Alexis Jacobi wrote: ↑Sun Nov 08, 2026 11:24 am
The spiritual doctrine of Maya states that because we are in a fallen condition (trapped in Nature and processes that are mindless and amoral) we are always inclined to be duped by our own needs and desires to sacrifice those principles that are metaphysical to material life.
It's not so much a "fallen" condition as an
evicted one. Human beings are cast out of the divine and imprisoned in the physical world, which is
maya...delusory. Maya's a gnostic idea...that the "transcendent" is good, and the physical is a trap. It's dualistic and contemptuous of the natural world. As such, it cannot coexist with Atheism, because Atheism needs our belief in the absolute trustworthiness of the physical world, and its absolute sufficiency for drawing conclusions...as well as our uncritical trust of the Atheist's own limited experience of that world, so that we come to accept that the fact that HE knows no gods is sufficient warrant for us to believe we ought to believe no gods exist.
Christianity is not dualistic, at all. Rather, the created world was created good (Gen. 1, repeatedly so) -- but is now temporarily fallen -- and is restorable, as well. Unlike in gnosticism, the natural world even retains intimations of the existence and nature of God (Romans 1), and is not going to be eradicated but delivered from its fallen condition (Rm. 8:21-13, for example, or Is. 65:17, or 2 Pet. 3:13...etc.).
So Christianity is neither gnostic nor dualistic. It foresees a permanent role for the created world, but not as it presently is, but rather in a restored condition.
If I can risk putting the case bluntly, I think that what's happening is that, not really knowing Christian doctrine, you're projecting Hinduism or Buddhism onto it, and then assuming it's the same. This is the old mistake, though; common as it is, it's untrue -- particularly popular among Westerners who don't really want to have to engage religions in any serious way, and prefer a dilatory relationship to one "tradition" as an explanation for every other "tradition". It comes off as superficially "tolerant" and "open," but really ends up being contemptuous of all other "traditions," as I shall shortly explain.
Religions actually have their own features that make them different from each other -- areas in which they flatly contradict and are not at all compatible. It is these distinctions which religious people value most, in fact: for why should you believe my religion, or I believe yours, if neither of them has any distinct feature, advantage, or nuance to offer that any other religion simply does not? And how is it not insulting to all religions to pretend that none of them have any worthwhile distinctives, and that any differences are just superficial? And how can you recommend this sort of uninformed inclusivism, if such inclusivism itself offers no distinctive or advantage over exclusivism?
So you see, it's just not coherent to believe that, and it undermines your own ability to recommend your own system. If yours is not better than mine, in some important way, then why should you advise me to believe you? So you can't even believe in such inclusivism...or you can't recommend inclusivism.
But as I say, it all runs afoul of the Law of Non-Contradiction, as well. And that's the impartial referee that shows that such Westernized, comfortable inclusivism is simply nonsense. It's really failure to understand anything about these various options-for-belief.