nov 17, 2026 2:48 pm
Gary Childress wrote: ↑Tue Nov 17, 2026 2:11 pm
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Mon Nov 16, 2026 1:01 am
This is no announcement I ever made. Gary's making stuff up...again.
You told me that in your experience, people who reject God are prone to mental illness? Are you saying that I misunderstood you?
Well, in the first place, I didn't "announce" anything at all. You turned it into an "announcement. And secondly, all I did was point out to you what the Scriptures themselves say is the case, in Romans 1 -- namely, that one cause of mental confusion and derangement can be that the person in question has rejected the knowledge of God.

Now, if you want to take that as some sort of blanket diagnosis on the cause of mental illness in all cases, you're saying more than the Word of God says. It leaves open the possibility that mental illness has multiple causes; and I think it does.

Some mental illness is caused by a history of abuse by other wicked persons, rather than by an individual's rejection of God. Some may be precipitated by bio-chemical imbalances. Some may be the residual effect of drug abuse. And some may be ideological, induced by a mania derived from excessive devotion to an idea or to a toxic self-image. Some may be spiritual in origin. But also, some mental derangement is clearly caused by a distorted worldview, one distorted by an obdurate refusal to reckon with the existence of God.

And that's pretty easy to demonstrate, too. Rejection of God, or Atheism, subjects its "faithful" to additional beliefs that, while not specified in Atheism's one basic claim, follow like an avalanche from that basic commitment. For instance, if one is an Atheist, one cannot find even one single moral precept that Atheism requires of one. This blinds the Atheist to the possibility of any grounds for moral belief. And not surprisingly, this also inclines the Atheist to a further logical entailment: namely, that all morals are merely "subjective," which further entails that none is real or binding at all. Thus Dostoevsky said that "If God is dead, everything is permitted": and the very Atheistic Nietzsche agreed with him entirely, claiming that the wise, the ubermenschen, are inevitably "beyond good and evil." Thus, one who really believes Atheism must also believe there is not moral imperative in this world, and no ultimate consequence for living amorally.

In the same way, Atheism implies necessarily that the universe has no teleology. It is not create FOR anything, nor does it tend TOWARD any meaningful goal. Not only does it have no afterlife, it has no judgment entailed. Nor can the universe itself mean anything by its existence; it cannot succeed or fail at any goal, precisely because accidental causation by definition HAS no goal, and cannot possibly be ascribed any. The universe, according to Atheism, came into existence by sheer accident, and tends only toward final entropy, the famous "heat death."

Having no teleology, then the universe also has no inherent meaning. But human beings cannot live without a sense of meaning, because they must guide their choices toward some objective or goal. How else are they to make choices of what is better or worse, more functional or less, or more inclined to produce a desired outcome or less so? Absent any objective meaning in their universe, the Atheist is force to substitute delusion into the role of making meaning and organizing a life. There is no alternative, because he believes the universe offers him no insight on the matter. So he must make it up, and then cling to it, like a drowning man to a bit of gradually-sinking debris. But it can, according to Atheism, never be real, no matter how much he desires it.

We could go on. There are further stages of such derangement, and they are outlined in Romans 1. But these were no announcement from me; they are a declaration of God. And they are an observable fact in our world, as well.
If you think there is ultimate fairness and justice in the universe, then good luck. I see no evidence of it.

Re: ANNOUNCEMENT FROM IC

Posted: Wed Nov 18, 2026 1:07 pm
by phyllo
If you think there is ultimate fairness and justice in the universe, then good luck. I see no evidence of it.
You will see fairness and justice once you are dead. Or maybe not even then.

If you look at the history of religion, there used to be no punishment or reward in the afterlife. Everybody basically ended up in the same place, if they ended up anywhere. But that bothered people because they noticed that often nasty people were well off and good people suffered. It seemed unfair, so the concept of justice after death developed.

So you are not the only one who doesn't see evidence of fairness and justice in the universe.

