Page 19 of 22

Re: Riots in the city of love

Posted: Wed Nov 18, 2026 4:09 pm
by Immanuel Can
Gary Childress wrote: ↑Wed Nov 18, 2026 12:23 pm
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Wed Nov 18, 2026 1:16 am
MikeNovack wrote: ↑Wed Nov 18, 2026 12:33 am

Initially students (like elsewhere). But in the case of Serbia, they managed to form a political party. And the Student List party has just displaced a populist regime that has been in power for many years. I don't think I need to present you with Serbian news of the last few years. I am sure you are capable of doing that research,
So it's completely different from what we're seeing now in France, Spain, Belgium, Czech Republic, Italy, etc. There, what started as a student protest is simply taken over by Unionists, environmentalists, Islamists, Communists...and just plain vandals and looters...and doesn't issue in any coherent political movement.

So it makes me wonder why you brought the Serbian situation up, in the first place. Apparently, it's not comparable.

So, back to my original question: what is the endgame for these rioters?
There is no "endgame". They see no reason to have hope.
Oh. So they're just destructive. It's just a pointless rage fit, you're saying?

It sure looks like that's right. But they also don't realize that they're going to slit their own throats. Because endgame or none, an end will come out of the riots...some state of affairs will obtain, the minute the dust settles and the fires go out.

I just want to know how they envisage that outcome...for good or bad. I wonder what they suppose it is...what it will look like. Because I'm pretty sure I know, or at least have the best guess; and I want to know if they know where they're headed, or whether they're just madly careening down a road to misery.

Re: Riots in the city of love

Posted: Wed Nov 18, 2026 4:46 pm
by Immanuel Can
promethean75 wrote: ↑Wed Nov 18, 2026 12:46 pm It's not logically impossible for good things to exist without there being a god, btw.
Quite right...or more precisely, it's not possible for the concept "good" to have any substantive content without there being a God.

But maybe this is what has so confused them... that they are still searching for god and losing patience? Are these rioters the Lieutenant Dan type shaking their fists at god and shouting, "How can you allow this?!" when they can't afford their groceries? We'll then, that is precisely their problem, sir. Their war is not with god but with the capitalist.[/quote]
It's easy for them to make a mistake, though: to think they are going to war with men, when what they're really doing is resenting the God who allowed those men to exist. So it's not only possible, but common, for it to end up being both they are fighting.
'God' was merely a concept inserted by the ancient capitalist to keep you confused.
Not possible. Belief in God vastly predates any sort of "capitalism."
Besides, what kind of god wouldn't side with these rioters... and would you want to worship such a thing?
Ah, you see the natural transition? You've just reproduced it, essentially saying, "Any god who wouldn't side with the rioters is a bad God, who should not be worshipped."

But why would that be? The rioters, we have noted, seem to have no endgame, no hope, and no point. They're merely indulging a petulant hissy fit, completely unthinking of what is to come. They're purely destructive, it seems, with no formed or creative intention at all. They're just emoting, we have said.

Why would you want a god like that? :shock:

Re: Riots in the city of love

Posted: Wed Nov 18, 2026 4:49 pm
by Immanuel Can
phyllo wrote: ↑Wed Nov 18, 2026 12:51 pm The endgame is clear:

Destroy Western civilization.

Setup an Islamic theocracy with Sharia law.

Take all wealth from the white people.

Live luxuriously as kings with white slaves.
This is exactly what the Islamists seem to be aiming at. I agree.

But of course, the rioters aren't just composed of Islamists, but also of Socialists, Unionists, Environmentalists, students, etc. So we have to wonder what these non-Islamist groups think is going to happen when the bulwark against Islamism presented by secular, Western civilization is destroyed. What will the next state look like?

One thing we can be sure of: without a new spasm of horrible violence, it won't end up being Socialist, or Unionist, or Environmentalist...

Re: Riots in the city of love

Posted: Wed Nov 18, 2026 4:52 pm
by Immanuel Can
promethean75 wrote: ↑Wed Nov 18, 2026 1:03 pm I've actually become a little less outraged when I reflect on the tragic irony of the history of the biblical religions and how they are responsible for almost all of the nightmare the world is experiencing right now.
Um...no.

