Page 18 of 18

Re: Can't both be right?

Posted: Sun Nov 08, 2026 10:23 pm
by Immanuel Can
Alexis Jacobi wrote: ↑Sun Nov 08, 2026 7:44 pm Generally, in theology, we deal in stories that have come down to us, not those that we actually discovered for ourselves.
What every meta-story tries to do is to narrate reality. In that sense, they're all attempts at "discovery" of something that pre-exists...reality itself.

Re: Can't both be right?

Posted: Wed Nov 11, 2026 11:41 pm
by FlashDangerpants
Alexis Jacobi wrote: ↑Sun Nov 08, 2026 6:42 pm
FlashDangerpants wrote: ↑Sun Nov 08, 2026 6:26 pm I've only been telling you why you (plural) are losing to IC. Talking mystical woo with nazis isn't one of my interests.
Then you can well understand why discussing matters of metaphysics with a perverted freako always turns out to be a dead-end.
Because you don't really know what any of the words mean. You have no education and your ability to learn is compromised.

Weirdly the only term you routinely get right is "a priori" which is the one IC was accusing you of not understanding a while ago.

Re: Can't both be right?

Posted: Thu Nov 12, 2026 12:19 am
by Alexis Jacobi
FlashDangerpants wrote: ↑Wed Nov 11, 2026 11:41 pm Weirdly the only term you routinely get right is "a priori" which is the one IC was accusing you of not understanding a while ago.
Allah be Praised!

I would like to beat on you some, don’t get me wrong, I just don’t have the time right now!

Re: Can't both be right?

Posted: Thu Nov 12, 2026 1:02 am
by MikeNovack
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Sun Nov 08, 2026 10:23 pm What every meta-story tries to do is to narrate reality. In that sense, they're all attempts at "discovery" of something that pre-exists...reality itself.
Not necessarily. Something real/meaningful, not necessarily that EXISTS anywhere.

You'll want an example. Take the myth of Pandora and the box of evils. What is it ABOUT? Well it is asking us to consider a question about the human condition. Namely, is hope a good or an evil. You might think of hope as being real, but not something having an existence anywhere.

Or the stories might be explanations of WHY things are the way they are n the material world (the material realm has no "why")

Re: Can't both be right?

Posted: Thu Nov 12, 2026 10:32 am
by FlashDangerpants
Alexis Jacobi wrote: ↑Thu Nov 12, 2026 12:19 am
FlashDangerpants wrote: ↑Wed Nov 11, 2026 11:41 pm Weirdly the only term you routinely get right is "a priori" which is the one IC was accusing you of not understanding a while ago.
Allah be Praised!

I would like to beat on you some, don’t get me wrong, I just don’t have the time right now!
That sounds gay. Please don't do whatever that is.

Re: Can't both be right?

Posted: Thu Nov 12, 2026 4:23 pm
by Immanuel Can
MikeNovack wrote: ↑Thu Nov 12, 2026 1:02 am
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Sun Nov 08, 2026 10:23 pm What every meta-story tries to do is to narrate reality. In that sense, they're all attempts at "discovery" of something that pre-exists...reality itself.
Not necessarily. Something real/meaningful, not necessarily that EXISTS anywhere.
It depends on what you mean by "meaningful."

The story of Goldilocks and the Three Bears has "meaning." But it's not the sort of meaning by which one can order a life. It is, at most, a sententious pronouncement on the inadvisability of home-invasions. So there, "meaning" is not at all of the quality or extent we mean when we (or Lyotard) speak of a "metanarrative."

A "metanarrative" is more than a story. It's an overarching, all-embracing kind of narrative, presupposing a re-ordering of human meaning and priorities. Metanarratives are stories by which people actually aim to live, not merely to entertain themselves, or even to inform themselves of some pithy little point, whether about material reality or something else. They are actual attempts to redescribe reality...and with such consequence that a person can re-order his entire life and priorities by them.

As such, they present as a better explanation of reality itself, rather than merely as a local fictional construct.

Re: Can't both be right?

Posted: Thu Nov 12, 2026 7:06 pm
by MikeNovack
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Thu Nov 12, 2026 4:23 pm
Not necessarily. Something real/meaningful, not necessarily that EXISTS anywhere. [/quote]
It depends on what you mean by "meaningful."

The story of Goldilocks and the Three Bears has "meaning." But it's not the sort of meaning by which one can order a life.
[/quote]

????? (though "Goldilocks" is NOT about "home invasion") I gave you an example "story", one you consider "false" (a story from a society with many gods). Discuss THAT story. Do you claim it is not about something fundamental to our human lives? And how we should live them? My example story is not one providing "the answer" (as some do) but provoking the question << about hope >>

Re: Can't both be right?

Posted: Thu Nov 12, 2026 7:11 pm
by Immanuel Can
MikeNovack wrote: ↑Thu Nov 12, 2026 7:06 pm I gave you an example "story", one you consider "false" (a story from a society with many gods). Discuss THAT story.
No problem.
Do you claim it is not about something fundamental to our human lives? And how we should live them?
Sure, I'll hear about that.

What metanarrative do you perceive to be derivable from Pandora?

Re: Can't both be right?

