Page 11 of 18
Re: Can't both be right?
Posted: Wed Nov 04, 2026 12:05 am
by Alexis Jacobi
FlashDangerpants wrote: ↑Tue Nov 03, 2026 11:22 pm
This is why you will definitely get your arse handed to you with this whole thing. Jacobi will get similarly beaten up. Questions remain about whether either of you are smart to realise this has happened.
You are an amazing poseur. And you have no idea what you’re talking about. But talk you do …
No definitive statements can be made about supernatural declarations comparable to science-statements or measurement facts. Therefore, statements made about supernatural notions cannot be compared with concrete facts where the non-contradiction law well applies.
You too are play-acting. That’s sn interesting turn of events.
Re: Can't both be right?
Posted: Wed Nov 04, 2026 12:14 am
by FlashDangerpants
Alexis Jacobi wrote: ↑Wed Nov 04, 2026 12:05 am
No definitive statements can be made about supernatural declarations comparable to science-statements or measurement facts. Therefore, statements made about supernatural notions cannot be compared with concrete facts where the non-contradiction law well applies.
That's not a limitation of logic you moron. You have no idea what you are babbling about.
Poseur indeed.
Re: Can't both be right?
Posted: Wed Nov 04, 2026 12:18 am
by FlashDangerpants
Alexis Jacobi wrote: ↑Tue Nov 03, 2026 11:57 pm
IC, stop all this play-acting. I cannot take you seriously.
I can't take him seriously. Willy B can't take him seriously. Mcstinky can't either. In truth, Impenitent likely doesn't.
You are not in any position to take seriously or not to. You don't have the basic knowledge to play this game.
Re: Can't both be right?
Posted: Wed Nov 04, 2026 12:25 am
by Immanuel Can
Alexis Jacobi wrote: ↑Tue Nov 03, 2026 11:57 pm
IC, stop all this play-acting. I cannot take you seriously.
Isn't it just so much easier to slander the messenger, than to deal with the message?

Re: Can't both be right?
Posted: Wed Nov 04, 2026 1:22 am
by Alexis Jacobi
FlashDangerpants wrote: ↑Wed Nov 04, 2026 12:14 am
Alexis Jacobi wrote: ↑Wed Nov 04, 2026 12:05 am
No definitive statements can be made about supernatural declarations comparable to science-statements or measurement facts. Therefore, statements made about supernatural notions cannot be compared with concrete facts where the non-contradiction law well applies.
That's not a limitation of logic you moron. You have no idea what you are babbling about.
Poseur indeed.
I am not interested in logic
games, you nut. I have explained, time and again, the sole means by which this conflict is put to rest. It stands beyond any doubt.
Re: Can't both be right?
Posted: Wed Nov 04, 2026 1:24 am
by Alexis Jacobi
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Wed Nov 04, 2026 12:25 am
Alexis Jacobi wrote: ↑Tue Nov 03, 2026 11:57 pm
IC, stop all this play-acting. I cannot take you seriously.
Isn't it just so much easier to slander the messenger, than to deal with the message?
You have at least
a dozen messages that you have not dealt with and will never deal with. Your tactic is to ignore everything.
Re: Can't both be right?
Posted: Wed Nov 04, 2026 1:26 am
by Alexis Jacobi
Oh no! Now two reckless nut-jobs are in the process of teaming up to pursue “logic games”. Amazing …
Re: Can't both be right?
Posted: Wed Nov 04, 2026 1:41 am
by FlashDangerpants
Alexis Jacobi wrote: ↑Wed Nov 04, 2026 1:22 am
FlashDangerpants wrote: ↑Wed Nov 04, 2026 12:14 am
Alexis Jacobi wrote: ↑Wed Nov 04, 2026 12:05 am
No definitive statements can be made about supernatural declarations comparable to science-statements or measurement facts. Therefore, statements made about supernatural notions cannot be compared with concrete facts where the non-contradiction law well applies.
That's not a limitation of logic you moron. You have no idea what you are babbling about.
Poseur indeed.
I am not interested in logic
games, you nut.
If true, that would explain how you failed so horribly to understand to what the law of non-contradiction applies. But the fact that you tried to do that shows that it is a lie. You are a teller of observable untruths mister Jacobi.
Re: Can't both be right?