Re: ANNOUNCEMENT FROM IC

Posted: Wed Nov 18, 2026 4:06 pm
by Immanuel Can
Gary Childress wrote: ↑Wed Nov 18, 2026 11:29 am If you think there is ultimate fairness and justice in the universe, then good luck. I see no evidence of it.
I didn't say the present universe was fair. In fact, it's obviously not. The important question is WHY it's not...what that not-fairness is telling us is going on.

You say it's God's fault. I say it's humanity's fault. But we agree that things are far from what they should be, right now.

You say it's incurable. I say God will cure the injustice.

You say he must be incapable. I say God is merciful, because if he judged immediately, it would be with perfect justice, which would sweep up Gary Childress and charge him with all the things he's said so publicly against God.

So we'll see who is right: is God mean and incapable? Or is God just and merciful? If, eventually, He does judge, as He says He will, then I'm right. If He does not, then you would have your case.

But then, exactly what would you win? :shock:

Re: ANNOUNCEMENT FROM IC

Posted: Wed Nov 18, 2026 4:16 pm
by promethean75
"So you are not the only one who doesn't see evidence of fairness and justice in the universe."

But this can be good news if you remember that this means there is no injustice either. Good news for the sociopath, i mean... not you regular guys.

One of the saddest things you'll ever see is a sociopath hesitating and second-guessing himself because there's still a little good left in him, and he can't bring himself to do it. I sob every time I see it happen. These guys are like saints.

You know how you break down and cry before the unworldly beauty of the virgin Mary when you're in church? I do the same thing when I see sociopaths. Sometimes I don't even feel worthy, and I have to look away.

Re: ANNOUNCEMENT FROM IC

Posted: Thu Nov 19, 2026 6:51 am
by Gary Childress
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Wed Nov 18, 2026 4:06 pm You say he must be incapable. I say God is merciful, because if he judged immediately, it would be with perfect justice, which would sweep up Gary Childress and charge him with all the things he's said so publicly against God.
Enjoy. I have no delusions about the world. I assume I'll see more of the same shit show all the way to the end of this life. The girl I bailed out of financial ruin with all my life savings and who then blew me off is a "devout" Catholic. I'm sure she's laughing all the way to the bank while I beg and plead for her to at least show a little gratitude and acknowledge my existence. Now that she's back on her feet, she's a big whig in management at an assisted living facility and probably makes hundreds of times what I scrounge up on disability. (Yes. I literally know what it's like to bail out the rich.) In the end, the weak perish, and the strong (as well as those who can convince everyone they're "Christians") get to frolic in joy and prosperity while we losers wallow in shit. Believe me, I hope there's a God, and I hope God is just and fair. I very much doubt it, though.

Re: ANNOUNCEMENT FROM IC

Posted: Thu Nov 19, 2026 8:57 am
by phyllo
So we'll see who is right: is God mean and incapable? Or is God just and merciful? If, eventually, He does judge, as He says He will, then I'm right. If He does not, then you would have your case.

But then, exactly what would you win? :shock:
The prize is truth.

The winner lived according to the truth and the loser lived according to a lie.

Re: ANNOUNCEMENT FROM IC

Posted: Thu Nov 19, 2026 1:30 pm
by Immanuel Can
phyllo wrote: ↑Thu Nov 19, 2026 8:57 am
So we'll see who is right: is God mean and incapable? Or is God just and merciful? If, eventually, He does judge, as He says He will, then I'm right. If He does not, then you would have your case.

But then, exactly what would you win? :shock:
The prize is truth.
Well, what the truth is, is the subject of the present question. But let me ask you this.

