Re: Music
Posted: Mon Sep 12, 2016 3:58 pm
I told you I thought Liberace was an excellent pianist who sold his soul. Why all the violins and accompaniments? He also has some kind of spasm at 1:56. Otherwise he does an ok, if not particularly sensitive job, apart from all the tasteless fluff he's added.
He did cut it a bit short, and I did notice a few errors, not sure if they were intentional.vegetariantaxidermy wrote:I told you I thought Liberace was an excellent pianist who sold his soul. Why all the violins and accompaniments? He also has some kind of spasm at 1:56. Otherwise he does an ok, if not particularly sensitive job, apart from all the tasteless fluff he's added.
Richard Clayderman:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=U21Ts_FfRU4
Spot the deliberate mistakes. Apparently Clayderman thinks he can improve on Beethoven.
I have seen musicians who will take a solo piece and add other instruments making an orchestral work out of it. If you have an orchestra at your disposal, why not give them something to do? It doesn't make the piece better or worse, just different.vegetariantaxidermy wrote: I told you I thought Liberace was an excellent pianist who sold his soul. Why all the violins and accompaniments?
Yeah, to cover up their own bullshit bad playing or to cater to morons. It's not possible to underestimate the taste of the general public.thedoc wrote:I have seen musicians who will take a solo piece and add other instruments making an orchestral work out of it.vegetariantaxidermy wrote: I told you I thought Liberace was an excellent pianist who sold his soul. Why all the violins and accompaniments?
Just curious, what is your opinion of Andre Rieu?vegetariantaxidermy wrote: Yeah, to cover up their own bullshit bad playing or to cater to morons. It's not possible to underestimate the taste of the general public.
You mean that guy who makes Liberace look subdued and tasteful? I'm not a fan of schmaltz over substance. I don't need fountains, gold carriages, fake snow and an old lady's wet dream to enjoy music. I really don't think music is so 'inaccessible' that people are forced to go to this kind of extreme. How is Barenboim's 'Moonlight' less 'accessible' than Clayderman's? Those people are there for the spectacle--the actual music is secondary (and second rate).thedoc wrote:Just curious, what is your opinion of Andre Rieu?vegetariantaxidermy wrote: Yeah, to cover up their own bullshit bad playing or to cater to morons. It's not possible to underestimate the taste of the general public.
vegetariantaxidermy wrote:You mean that guy who makes Liberace look subdued and tasteful? I'm not a fan of schmaltz over substance. I don't need fountains, gold carriages, fake snow and an old lady's wet dream to enjoy music. I really don't think music is so 'inaccessible' that people are forced to go to this kind of extreme. How is Barenboim's 'Moonlight' less 'accessible' than Clayderman's? Those people are there for the spectacle--the actual music is secondary (and second rate).thedoc wrote:Just curious, what is your opinion of Andre Rieu?vegetariantaxidermy wrote: Yeah, to cover up their own bullshit bad playing or to cater to morons. It's not possible to underestimate the taste of the general public.
You can tune a piano? That's pretty cool. I have a beautiful set of tuning tools, but I haven't quite been able to bring myself to give it a go.thedoc wrote:
I wouldn't go quite that far, but I do agree that he isn't more than a mediocre Violinist who has assembled an orchestra that plays the popular and familiar to an uneducated audience. Though I do appreciate some of his renditions of the familiar and popular pieces, even if they are a bit abreviated, and I will state again that he introduces people to works that they might not have listened to before. Some of us are more sophisticated than others, but that doesn't mean that the others should be denied the popular access to the better that is available. I once worked with a person who refused to listen to a recording that was less than perfect, yet I had a recording of "Peter and the Wolf" that was taken of an old 78 vinyl disc, and the sound was much less than even good, but I still listened to it.
FYI, right now I'm waiting for the weather to change and the humidity to drop just a little. I tried to tune my piano, which was running a bit sharp, and found that the pin block was a bit tight and I couldn't bring the strings into proper tune. I'm hoping that when the pin block dries out a little, the tuning pins will be a bit easier to get just right. Instead of moving smoothly, the pins tended to pop from one position to another, and never just right.