Philosophy Now Forum

ncrbrts wrote:
I only question because all of the smart people I know seem predisposed to major depressive disorders.

Mind you, my ex was the king of the idiots but tried to kill himself twice. He was unsuccessful because he cut his wrists the wrong way. We split because he didn't like me pointing out his mistake

Is this a joke?

PhilX

Philosophy Explorer wrote:

ncrbrts wrote:
I only question because all of the smart people I know seem predisposed to major depressive disorders.

Mind you, my ex was the king of the idiots but tried to kill himself twice. He was unsuccessful because he cut his wrists the wrong way. We split because he didn't like me pointing out his mistake

Is this a joke?

PhilX

Nope - all true.

ncrbrts wrote:

Hobbes' Choice wrote:

ncrbrts wrote:
To varying degrees though?

A stupid person can be tragically unhappy, as can an intellectual. Whilst both stupidity and intellectuality might make it worse, there is no correlation that would make me think one was more a problem than the other.
I don't think stupidity leads to happiness anymore than smartness does.

I only question because all of the smart people I know seem predisposed to major depressive disorders.

Mind you, my ex was the king of the idiots but tried to kill himself twice. He was unsuccessful because he cut his wrists the wrong way. We split because he didn't like me pointing out his mistake

I suppose that all depends on how you pointed it out.
Is he still alive?

Hobbes' Choice wrote:I suppose that all depends on how you pointed it out.
Is he still alive?

Yes, he is very much alive.

I pointed out when he slashed his wrists in front of me that he wouldn't get far cutting across his arm with a blunt knife. I was right.

Probably sounds callous to an objective onlooker. In fact, I gained a tiny bit of respect for him. It was the bravest thing he ever did.