Why does truth have any value for somebody who's just going to die and go to dust anyway? :shock: Isn't it more fun to live by comforting lies, if that's how we all end up? And if the self-deceiver is having more fun, and death ends all...well, how is the person who's suffering for the truth "winning" anything? :shock:

Re: ANNOUNCEMENT FROM IC

Posted: Thu Nov 19, 2026 1:43 pm
by Gary Childress
phyllo wrote: ↑Thu Nov 19, 2026 8:57 am
So we'll see who is right: is God mean and incapable? Or is God just and merciful? If, eventually, He does judge, as He says He will, then I'm right. If He does not, then you would have your case.

But then, exactly what would you win? :shock:
The prize is truth.

The winner lived according to the truth and the loser lived according to a lie.
He's right about one thing, though. Even if he's the one living a lie and I'm living the truth (which I see very little reason to think I'm not) there's very little consolation in knowing the truth if the world is a cruel and unjust place for humans. Heck, in a cruel and unjust world, it's probably better to be deluded and think that everything will be roses and caviar in the end. But it's difficult to intentionally delude oneself once the absurdity of reality has sobered up a person's psyche to the dismal and hopeless truth. But we'll see. Maybe I'm wrong, and there's a fair and just God, and my female friend will come running to me with open arms, and we'll live happily ever after. Or at least, maybe she'll pay me back with interest. That would be the second-best outcome.

Re: ANNOUNCEMENT FROM IC

Posted: Thu Nov 19, 2026 1:51 pm
by phyllo
Why does truth have any value for somebody who's just going to die and go to dust anyway? :shock: Isn't it more fun to live by comforting lies, if that's how we all end up? And if the self-deceiver is having more fun, and death ends all...well, how is the person who's suffering for the truth "winning" anything? :shock:
The truth is valuable in itself.

Even it you consider it to be only a 'tool', truth would produce a life better aligned with objective reality than the lie. Which has always been useful for survival and prosperity. Sure, sometimes lies work out well, but they can't be relied on because they have no strong base.

Didn't you once, or more than once, write that you believe in God because it is the truth? Are you suggesting now, that you believe in God because it is a comforting lie?

If you found out that God and Christianity are lies, would you continue to believe?

Re: ANNOUNCEMENT FROM IC

Posted: Thu Nov 19, 2026 1:51 pm
by promethean75
Welp, Nietzsche and all the rest obsessed over it. Stirner laughed and waved it aside.

Everything on the other side of my skin is a mystery, maybe even a dangerous one... and I know only one thing for certain: Me, muthafucka. Why would I concern myself with anything else, then, when i could be wrong about it?

One thing I won't do is play a stupid game with a creator that did not first aks me if I wanted to play. I am under no obligation whatsoever to such a thing, and if I am obliterated for refusing to play, I've made it back to where I originally was (nothingness), and nothing is lost.

Has there been an iconoclast greater than me, yet? They've all been lovely, yes, but they're all welterweights, you guys.

Re: ANNOUNCEMENT FROM IC

Posted: Thu Nov 19, 2026 2:04 pm
by Immanuel Can
phyllo wrote: ↑Thu Nov 19, 2026 1:51 pm
Why does truth have any value for somebody who's just going to die and go to dust anyway? :shock: Isn't it more fun to live by comforting lies, if that's how we all end up? And if the self-deceiver is having more fun, and death ends all...well, how is the person who's suffering for the truth "winning" anything? :shock:
The truth is valuable in itself.
That would mean it was objectively valuable. Are you now believing in objective truth?
Even it you consider it to be only a 'tool', truth would produce a life better aligned with objective reality than the lie.
Often the opposite is the case. You find that many people prefer live by lies, and find it easier, than those who force themselves to face unpleasant truths. Look at Hollywood. Look at politics. Look at the press, and all those who prefer to believe the major networks are telling them the truth, rather than having to examine. Seeking truth is a lot of work; and when you find it, it's often hard to swallow.