Posted: Wed Nov 04, 2026 2:33 am
by Immanuel Can
Alexis Jacobi wrote: ↑Wed Nov 04, 2026 1:24 am
Your tactic is to ignore everything.
I ignore all the
ad homs. I ignore all the phony psychologizing. I ignore all the irrelevant asides. I ignore all the insults. I ignore all the statements that simply aren't true. I ignore the red flags, the red herrings, and the red-faced rants. And I return to the main argument.
I accept that that procedure is a bit unfamiliar to you. But you'll have to learn to live with it. Nothing's going to change.
Re: Can't both be right?
Posted: Wed Nov 04, 2026 2:58 am
by Alexis Jacobi
Two really odd mesheggeners. May God help me.
In any case the following is my “definitive statement”:
The issue is resolved quite simply. There can be any number of statements made about this term God. And no one making such statements can be said to have definitive information that can be corroborated, verified, proved. Period.
What people say, and why they say it, is a very complex question that is nearly completely outside of understanding because there are so many motives involved. So when this basic set of facts is laid out, it is only at that point can the statements made be examined. But those “inside” a belief-system — as opposed to those outside and without such a belief system — can only speak from their own inclination. And these are always complex and indeed there may be reasons unknown even to the believer.
So, you can suppose that this thing you refer to as God has specific characteristics that can be known and described, but you could only make such claims and attempt a description if you turned against your first established set of ‘facts’.
Since you cannot know anything exact and absolute and provable about “God”, you cannot make statements that even approach a situation comparable to, say, a cat in a box where the Law of Non-Contradiction certainly applies The Law cannot apply unless you have players who agree on basic terms as if in a game.
When people with different explanatory systems come together to exchange views and understandings, it can only be about a) sharing anecdotes that are personal and subjective, or b) referring to dogmatic systems where the descriptions (of God etc.) have been collected.
Re: Can't both be right?
Posted: Wed Nov 04, 2026 3:24 am
by MikeNovack
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Tue Nov 03, 2026 11:01 pm
Are mutually exclusive propositions,
regardless of the identity of X.
Aren't you?
Regardless of "identity", yes, regardless of ability to tell apart/distinguish, no.
I don't understand how to distinguish "no god" from "one god" or "many gods from one god". Not when I look at a whole range of religious beliefs. You think it easy because you are looking at the problem only from the position of one true religion. From outside that true religion, not so easy.
Re: Can't both be right?
Posted: Wed Nov 04, 2026 3:36 am
by Immanuel Can
MikeNovack wrote: ↑Wed Nov 04, 2026 3:24 am
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Tue Nov 03, 2026 11:01 pm
Are mutually exclusive propositions,
regardless of the identity of X.
Aren't you?
Regardless of "identity", yes, regardless of ability to tell apart/distinguish, no.
Well, to repeat the obvious, that's a worry about epistemology...it has no impact on ontology. That is to say, whether or not X exists will not be in the least affected by who knows whether or not X exists. America existed before it was discovered, cancer existed before it was discovered, Pluto existed before it was discovered, and gravity existed when nobody had any idea what it was...that's what the word "discovered" implies, of course.
So what somebody knows has nothing to do with what does or does not exist.
Re: Can't both be right?
Posted: Wed Nov 04, 2026 3:41 am
by Fanman
Alexis Jacobi wrote: ↑Mon Nov 02, 2026 5:03 pm
Fanman wrote: ↑Mon Nov 02, 2026 12:48 am
Okay, but that is one possible take, and as far as intuition goes, it feels honest. But from a subjective viewpoint, no matter how profound it sounds, we have to compare it with other spiritual and religious constructs. I think the common theme among the constructs is 'higher-order' thinking, conduct, and states. Now, there are different definitions, takes, and narratives about exactly how those combinations exist within each construct. Still, themes across those who experience it (the purportedly divine) include peace, greater understanding, and resonating with love and compassion. So maybe the divine isn't a place, in the sense of a specific spatial location. As you've alluded to, it may be a state of mind, where we experience reality at its most fundamental state: pure, unblemished, light, and just.
My view is that it is always going to be subjective except where groups decide on a theological picture they align with and seems to answer their most profound questions. So, the Bhagavad Gita is a (relatively) late compendium or synthesis of religious thought. Or you could say a refinement of religious and metaphysical ideas. There is a long history in India of the development of conceptual “pictures” of how reality is constructed. I could share a few of the historical pictures (conceptual orders) from ancient India that would illustrate this fact.
