Philosophy Now Forum

The Jesus Head wrote:...
You should not be so confident as to claim that your judgement coincides with that of others
when your supposition is strictly general. ie all things said by Arising we be agreed upon.
What we know about you is that Arising has a secret connection with yourself ,that is not so secret with me. lick lick
...

artisticsolution wrote:

chaz wyman wrote: There are many more people with far more creativity than she would have ever had, that lead long and fruitful lives.
You have no thesis here.
All her best work was due to Mark Ronson's excellent music experience and taste. His instrumentation and arrangement of that and other of her songs made her the star she so temporarily was.
All you have to do is to contrast her own version of Rehab with Mark's final version to know what I am talking about.

Oh yeah...if you look really really close in this video you can see the strings in which Mark is controlling his little marionette Amy....Not!

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lqSKVv6YO8g

Here is Mark's version with his marionettes pretending to be Amy:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4HLY1NTe04M

Even though it is her voice...it completely misses her essence...and THAT was her art. Her essence came through her pores not to be duplicated or arranged by anyone. Sure, artists can collaborate...but that in no way implies that one is better than the other.

The Jesus Head wrote:

Any had a great voice and was able to write interesting and biographical lyrics - however she never became a great singer, simply because she had an addictive personality, access to drugs, and an unlimited supply of cash to buy the stuff.

Even more nonsense. She was regarded as another Billy Holiday and in my expert opinion she was an exceptional vocalist.
:

Arising_uk wrote:

The Jesus Head wrote:...
You should not be so confident as to claim that your judgement coincides with that of others
when your supposition is strictly general. ie all things said by Arising we be agreed upon.
What we know about you is that Arising has a secret connection with yourself ,that is not so secret with me. lick lick
...

Correction. What a shit-stirring little attention seeker you are.

The Jesus Head wrote:Hardly . Let us face it ,no one knows who I am, so how in logics name ,could that be, you foolish
chicken.

chaz wyman wrote:

The Jesus Head wrote:

Any had a great voice and was able to write interesting and biographical lyrics - however she never became a great singer, simply because she had an addictive personality, access to drugs, and an unlimited supply of cash to buy the stuff.

Even more nonsense. She was regarded as another Billy Holiday and in my expert opinion she was an exceptional vocalist.
:

Actually I do have some experience in the music industry.

Ok ok let us hear what it is.

And Billy Holiday lived a long life because she was not a drug addict nor a drunk. Which is exactly the point I was making thanks.

Arising_uk wrote:

Not logic, writing style. Woof! Woof!

chaz wyman wrote:

I did not imply either.

This sort of attack does not suit you.

The Jesus Head wrote:What a cretin ! What I mean is no one knows who I am in the real world so why would I be attention seeking ?
How could I get attention.
I think you are throwing your teddy out of the cot again.

The Jesus Head wrote:[[ or as Arising would say " to personally" ]

Arising_uk wrote:

Not in the real world twit, here. Why else would you take any opportunity to mention me? Especially since I'm supposed to be having a nice rest in the wilderness.

Arising_uk wrote:

It was just my pendantic nativity showing.

Arising_uk wrote: I'll take you word for that.

You've not yet given your 'qualified' diagnosis of those with a terminal aversion to question answering ?

The Jesus Head wrote:I have a rule. I do not get embroiled in detailed question answering with complete retards