So again, if death ends all, why choose the harder, sadder path of truth, rather than the comforting delusion?
Didn't you once, or more than once, write that you believe in God because it is the truth? Are you suggesting now, that you believe in God because it is a comforting lie?
No. I'm asking the question FROM AN ATHEIST PERSPECTIVE. For Christians believe in God, judgment and the afterlife, so truth is worth having, for them. But why, if one didn't believe in any of those things, would living by a harsh truth be preferable to live by comforting lies?
If you found out that God and Christianity are lies, would you continue to believe?
I think that if we really believed that, any of us who was smart would do a rethink. If there were no God, as Dostoevsky said, everything becomes permissible. And to be able to do anything, with no consequences, would be a great temptation for anybody, wouldn't it?

Re: ANNOUNCEMENT FROM IC

Posted: Thu Nov 19, 2026 2:43 pm
by phyllo
That would mean it was objectively valuable. Are you now believing in objective truth?
You have some other kind of truth?? :lol:
Often the opposite is the case. You find that many people prefer live by lies, and find it easier, than those who force themselves to face unpleasant truths. Look at Hollywood. Look at politics. Look at the press, and all those who prefer to believe the major networks are telling them the truth, rather than having to examine. Seeking truth is a lot of work; and when you find it, it's often hard to swallow.
If you did an analysis, then truth would be revealed to be much more prevalent. But people overlook the tiny truths of everyday life and focus on the lies.
Sure, there are some people who prefer some lies.
So again, if death ends all, why choose the harder, sadder path of truth, rather than the comforting delusion?
You already asked and I already answered.
No. I'm asking the question FROM AN ATHEIST PERSPECTIVE.
I have no idea why you would do that.
I think that if we really believed that, any of us who was smart would do a rethink. If there were no God, as Dostoevsky said, everything becomes permissible. And to be able to do anything, with no consequences, would be a great temptation for anybody, wouldn't it?
We?

I asked you.

The question is not if you would be tempted to "do anything". The question is ... Would you continue to believe in God and Christianity if you knew they were lies.

Re: ANNOUNCEMENT FROM IC

Posted: Thu Nov 19, 2026 2:53 pm
by Immanuel Can
phyllo wrote: ↑Thu Nov 19, 2026 2:43 pm
That would mean it was objectively valuable. Are you now believing in objective truth?
You have some other kind of truth?? :lol:
Secularists do. They think "truth" can mean something subjective. Of course, I agree with you that that's stupid.
Often the opposite is the case. You find that many people prefer live by lies, and find it easier, than those who force themselves to face unpleasant truths. Look at Hollywood. Look at politics. Look at the press, and all those who prefer to believe the major networks are telling them the truth, rather than having to examine. Seeking truth is a lot of work; and when you find it, it's often hard to swallow.
If you did an analysis, then truth would be revealed to be much more prevalent.
You'll find it's quite the contrary, actually. And it really makes no difference which worldview you take to be "the truth," or closer to it. Whichever it is, you'd have to recognize that most of the world doesn't believe it; because there are so many ideologies around, with so many contrary "truth" stories, that any one of them is a minority taste.

So no, it's not at all the finding that "truth is more prevalent." What's obvious is that, whatever one believes, most are not believing that.
So again, if death ends all, why choose the harder, sadder path of truth, rather than the comforting delusion?
You already asked and I already answered.
But not effectively. The question returns, so soon as we discover that falsehoods are both more common and more preferred than truth.
No. I'm asking the question FROM AN ATHEIST PERSPECTIVE.
I have no idea why you would do that.
It's testing whether that perspective has anything to offer us. The best way to do that is to see where it leads, logically. That's what we're doing.
The question is ... Would you continue to believe in God and Christianity if you knew they were lies.
Did you not read my answer?

Re: ANNOUNCEMENT FROM IC

Posted: Thu Nov 19, 2026 3:12 pm
by phyllo
You repeat yourself and you avoid answering questions directed to you.

Okay in the abstract, specifying nobody in particular ...

Is it reasonable that if a person found out that God and Christianity are lies, that person would continue to believe? Is it even possible? That person would have construct some other lies as to why God and Christianity are not lies. Which in turn may require propping up by still more lies.