You can observe IC struggling mightily to insist, by way of The Law of Non-Contradiction, that the “picture” he holds and “believes in” is the absolutely true one. But it is, no matter how you look at it, just a diagrammatic representation:
Starting with: A) a time and a place where Adam & Eve existed in harmony in a deathless, perfect world B) an event that caused the loss of harmony and calamitous changes to afflict their status and the Cosmos itself C) life for those offspring who followed as confusion, chaos, pain, crime and death D) the appearance of Signs portending an intervention by The Creator E) the arrival of God as “God’s son” and a series of Actions that totally changed Destiny (by way of an act of mercy) F) the thoughtless destruction of that Avatar by a rebellious entity steeped in the illusion of being more powerful than The Creator (but destined to suffer defeat) G) a process of “intervention from afar” by Jesus and his saints in the world beyond this one which sets up H) the eventual Return of God into the world with full force, the total crushing of the Rebel entity disturbing and preventing Order from being reestablished I) then the descent of a Heavenly Order that merges with the Chaotic Order and “completes” the World Cycle for ever & ever & ever …
That is the original Christian picture.
Alexis, I have distilled our conversation to one axiom-like expression:
Human aspirations of higher states ≈ Transcendent ideals ≈ Elevated mental state ≈ Divine analogue
Let me know what you think.
Re: Can't both be right?
Posted: Wed Nov 04, 2026 12:11 pm
by Alexis Jacobi
Fanman wrote: ↑Wed Nov 04, 2026 3:41 am
Alexis, I have distilled our conversation to one axiom-like expression:
Human aspirations of higher states ≈ Transcendent ideals ≈ Elevated mental state ≈ Divine analogue
Let me know what you think.
I see your statement, if this is not obvious, as a way of arranging your own position in respect to this thing we label “divinity”. And as such it is (as I think you intended) a reduction, an encapsulation. It results (perhaps?) in the final realization: “Ah, so that what it really is all about”. Reductions make things simpler for the understanding, but they also function to wave-away what may very well be an issue that cannot or shouldn’t be dismissed as readily.
Re: Can't both be right?
Posted: Wed Nov 04, 2026 12:38 pm
by Alexis Jacobi
FlashDangerpants wrote: ↑Wed Nov 04, 2026 12:14 am
That's not a limitation of logic you moron. You have no idea what you are babbling about.
Poseur indeed.
Let’s start with the basics: You have no genuine interest in the issues and questions being discussed. As you put it your orientation is atheistic. You enter in (in typical arrogant manner) only insofar as a language game of “logic” excites your conflict-seeking temperament. And you reduce the entire issue to one of “logic”. This, you tell those who read you, is what real philosophers do. It amounts to game-playing. The rehearsal of bitter mind-games from which you gather sustenance. So it should be obvious that any responsible person, with genuine concern for the issues of our day, will dismiss and reject the entire, vain rehearsal.
Now here is the weird thing. Immanuel is attempting to maintain the validity and usefulness of this “logic game” because also in a genuine conversation he lacks completely an honest will to participate in a genuine manner. He is no atheist and in fact is a zealot-extremist. But here, in a game-playing pseudo-philosophical forum you and he team up in defense of — but what is it? Once you attach “game” to these rehearsals you then uncover the basic defect in operation. It’s hard to label but at the core it seems to be “basic dishonesty”.
Now as I said you have no other reason to jump in her except to play the bitter games you always play. There is nothing more to it. So you dismiss yourself entirely.
IC on the other hand works in a far more consequential area of (this is my assessment of course) basic dishonesty. And though my assessment is disliked it still must be brought out and discussed. His dishonestly is profoundly psychological. This is not “epistemology” and it is not “ontology” it is a man who double triples and quadruples-down on literally absurd beliefs but presented as if they are rational and can be rationally explained.
I presented to IC a listing of the core Christian mythology. It is material that no honest could describe as “rational” but is completely “irrational”. What do I hope to gain by exposing this? It would be of no concern whatever to you, but it is of concern to those involved in issues of religion, spirituality, the transcendental and many other issues that are issues of
value.