Page 12 of 18

Re: Can't both be right?

Posted: Wed Nov 04, 2026 12:55 pm
by Alexis Jacobi
So in my view, once you (a person, we) have seen the religious zealot in full operation, once you have seen the devious rhetorical tricks, the evasions, and as I say the dishonesty in operation, you recoil from it because it has implications for the structure of our own positions.

It’s like watching something as crude and manipulative as televangelism on the TV screen. It is insulting to what we conceive of as “intelligence” and it reveals something akin to ‘the reptilian mind’ that is easy to capture and sway. The modality of “mass religion” and pre-digested theology-bits that are employed so vulgarly nauseate.

What then occurs in the mind and also the spirit (if the word can be used here)? What occurs is demoralization. It actually destroys that conceptual path to what is described as, or felt to be, transcendent and sacred. These exist in art, poetry, literature and also in religious expression, but here? Come now!

Whatever the method pursued here among stunningly potent “philosophes” is pretty much like dogshit you scoop up and bury in the backyard.

And so the question that comes to the fore is: What do we do in this situation? But what is the situation? That in my view is what the conversation is about. If it does not deal on expresdions of principle, on genuine issues of value, then what is it really about?

Surely we can dismiss the game-playing though? Yes?

Re: Can't both be right?

Posted: Wed Nov 04, 2026 1:13 pm
by Alexis Jacobi
Alexis Jacobi wrote:IC, stop all this play-acting. I cannot take you seriously.
Flash wrote:I can't take him seriously. Willy B can't take him seriously. Mcstinky can't either. In truth, Impenitent likely doesn't.

You are not in any position to take seriously or not to. You don't have the basic knowledge to play this game.
But here is the real issue, the most fundamental issue: IC presents as an extremely defective apologist for a series of “pictures” that he presents, behind which there is a threat of total perdition and violent cruelty perpetrated on the soul. It is a vulgar and insidious game. It has no apologetic value — meaning: it does not elucidate, explain nor convince anyone. He has turned himself into a mechanism.

And all of you puffed-up braying jack-asses, with your varying degrees of philosophy-accomplishment, get stuck in your own vain rehearsals. And in my view you-plural completely miss the point. In fact I have all of the qualifications to clarify what really is under discussion. You are not even in the conversation!

And so the conversation can only be about attempting to define what really is at stake when religion, of the Bible, or theology, and of course spirituality and the transcendent are discussed among honest participants whose object is to be productive.

Re: Can't both be right?

Posted: Wed Nov 04, 2026 1:41 pm
by FlashDangerpants
Alexis Jacobi wrote: ↑Wed Nov 04, 2026 1:13 pm
Alexis Jacobi wrote:IC, stop all this play-acting. I cannot take you seriously.
Flash wrote:I can't take him seriously. Willy B can't take him seriously. Mcstinky can't either. In truth, Impenitent likely doesn't.

You are not in any position to take seriously or not to. You don't have the basic knowledge to play this game.
But here is the real issue, the most fundamental issue: IC presents as an extremely defective apologist for a series of “pictures” that he presents, behind which there is a threat of total perdition and violent cruelty perpetrated on the soul. It is a vulgar and insidious game. It has no apologetic value — meaning: it does not elucidate, explain nor convince anyone. He has turned himself into a mechanism.

And all of you puffed-up braying jack-asses, with your varying degrees of philosophy-accomplishment, get stuck in your own vain rehearsals. And in my view you-plural completely miss the point. In fact I have all of the qualifications to clarify what really is under discussion. You are not even in the conversation!

And so the conversation can only be about attempting to define what really is at stake when religion, of the Bible, or theology, and of course spirituality and the transcendent are discussed among honest participants whose object is to be productive.
That's funny. With the exception of Fanman, everyone else knows what you are an extremely defective apologist for. So can it Hitler boy.

Re: Can't both be right?

Posted: Wed Nov 04, 2026 2:25 pm
by Fanman
Alexis Jacobi wrote: ↑Wed Nov 04, 2026 12:11 pm
Fanman wrote: ↑Wed Nov 04, 2026 3:41 am Alexis, I have distilled our conversation to one axiom-like expression:

Human aspirations of higher states ≈ Transcendent ideals ≈ Elevated mental state ≈ Divine analogue

Let me know what you think.
I see your statement, if this is not obvious, as a way of arranging your own position in respect to this thing we label “divinity”. And as such it is (as I think you intended) a reduction, an encapsulation. It results (perhaps?) in the final realization: “Ah, so that what it really is all about”. Reductions make things simpler for the understanding, but they also function to wave-away what may very well be an issue that cannot or shouldn’t be dismissed as readily.
Valid points; that's all I can think of saying right now. I'll get back to you if I think of something useful.