Islamists are not "biblical." They're Quranic. And no "biblical religions" are even involved in the present conflict: it's various secular groups hell-bent on killing each other.

It's secularism that is primarily actually responsible for "almost all the nightmare," and it has been for over a century now. None of the 20th C. wars was religious, and this conflict is between the Quranic and the secular.

Re: Riots in the city of love

Posted: Wed Nov 18, 2026 7:08 pm
by MikeNovack
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Wed Nov 18, 2026 4:52 pm Islamists are not "biblical." They're Quranic. And no "biblical religions" are even involved in the present conflict: it's various secular groups hell-bent on killing each other.
IC, look up the concept in Islam of "the people of the book" (in al Quran and in both traditions of Hadith). Also how the Bible is considered (the original revelation, corrupted over time by the Jews and the Christians)

Take a look at Islam IN GENERAL and not through your narrow lens "at the moment, radical Islam is important" << not the first time -- from the time in the 11th-12th Centuries we get the word "assassin" >> The point is that even now, large segments of the Muslim world are uninvolved with this radical (and violent) revival.

Re: Riots in the city of love

Posted: Wed Nov 18, 2026 7:12 pm
by promethean75
Lol Islam wouldn't even exist if not for Judaism.

All three biblical root religions are the product of hijacking other myths existing prior to themselves. Judaism is coming out of a mishmash of Sumerian, Egyptian, and Greek mythology, astrology, and hermeticism.

Each of the three religions produced a series of honest megalomaniacs (or insincere frauds) that would pretend to be various foretold messiahs, prophets, and important figures to come... ideas they picked up from the myths that were borrowed from.

Re: Riots in the city of love

Posted: Wed Nov 18, 2026 7:17 pm
by promethean75
Warning to Jews. Be careful when making up shit about being chosen people and inventing religions. Your neighbor might find your Bible and get some big ideas of their own coughIslamcough.

Re: Riots in the city of love

Posted: Wed Nov 18, 2026 8:37 pm
by Immanuel Can
MikeNovack wrote: ↑Wed Nov 18, 2026 7:08 pm
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Wed Nov 18, 2026 4:52 pm Islamists are not "biblical." They're Quranic. And no "biblical religions" are even involved in the present conflict: it's various secular groups hell-bent on killing each other.
IC, look up the concept in Islam of "the people of the book" (in al Quran and in both traditions of Hadith)...
...is an extremely stupid concept, believed only by those who know nothing about Islam. There is no "book" the Islamists regard in common with Christians and Jews -- as you point out, they claim that the "book" the Christians and Jews have is "corrupted," though they have no evidence at all that such has ever happened.

Don't lump all "religious" people into the same boat. It's ignorant and prejudiced, and betrays a lack of knowledge of the "religions" being considered. It's also very dangerous for you.
The point is that even now, large segments of the Muslim world are uninvolved with this radical (and violent) revival.
No, that's really NOT the point. It will make no difference, if Islam teaches violence: and you know it does.

See, this is the Western arrogance, the Western mistake: to think that all "religions," when rightly analzyed, will turn out to be some form of liberalism. It's not even remotely the case. But liberals believe it with fervent stupidity, flying in the face of all the facts.

Nice Mo, the guy from down your street, is no threat, maybe. But Ali, his cousin, is a psychotic Islamist, who would happily slit your throat, if he could. And let's say there are ten Nice Mo's for every psychotic Ali. That's too high a ratio, but let's play along.

The real point is, what will happen when psychotic Ali tries to kill you? The answer is that Mo will do nothing, because Mo is Islamic, and so is Ali. So Nice Mo won't kill you; but neither will Nice Mo prevent Ali from killing you. He'll stay quiet, and play low-key. And Ali will be doing what Islam actually requires and commands, Sharia, and following the Koran and Haddiths. Ali is, so far as Muslims see it, the "real" Muslim, because he's crazy enough to kill and to die for Islam. He's a hero, in their viewpoint, deserving of 72 perpetual rape victims to abuse for all eternity, in Muslim heaven.

So Nice Mo will be regarded, even by other Muslims, as a corrupted, Westernized Muslim, because he doesn't have Ali's passion or fervour for Sharia. He doesn't deserve any virgins to rape. And Nice Mo will be brought-to-heel by the rest of the Islamists, because he knows exactly what awaits him, if he resists them; it will be very much the same as what happened for you. Mo's niceness, at the end of the day, will be of absolutely no benefit to you and will be a danger to him.

