Page 10 of 18

Re: Can't both be right?

Posted: Tue Nov 03, 2026 5:26 pm
by Alexis Jacobi
FlashDangerpants wrote: ↑Tue Nov 03, 2026 5:11 pm Watching you utter clowns get schooled in day 1 basic propositional logic by Immanuel Can of all people is quite excruciating. You are all complete idiots.
Thanks for your contribution, Flash. Now sit down please and drink your juice.

Re: Can't both be right?

Posted: Tue Nov 03, 2026 5:41 pm
by FlashDangerpants
MikeNovack wrote: ↑Mon Oct 26, 2026 10:40 pm I've seen it expressed here, that if person A has beliefs about the divine, and person B has beliefs about the divine, and these beliefs are mutually contradictory, the following is certain ......... both can be false, one can be false and the other true, but both cannot be true.

Really?
Yes. The law of non contradiction and the law of excluded middle apply. The LNC seems to be something you clowns have sort of grasped now, but IC hasn't shoved the LEM down your throat yet. It states that for any proposition, either that proposition is true or its negation is true, which makes it the companion of that other law.
MikeNovack wrote: ↑Tue Nov 03, 2026 5:15 pm That's the main point. The Law of Non-Contradiction depends on TRUTH (about the things being considered as exclusionary). But that's truth in its material sense, not truth in its spiritual, religious, ideological senses.
Actually it depends on the LEM. If proposition that there is exactly one universal God is true, then the LEM and LNC combine to show that the proposition that there is more than one god, or a competing one that there are no gods at all are necessarily false.

This didn't need to be complicated. You screwed yourself with your original question through incompetence at reason. Your move was supposed to be not that contradictory propositions are somehow both true, but that they aren't actually contradictory.
MikeNovack wrote: ↑Tue Nov 03, 2026 5:15 pm consider a room with a woman in it. How many human persons are in that room? Is she pregnant? How does that affect our answer "one" vs "more than one"? Her being pregnant is a matter of material truth, but whether the fetus is a human person is a matter of spiritual, religious, ideological truth.
This is not at all the quandry you hope for. Terrible error of argumental judgment. The LNC and LEM apply and you are accidentally relying on them in your own reasoning. Trying to treat these basic laws of prop logic as optional is a stupid move unless you are a very talented logician using a Substructural Logic. But those would be beyond not only your own talents but also those of your entire audience, including me.
MikeNovack wrote: ↑Tue Nov 03, 2026 5:15 pm So SOMETIMES the Law of Non-Contradiction fails to apply even to ordinary things. But it would ALWAYS fail to apply when discussing gods/divine beings because these have no material truths, only spiritual, religious, ideological truths.
Even if you fix this with regards to the contradictiory truths issue, it will be a stupid argument still. You've completely jumped the shark with this shit. IC is goping to beat you like a red-headed step-child for exactly as long as you keep providing such easy ways to do so.

If you are married to the insane argument there are no true propositions to describe the divine even if it happens not to exist and the proposition in question states that divinty is imaginary, then why would you bother debating the subject at all? You can never be right. Meanwhile anybody who holds a view that any one among the very many competing propositions about the divine is truthful can simply say that if their claim is true, yours is renderred untrue via the Law of Excluded Middle.

You are unilatterally disarming without taking any steps to disarm your enemy. That's quite a bad argument strategy.

Re: Can't both be right?

Posted: Tue Nov 03, 2026 6:35 pm
by Alexis Jacobi
The issue is resolved quite simply. There can be any number of statements made about this term God. And no one making such statements can be said to have definitive information that can be corroborated, verified, proved. Period.

What people say, and why they say it, is a very complex question that is nearly completely outside of understanding because there are so many motives involved. So when this basic set of facts is laid out, it is only at that point can the statements made be examined. But those “inside” a belief-system — as opposed to those outside and without such a belief system — can only speak from their own inclination. And these are always complex and indeed there may be reasons unknown even to the believer.

So, you can suppose that this thing you refer to as God has specific characteristics that can be known and described, but you could only make such claims and attempt a description if you turned against your first established set of ‘facts’.

Since you cannot know anything exact and absolute and provable about “God”, you cannot make statements that even approach a situation comparable to, say, a cat in a box where the Law of Non-Contradiction certainly applies The Law cannot apply unless you have players who agree on basic terms as if in a game.

When people with different explanatory systems come together to exchange views and understandings, it can only be about a) sharing anecdotes that are personal and subjective, or b) referring to dogmatic systems where the descriptions (of God etc.) have been collected.

Flash, it is time for you to get your ass super-kicked. Why you mealy-mouthed cockroach of a drooling poseur I am ready to do it but dammit I don’t have time till Thursday after 1:00 PM! Mark your calendar 📆.

Re: Can't both be right?

