MikeNovack wrote: ↑Fri Nov 13, 2026 4:54 pm
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Fri Nov 13, 2026 2:51 pm
So what you've told me seems to be that Pandora's Box offers no metanarrative at all...which I already knew. But I wonder if you realized it, since you didn't seem to recognize the distinction between mere story and metanarrative.
Sorry IC, but what I was ignoring was a culture having (among its stories) a metanarrative.
Again, this seems to miss the point of what a "metanarrative" is. What makes it a "meta-narrative" is that it presides over and above all the subordinate "stories" a culture might have, organizes them, provides their larger context of meaning, and points them toward a teleology of some kind that is actionable by living people.
In other words, if it's not a story that has the significance to change your whole worldview, then it's not really a metanarrative. It's some lesser kind of story.
I do not recognize a COLLECTION of stories to be a single story/metanarrative.
Good for you, because that's not what a metanarrative is.
For example, the Bible is often described as a metanarrative
That would be incorrect. The Bible isn't even entirely narrative, for that matter. It contains didactic stuff, poetry, history, theology, prophecy, and other genres. But within it, a metanarrative that brackets all that exists: the poetry, the prophecy, the laws, etc. all coalesce around a particular grand "story" or metanarrative, that sweeps all the way from the origins of life to the end of chronological history, and directs the whole toward a teleological plan. So it's not that the Bible IS a metanarrative, but it certainly
presents and
advocates one.
Pharisee (too early, it would be after the lifetime of Jesus when they first came into power)
"The Pharisees emerged in Palestine during the Second Temple period, around 165–160 BCE, shortly after the Maccabean Revolt." -- Britannica.
That's in plenty of time to be around during the time of Jesus Christ...over a century and a half, in fact. And the Bible records their power-struggles with the Sadducees, too, and what their main theological differences were over. (Acts 23:7-8)
Seems it got that right.