attofishpi wrote: ↑Mon Feb 07, 2022 9:13 am
Sculptor wrote: ↑Sun Feb 06, 2022 6:33 pm
According to Hume, a violation of natural law. ... , the evidence in favor of a miracle, even when that is provided by the strongest possible testimony, will always be outweighed by the evidence for the law of nature which is supposed to have been violated.
"I pronounce my decision, and always reject the greater miracle. If the falsehood of his testimony would be more miraculous, than the event which he relates; then, and not till then, can he pretend to command my belief or opinion." Hume Inquiry X,1
In other words it would take a miracle for Hume to believe one.
I don't consider what I know to exist - that there is an intelligence that makes what we perceive as reality - to be "supernatural" - in other words, there must be a valid reasonable explanation by the sciences (eventually) for IT. Ergo - I don't believe in 'miracles'
The 'valid reasonable explanation', 'by the sciences', for what you call 'IT' has ALREADY been EXPRESSED and SHOWN.
attofishpi wrote: ↑Mon Feb 07, 2022 9:13 am
..as per above, had Hume watched a TV and at his time, he may have considered it a miracle.
EXACTLY. And, until ANY one provides AN 'example' of a so-called 'miracle', then, and ONLY THEN, we have some 'thing' to LOOK AT and DISCUSS, in relation to this topic discussion.
attofishpi wrote: ↑Mon Feb 07, 2022 9:13 am
I asked Jori - the creator of this thread to define: Miracle.
And, DEFINING the words used in discussions is Truly HELPFUL in FINDING what thee ACTUAL and IRREFUTABLE Truth IS, EXACTLY.
To me, miracle interestingly sounds like Mirror_Coil --> coiling what we perceive.[/quote]
'miracle' can also be a combination of 'mira', meaning
peace, and 'acle' sounding like 'oracle', meaning
medium through which advice or prophecy is sought or found. Which could just mean; precognition of A Truly peaceful world, for Everyone, through some mediums seen as or known as 'miracles'.
But, then again, just about ANY 'thing' can be SEEN or HEARD through just about ALL 'things'.
attofishpi wrote: ↑Mon Feb 07, 2022 9:13 am
What I have witnessed as empirical evidence of a 3rd party-intelligence behind the construct of reality - I must say - I would be failing to comprehend it in any rational manner, had I had such experiences 3-400 years ago.
Are you able to comprehend 'it', in a rational manner, now?
If yes, then will you explain 'it' to us here now?
If no, then why not?
attofishpi wrote: ↑Mon Feb 07, 2022 9:13 am
Since I have witnessed
countless examples of what would typically be defined as "miracle" and it appears that definition requires defacing the 'natural laws' of at least physics, then I shall proceed..
The last "miracle" by firm of the qualia of sound and vision. Was within the week that the 3rd part intelligence that is behind the construct of reality (God\'God') was intent upon forcing me out of office work - to do art.
I was working in the city for a Jap IT company - NEC - 2017 - what they were and are up to for the Oz Govnt (facial recognition) is contrary to me and my cyberpunk tendencies. Nevertheless..
At 0630 in the midst of winter I was waiting for a bus. I saw a truck coming down the hill to where my bus-stop was - and there was a huge puddle in front of where I stood. I thought, that truck is going to drown me! - it had two lanes but was on the outer lane, where I stood. As the truck got nearer the driver moved to the right - to avoid the massive puddle. I put a thumbs up in case he viewed his read vision mirror.
Immediately after, I saw another truck barrowing down the hill in the same lane, I thought - unlikely this guy is going to move over and avoid the puddle, so I turned my back (wearing waterproofs from the legs up) ...it didn't happed, I turned my back with -wtf- in my head - the truck had disappeared.
SO.
Brains in a vat?
Divine reality?
I'm not so sure...Christ at least at the upper stage of reality - the Divine - is worth.Y ..of consideration.
So, what, exactly, was the ACTUAL purpose of a "disappearing truck", for you?
To you, could that "disappearing" (to you) "truck" be explained in a valid reasonable way, by the sciences, (eventually)?
Or, will that event ALWAYS remain 'explainable', to you?