Re: Can't both be right?

Posted: Wed Nov 04, 2026 2:43 pm
by Alexis Jacobi
The most essential message expressed in Christianity (and elucidated in depth in the Bhagavad Gita) is that of sacrifice.

Re: Can't both be right?

Posted: Wed Nov 04, 2026 3:43 pm
by Alexis Jacobi
This is an interesting statement, germane to this conversation I think, by Aurobindo commenting on verse 40 in the 4th chapter of the Gita.

Fairly obviously, this statement has no relevance or meaning for (for example) Flash. And though it should have great relevance for IC (for whom faith is highly relevant) he cannot participate in the meanings discussed because, for him, they come from a demonic source.

However, by comparing religious stances we find similarities not always differences.

The idea of Yoga (and Vedanta) is that we are submerged in layers of restriction. Our physical binding in Nature obviously. But in what this Vedanta school defines as “ignorance”. That is, incapacity to see and realize something that is there, but which we do not see or choose not to become aware of. Yet it is there and it can be discovered.

All of IC’s preachings over the years stress this, in his lop-sided disturbed way, but he too is devoted to an irrational system. Steeped in ignorant pictures that cannot be defended rationally.

My view has always been: IC needs to sort things out, and sort himself out. To say nothing of the class’s certified philosophical clown, our own Flash. 🤡

Here is Aurobindo:
We must have a faith which no intellectual doubt can be allowed to disturb. In fact, it is true that without faith nothing decisive can be achieved either in this world or for possession of the world above, and that it is only by laying hold of some sure basis and positive support that man can attain any measure of terrestrial or celestial success and satisfaction and happiness; the merely skeptical mind loses itself in the void.
In the lower knowledge doubt and scepticism have their temporary uses; in the higher they are stumbling-blocks: for there the whole secret is not the balancing of truth and error, but a constantly progressing realization of revealed truth. It is not a truth which has to be proved, but a truth which has to be lived inwardly, a greater reality into which we have to grow.

Finally, it is in itself a self-existent truth and would be self-evident if it were not for the sorceries of the ignorance in which we live; the doubts, the perplexities which prevent us from accepting and following it, arise from that ignorance, from the sense-bewildered, opinion-perplexed heart and mind, living as they do in a lower and phenomenal truth and therefore questioning the higher realities, ajnanasambhutam hritstham sansha-yam. They have to be cut away by the sword of knowledge, says the Gita, by the knowledge that realizes, by resorting constantly to Yoga, that is by living out the union with the Supreme whose truth being known all is known, yasmin vijnatesarvam vijnatam.

Re: Can't both be right?

Posted: Wed Nov 04, 2026 4:09 pm
by Immanuel Can
Alexis Jacobi wrote: ↑Wed Nov 04, 2026 3:43 pm And though it should have great relevance for IC (for whom faith is highly relevant) he cannot participate in the meanings discussed because, for him, they come from a demonic source.
Bad news for you.

If you'd been paying any attention, you'd already know I not only read the Gita, but have it here. And no, "sacrifice" is not its central message, unless you mean sacrificing your enemies to the giant, slavering maw of "Fate."

The Gita has some very pretty and well-written passages -- unlike the Koran, which is uniformly ugly and clumsy -- but its message is still horrendous.

Re: Can't both be right?

Posted: Wed Nov 04, 2026 4:22 pm
by Alexis Jacobi
Sacrifice is very definitely, and without doubt, the central focus of the Gita’s philosophy and certainly of Vedanta.

I have “paid attention” to what you write for years, IC.

Re: Can't both be right?

Posted: Wed Nov 04, 2026 4:44 pm
by Immanuel Can
Alexis Jacobi wrote: ↑Wed Nov 04, 2026 4:22 pm I have “paid attention” to what you write for years, IC.
Amazing that you missed that, then.

Re: Can't both be right?

Posted: Wed Nov 04, 2026 6:09 pm
by Alexis Jacobi
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Wed Nov 04, 2026 4:44 pm
Alexis Jacobi wrote: ↑Wed Nov 04, 2026 4:22 pm I have “paid attention” to what you write for years, IC.
Amazing that you missed that, then.
I didn’t miss it. I have read, and thought through, every comment you have made about “the maw” (as you describe it) that sums up the message of the Bhagavad Gita. I am aware of the books you have right next to your desk, and I am aware of your extremely limited understanding of religion and your own religion.