Posted: Tue Nov 03, 2026 6:37 pm
by MikeNovack
FlashDangerpants wrote: ↑Tue Nov 03, 2026 5:41 pm
If you are married to the insane argument there are no true propositions to describe the divine even if it happens not to exist and the proposition in question states that divinty is imaginary, then why would you bother debating the subject at all?
Should we perhaps have begun with the broader questions, what are religions, why do we humans have them, what purpose do they serve in our human lives?

I come at this from the viewpoint of "comparative religions". The TRUTH of any of them, in the sense that IC considers his religion true, is not my concern. How they help people cope with the human condition is. It matters to IC what happens to his soul after he dies, the truth of this, the truth of how he is freed from the burden of sin, etc. That matters to me not at all. My concern is how these beliefs shape his life, help him live s a human.

If this seems strange to you, consider that I am not a Christian, and am unconcerned that IC might consider my religious beliefs (if any) false. I look at many different beliefs. That they are not in agreement, cannot all be true (in the sense IC considers his religion true) bothers me not at all, simply not relevant to discussing religion. How a religion helps us iive our lives does NOT depend on their truth in that sense.

And before jumping on "then belief can help us live our lives and disbelief cannot" try say This I Don't Believe by Robert Jensen (an atheist describing how to have a fulfilling life without belief in gods, free will, etc. --- and no, I was not in the "peer group" for that one (Jensen would not invite a woo-woo like myself for that) but I did get to read pre-publication)

Re: Can't both be right?

Posted: Tue Nov 03, 2026 6:49 pm
by Alexis Jacobi
I cannot define for you what God is. I can only say that my work has proved empirically that the pattern of God exists in every man, and that this pattern has at its disposal the greatest of all his energies for transformation and transfiguration of his natural being.

CG Jung
Here we have a sensible statement. Here is a man who worked with people on that psychological level and therefore works with people at a fundamental level. That of their conscious persons but, with Jung, on unconscious and undiscovered levels in their selves. What people generally find (in psychic, psychological and spiritual work) is that they receive response. Something inside responds to them.

The “pattern” is there. What it is, why it is, involves many different ideas and considerations.

Re: Can't both be right?

Posted: Tue Nov 03, 2026 6:56 pm
by Immanuel Can
Alexis Jacobi wrote: ↑Tue Nov 03, 2026 4:09 pm
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Tue Nov 03, 2026 3:39 pm
Alexis Jacobi wrote: ↑Tue Nov 03, 2026 3:36 pm I have of course answered you, and you know it.
You give two answers: yes, the Law of Non-Contradiction is true, and no, it's not true, as soon as I say the world "religion". It's impossible to find logic in there, and you don't explain yourself.
Religion is a human tool, when you examine it honestly. It is a “conceptual contrivance” when the notions about metaphysical models are put into a doctrine like a catechism that is then shared.
"Conceptual contrivance" means "artificial invention of an idea." All you're saying is that all religion is essentially a lie, so no logic applies to it.

But it has zero impact on the Law of Non-Contradiction. All you're saying is, "The one view that's right is the Atheist view: the rest are merely 'conceptual contrivances,' (i.e. made-up stuff)."

And if you protest, all you're saying is, "My view is right, and your view is wrong." So you're affirming the Law of Non-Contradiction, even while trying to exempt your view from it.

Nice work. :lol:

Re: Can't both be right?

Posted: Tue Nov 03, 2026 7:10 pm
by FlashDangerpants
MikeNovack wrote: ↑Tue Nov 03, 2026 6:37 pm
FlashDangerpants wrote: ↑Tue Nov 03, 2026 5:41 pm
If you are married to the insane argument there are no true propositions to describe the divine even if it happens not to exist and the proposition in question states that divinty is imaginary, then why would you bother debating the subject at all?
Should we perhaps have begun with the broader questions, what are religions, why do we humans have them, what purpose do they serve in our human lives?
That's not a broader question, it's just an unrelated one. Either you want the parable of the blind men describing an elephant to be the centrepiece of something or you don't.
MikeNovack wrote: ↑Tue Nov 03, 2026 6:37 pm I come at this from the viewpoint of "comparative religions". The TRUTH of any of them, in the sense that IC considers his religion true, is not my concern. How they help people cope with the human condition is. It matters to IC what happens to his soul after he dies, the truth of this, the truth of how he is freed from the burden of sin, etc. That matters to me not at all. My concern is how these beliefs shape his life, help him live s a human.
Given that, I can't see how a discussion about two contradictory claims both being true would take you towards your goal.

That said, I think your goal might include some sort of opening up of the IC mind to possibilities he tends to dismiss with inadequate and doctrinaire argument. My somewhat jaded view is that if you do somehow crack that shell, all you get left with is a broken shell, but that it would never happen and the IC mind is sentences to remain closed until death. A discourse on the role of religion in society is of course always a valid thing though. I think is begins with a very different question to this thread.