Posted: Fri Nov 13, 2026 5:48 am
by MikeNovack
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Thu Nov 12, 2026 7:11 pm
What metanarrative do you perceive to be derivable from Pandora?
"Pandora's Box" is not a story giving an answer, it is a story posing a question. It is asking you to think about, discuss, decide. If you have read that story and don't see the question, you are not going to be able to deal with myth/stories not from within your tradition

You might do better with a story from the only text you recognize as legitimate. Let's try one.

"The Sword of Solomon" -- you know the story, so I won't repeat. Solomon said that he had determined who the real mother of the child was and rules that way. How do you understand that? Did he mean which prostitute really gave birth to the child? Or which was the real/proper mother to care for that child?

Re: Can't both be right?

Posted: Fri Nov 13, 2026 2:51 pm
by Immanuel Can
MikeNovack wrote: ↑Fri Nov 13, 2026 5:48 am
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Thu Nov 12, 2026 7:11 pm What metanarrative do you perceive to be derivable from Pandora?
"Pandora's Box" is not a story giving an answer, it is a story posing a question.
That only says it's not a metanarrative.

A metanarrative isn't just a story, or a myth, or even what we call a "narrative" per se.

In Lyotard's analysis (and he popularized the concept, so he should know), the "meta" addition signifies a comprehensive, totalizing, overarching kind of story, one that rationalizes a teleology or purpose, and thus offers a pattern for reorganization of an entire society or way of life. One cannot reorganize an entire society or way of life on cyphers. It takes definite answers, and of such a sweeping kind that a single parable, myth, analogy or story cannot possibly serve the purpose.

So what you've told me seems to be that Pandora's Box offers no metanarrative at all...which I already knew. But I wonder if you realized it, since you didn't seem to recognize the distinction between mere story and metanarrative. :?

Re: Can't both be right?

Posted: Fri Nov 13, 2026 4:54 pm
by MikeNovack
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Fri Nov 13, 2026 2:51 pm So what you've told me seems to be that Pandora's Box offers no metanarrative at all...which I already knew. But I wonder if you realized it, since you didn't seem to recognize the distinction between mere story and metanarrative. :?
Sorry IC, but what I was ignoring was a culture having (among its stories) a metanarrative. Might have JUST a collection of stories not including one central story serving as a metanarative. Or rather I do not recognize a COLLECTION of stories to be a single story/metanarrative.

For example, the Bible is often described as a metanarrative --- but that means accepting its origin as a single story. I do not. And I think this is more or less provable (that it is collection) because clearly some bits/stories were taken in so long after their origin that the stories dealt with cultural practices long forgotten << in other words, the story ~1000 years older than its addition to the collection >>

OR this works in reverse, a story gets told/modified to fit the time when written/compiled (not the time the story is set in). Thus in the Gospels, Jesus is described interacting with Pharisees clearly meaning "of a faction in power" while in reality couldn't have met an "in power" Pharisee (too early, it would be after the lifetime of Jesus when they first came into power) << I think the explanation is that those who composed the Gospels were familiar with Pharisees being in power and forgot the Sadducees (who were the faction in power at the time and who otherwise Jesus appears to be fighting with -- what's more, if you understand what the Pharisees and Sadducess were disputing, you see Jesus is on the Pharisee side of the arguments) >>

Re: Can't both be right?

Posted: Fri Nov 13, 2026 7:44 pm
by Immanuel Can
MikeNovack wrote: ↑Fri Nov 13, 2026 4:54 pm
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Fri Nov 13, 2026 2:51 pm So what you've told me seems to be that Pandora's Box offers no metanarrative at all...which I already knew. But I wonder if you realized it, since you didn't seem to recognize the distinction between mere story and metanarrative. :?
Sorry IC, but what I was ignoring was a culture having (among its stories) a metanarrative.
Again, this seems to miss the point of what a "metanarrative" is. What makes it a "meta-narrative" is that it presides over and above all the subordinate "stories" a culture might have, organizes them, provides their larger context of meaning, and points them toward a teleology of some kind that is actionable by living people.

In other words, if it's not a story that has the significance to change your whole worldview, then it's not really a metanarrative. It's some lesser kind of story.
I do not recognize a COLLECTION of stories to be a single story/metanarrative.
Good for you, because that's not what a metanarrative is.
For example, the Bible is often described as a metanarrative
That would be incorrect. The Bible isn't even entirely narrative, for that matter. It contains didactic stuff, poetry, history, theology, prophecy, and other genres. But within it, a metanarrative that brackets all that exists: the poetry, the prophecy, the laws, etc. all coalesce around a particular grand "story" or metanarrative, that sweeps all the way from the origins of life to the end of chronological history, and directs the whole toward a teleological plan. So it's not that the Bible IS a metanarrative, but it certainly presents and advocates one.
Pharisee (too early, it would be after the lifetime of Jesus when they first came into power)
"The Pharisees emerged in Palestine during the Second Temple period, around 165–160 BCE, shortly after the Maccabean Revolt." -- Britannica.

That's in plenty of time to be around during the time of Jesus Christ...over a century and a half, in fact. And the Bible records their power-struggles with the Sadducees, too, and what their main theological differences were over. (Acts 23:7-8)

Seems it got that right.