Re: Can't both be right?

Posted: Wed Nov 04, 2026 6:13 pm
by MikeNovack
What I am trying to get across is that when split "divinity" into no god, one god, or many gods we have already become entrapped by the "truths" of some particular religious beliefs. In arguing "one of these must be true" (regardless of what we believe) you are ignoring that the truth of the partition has been assumed.

Step back, let's try simpler/clearer.
a) There is only the material (strict secularist position).
b) In addition to the material there is also the divine/spiritual << not yet making any divisions of that >>
c) There is only the divine/spiritual << again not making any divisions/partitions of that >>

I would agree that one, and only one of those, must be true. Not dependent on beliefs. No assumptions about the divine/spiritual (other than it not being material) because as soon as we do that, as soon as we say god/gods we are already in the woods of our religious beliefs/truths.

Re: Can't both be right?

Posted: Wed Nov 04, 2026 6:18 pm
by Immanuel Can
Alexis Jacobi wrote: ↑Wed Nov 04, 2026 6:09 pm I am aware of your extremely limited understanding of religion and your own religion.
Oh, you're hilarious. :lol:

You have no idea, chum...none whatsoever. But that's one funny remark.

Never mind. You don't have enough knowledge even to open the subject, apparently.

Re: Can't both be right?

Posted: Wed Nov 04, 2026 6:23 pm
by Immanuel Can
MikeNovack wrote: ↑Wed Nov 04, 2026 6:13 pm What I am trying to get across is that when split "divinity" into no god, one god, or many gods we have already become entrapped by the "truths" of some particular religious beliefs.
But the Law of Non-Contradiction has no dependency at all on beliefs. It's always true, regardless of whether it's gods, cats or quantum surveyors one is talking about.

I can't imagine why the laws of logic fly out the window when you make the subject "religious". There are still only two states of things: existence, and non-existence. Everything else is merely detail that comes afterward. And all the LONC is dealing with here is the question of the existence or non-existence of the posited entity -- whatever entity you may wish it to be.

So let's go with cats.

1. There is only one cat (here, at this time, "cat" meaning the same kind of entity, in the same way, etc.)
2. There is more than one cat.
3. There are no cats.

Can more than one of these be true?

Re: Can't both be right?

Posted: Wed Nov 04, 2026 6:33 pm
by Gary Childress
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Wed Nov 04, 2026 6:23 pm
MikeNovack wrote: ↑Wed Nov 04, 2026 6:13 pm What I am trying to get across is that when split "divinity" into no god, one god, or many gods we have already become entrapped by the "truths" of some particular religious beliefs.
But the Law of Non-Contradiction has no dependency at all on beliefs. It's always true, regardless of whether it's gods, cats or quantum surveyors one is talking about.

I can't imagine why the laws of logic fly out the window when you make the subject "religious". There are still only two states of things: existence, and non-existence. Everything else is merely detail that comes afterward. And all the LONC is dealing with here is the question of the existence or non-existence of the posited entity -- whatever entity you may wish it to be.

So let's go with cats.

1. There is only one cat (here, at this time, "cat" meaning the same kind of entity, in the same way, etc.)
2. There is more than one cat.
3. There are no cats.

Can more than one of these be true?
Well, at least you're not trying to slip the Bible under the door with the LNC. Because the LNC proves nothing substantial about any of the religions that exist in reality except that perhaps some of them are not true, or else all of them are not true (assuming that logic applies to the unknowable). So for once, I can probably agree with you.

Re: Can't both be right?

Posted: Wed Nov 04, 2026 6:47 pm
by MikeNovack
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Wed Nov 04, 2026 6:23 pm
I can't imagine why the laws of logic fly out the window when you make the subject "religious". There are still only two states of things: existence, and non-existence. Everything else is merely detail that comes afterward. And all the LONC is dealing with here is the question of the existence or non-existence of the posited entity -- whatever entity you may wish it to be.

So let's go with cats.

1. There is only one cat (here, at this time, "cat" meaning the same kind of entity, in the same way, etc.)
2. There is more than one cat.
3. There are no cats.

Can more than one of these be true?
You tell me, IC. What is your answer if the cat is a child's stuffed toy? (some child's "tigger"). What if the cat is pregnant? Does your answer to that last change if it's a pregnant woman in the room and we are asking, how many people in the room? Especially if it does change, you should begin to see what I am getting at.

I don't accept that we can necessarily divide "the divine" into "gods" << that in seeing that division as real we are already basing things on our religious beliefs >>