That's how Islam rolls. If you don't know it, then you're laying your own head on the chopping block.

Re: Riots in the city of love

Posted: Wed Nov 18, 2026 8:40 pm
by Immanuel Can
promethean75 wrote: ↑Wed Nov 18, 2026 7:12 pm Lol Islam wouldn't even exist if not for Judaism.
You don't know Islam, obviously. Islamists claim the Jewish Scriptures are all corrupt, even though they aren't. (Islam can't produce a manuscript tradition for this allegation, but it's fervently believed among them.) So Islam is putting no stock at all in the Jewish Scriptures. Rather, Islam derives from a desert tribal cult, let by a guy named Mohammed.

A little research would fix your bad information on that. You've actually fallen prey to propaganda on that.

Re: Riots in the city of love

Posted: Wed Nov 18, 2026 9:35 pm
by MikeNovack
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Wed Nov 18, 2026 8:40 pm You don't know Islam, obviously. Islamists claim the Jewish Scriptures are all corrupt, even though they aren't.
Absolutely wrong.

Islam claims the Jewish scriptures and the Christian scriptures ARE true revelations from God, but that over time the Jews and the Christians have come to corrupt how they should be interpreted. The revelation of al Quran is supposed to correct that.

Re: Riots in the city of love

Posted: Wed Nov 18, 2026 9:44 pm
by Immanuel Can
MikeNovack wrote: ↑Wed Nov 18, 2026 9:35 pm
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Wed Nov 18, 2026 8:40 pm You don't know Islam, obviously. Islamists claim the Jewish Scriptures are all corrupt, even though they aren't.
Absolutely wrong.
??? What? :shock: You know so little about Islam that you can think that? :shock:

They're not shy about that claim, you know. They'll quite happily tell you themselves.
Islam claims the Jewish scriptures and the Christian scriptures ARE true revelations from God, but that over time the Jews and the Christians have come to corrupt how they should be interpreted. The revelation of al Quran is supposed to correct that.
Have you not noticed?

This amounts to exactly the same thing -
- whatever you Jews and we Christians have is "corrupt" and "not the true revelation." And the Koran, which conflicts in many obvious ways with both, is supposed to be the new "final revelation" that replaces everything Jews and Christians know as their own Scriptures. So whatever Islamists mean when they say "Torah" or "New Testament," turns out to be mythical documents nobody have ever seen...including Jews and Christians.

This leaves only Koran as decisive, for them. About Torah and the New Testament, they are able to believe only as much as Mo himself affirmed, and they can say anything but what Mo affirmed is part of the "corruption."

You can't be naive enough to think they actually care about the actual Torah or the actual NT, can you? No, they only care about Koran, to which their imagine the "original Torah," whatever they mean by that, was in complete harmony, allegedly, before the nasty Jews corrupted it, allegedly. And similarly the NT -- the Christians "corrupted" it.

In neither case do they mean anything you and I would recognize as the Torah or NT.

But here's an interesting slip Mo made: he grounded his own authority in Torah and the NT. If it turns out -- as indeed it does -- that there is no such imaginary "pre-corruption" tradition of documents, then Mo's own credibility is at stake -- by his own testimony.

Re: Riots in the city of love

Posted: Thu Nov 19, 2026 12:28 am
by MikeNovack
This is almost useless, IC. You are unable to see what Islam actually says.

Islam does not say the TEXTS are corrupt. Just that Jews and Christians have become corrupt in how they understand/interpret those texts. Al Quran is supposed to be a a new version of revelation to be easier to understand/interpret . That's why, "must be read in the original Arabic" << in translation would lead to misunderstanding/corruption >>

If you don't understand Muslim thinking on this, remember they knew both the Jews and the Christians were reading texts written in a language (now) different than their own. So not crazy for them to associate misinterpretation/corruption to translation.

Keep in mind that Jews consider how Christians misinterpret prophecies from the Prophets "corruption of text"

Re: Riots in the city of love

Posted: Thu Nov 19, 2026 12:54 am
by Immanuel Can
MikeNovack wrote: ↑Thu Nov 19, 2026 12:28 am You are unable to see what Islam actually says.
Have you read the Koran? Do you know any Haddiths? Do you know any Islamic people? Have you lived among them? I have. So tell me: who doesn't know what he's talking about?
Islam does not say the TEXTS are corrupt. Just that Jews and Christians have become corrupt in how they understand/interpret those texts.
In point of fact, they do insist that the texts have been corrupted, AND ALSO that they are misinterpreted by Christians and Jews. Either way, the effect is the same: Muslims do not regard themselves as having to follow any text but the Koran; and if the Torah and the NT depart from the Koran, there is never any question that the Koran and the Haddiths take priority in interpretation.
Al Quran is supposed to be a a new version of revelation to be easier to understand/interpret . That's why, "must be read in the original Arabic" << in translation would lead to misunderstanding/corruption >>
This creates another problem for Mo and co. That is, that Mo had to prove he was a prophet, and a prophet must perform an attesting miracle. The Islamists say the miracle that attests to Mo is the Koran itself. But two problems: one, Mo didn't write the Koran, but two, if it's only readable in Arabic, then no non-Arabic person can regard Mo as a prophet, because they can receive no attesting miracle. :shock:
So not crazy for them to associate misinterpretation/corruption to translation.
I can tell you haven't read the Koran. If you had, you'd know how bad it is, how poor Mo's memory for Torah was, how many particulars he simply got wrong, and how many ways it contradicts radically both Torah and the NT. But your comment suggests you've never checked.

Mo didn't have a problem of interpretation: he had a bad memory, and a whole lot of manipulative intentions. He got so much wrong it's really amazing to see.

Go and read the Koran (I apologize in advance for how painful and stupid you're going to find that experience, but you apparently need it).

Re: Riots in the city of love

Posted: Thu Nov 19, 2026 6:57 am
by Gary Childress
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Wed Nov 18, 2026 4:09 pm
Gary Childress wrote: ↑Wed Nov 18, 2026 12:23 pm
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Wed Nov 18, 2026 1:16 am
So it's completely different from what we're seeing now in France, Spain, Belgium, Czech Republic, Italy, etc. There, what started as a student protest is simply taken over by Unionists, environmentalists, Islamists, Communists...and just plain vandals and looters...and doesn't issue in any coherent political movement.

So it makes me wonder why you brought the Serbian situation up, in the first place. Apparently, it's not comparable.

So, back to my original question: what is the endgame for these rioters?
There is no "endgame". They see no reason to have hope.
Oh. So they're just destructive. It's just a pointless rage fit, you're saying?

It sure looks like that's right. But they also don't realize that they're going to slit their own throats. Because endgame or none, an end will come out of the riots...some state of affairs will obtain, the minute the dust settles and the fires go out.

I just want to know how they envisage that outcome...for good or bad. I wonder what they suppose it is...what it will look like. Because I'm pretty sure I know, or at least have the best guess; and I want to know if they know where they're headed, or whether they're just madly careening down a road to misery.
Maybe you should tell those low-class dregs to "eat cake"? When the world goes to shit, I'll suffer with the rest of those relatively fortunate by comparison. But I'll at least be able to say that I warned people to do more for society's outcasts, as they put the noose around my neck.

Re: Riots in the city of love

Posted: Thu Nov 19, 2026 1:32 pm
by Immanuel Can
Gary Childress wrote: ↑Thu Nov 19, 2026 6:57 am
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Wed Nov 18, 2026 4:09 pm
Gary Childress wrote: ↑Wed Nov 18, 2026 12:23 pm

There is no "endgame". They see no reason to have hope.
Oh. So they're just destructive. It's just a pointless rage fit, you're saying?

It sure looks like that's right. But they also don't realize that they're going to slit their own throats. Because endgame or none, an end will come out of the riots...some state of affairs will obtain, the minute the dust settles and the fires go out.

I just want to know how they envisage that outcome...for good or bad. I wonder what they suppose it is...what it will look like. Because I'm pretty sure I know, or at least have the best guess; and I want to know if they know where they're headed, or whether they're just madly careening down a road to misery.
Maybe you should tell those low-class dregs to "eat cake"?
I'm not telling them anything. I'm asking them what they think they're going to cause to happen.

What do you think they think they're doing, Gary? How do you see their actions working out?