The thing you pose there comes with an uncomfortable question about what the truth is and that's something that you have had difficulty with in this thread and similar issues have haunted your discussions of morality too. The common sense view of what it means for something to be true or false is a correspondence theory. In this it holds that what it means for a statement, proposition, belief or whatever to be true is correspondence to the underlying truth of the world, visible, detectable or otherwise. This common-sense view of truthiness is what IC assumes, it's what the LNC and LEM assume too. If you want to escape all that, you don't have a means to do so by simply announcing that divine stuff is different and propositions about divine stuff don't obey the same rules of truthiness as other talk does.

If you are determined to make that argument you'll have to know what your ideas regarding the metaphysics that underpin actual truth are. Maybe you would be able to argue the pragmatist or coherentist truth criteria to Jacobi's satisfaction. Maybe mine. But IC's? The way he argues is to not allow you to present your argument under any circumstances even when he is clearly proposing a mad pile of rubbish. Trying to do something as technical as this when his own position is the common-sense intuitive default everyone is born assuming... well let's say I reckon that would be a 200 page thread.
MikeNovack wrote: ↑Tue Nov 03, 2026 6:37 pm If this seems strange to you, consider that I am not a Christian, and am unconcerned that IC might consider my religious beliefs (if any) false. I look at many different beliefs. That they are not in agreement, cannot all be true (in the sense IC considers his religion true) bothers me not at all, simply not relevant to discussing religion. How a religion helps us iive our lives does NOT depend on their truth in that sense.

And before jumping on "then belief can help us live our lives and disbelief cannot" try say This I Don't Believe by Robert Jensen (an atheist describing how to have a fulfilling life without belief in gods, free will, etc. --- and no, I was not in the "peer group" for that one (Jensen would not invite a woo-woo like myself for that) but I did get to read pre-publication)
I'm an atheist. Or I'm an agnostic who is so irreligious as to not care about the difference. It's hard to persuade me to care about the distinction.

But the question of why you would debate at all was based on the guarantee of failure built into that way of arguing not the comparative importance of the question. If the party on one side of a debate says that "If I am right, you can be right too" while the other says "If I am right, you must be wrong" then the first party cannot ever win.

Re: Can't both be right?

Posted: Tue Nov 03, 2026 7:51 pm
by Alexis Jacobi
[Contrive: from Old French controver, from Late Latin contropāre to represent by figures of speech, compare, from Latin com- together + tropus figure of speech, trope]
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Tue Nov 03, 2026 6:56 pm "Conceptual contrivance" means "artificial invention of an idea." All you're saying is that all religion is essentially a lie, so no logic applies to it.
No, a conceptual contrivance does not mean artificial invention, except in a mind that functions like yours does. Just examine your own beliefs.

The religion you believe in and advocate for is a contrivance, a coming together of belief and ideas of extremely wide provenance. You believe things impossible to believe, but I assume you also believe in ethical fundamentals. You, yourself, are a contrivance. And there are entire orders of “concepts” that you swim with in that ultra-weird fishbowl. Just look at the listing of foundational beliefs!

Here:
Starting with: A) a time and a place where Adam & Eve existed in harmony in a deathless, perfect world B) an event that caused the loss of harmony and calamitous changes to afflict their status and the Cosmos itself C) life for those offspring who followed as confusion, chaos, pain, crime and death D) the appearance of Signs portending an intervention by The Creator E) the arrival of God as “God’s son” and a series of Actions that totally changed Destiny (by way of an act of mercy) F) the thoughtless destruction of that Avatar by a rebellious entity steeped in the illusion of being more powerful than The Creator (but destined to suffer defeat) G) a process of “intervention from afar” by Jesus and his saints in the world beyond this one which sets up H) the eventual Return of God into the world with full force, the total crushing of the Rebel entity disturbing and preventing Order from being reestablished I) then the descent of a Heavenly Order that merges with the Chaotic Order and “completes” the World Cycle for ever & ever & ever …
IC wrote:And if you protest, all you're saying is, "My view is right, and your view is wrong." So you're affirming the Law of Non-Contradiction, even while trying to exempt your view from it.
No again. The worthy conversation is one where religious beliefs is examined from a wide, considerate POV. It is wise to locate and place emphasis on what a religion in the best sense demands of man. My endeavor is many many levels above yours. You are like a child. But I am an adult. (This is not irony).

Re: Can't both be right?

Posted: Tue Nov 03, 2026 9:53 pm
by MikeNovack
FlashDangerpants wrote: ↑Tue Nov 03, 2026 7:10 pm But the question of why you would debate at all was based on the guarantee of failure built into that way of arguing not the comparative importance of the question. If the party on one side of a debate says that "If I am right, you can be right too" while the other says "If I am right, you must be wrong" then the first party cannot ever win.
No, the first party is saying "I may be right, or you may be right, AND THERE EXISTS NO POSSIBLE MEANS OF DETERMINING WHICH."

Saying "There exist no gods, or there exists exactly one god, or there exists more than one god means exactly one of these is true" says nothing of importance/use IF THERE IS NO POSSIBLE MEANS OF DETERMINING WHICH".

The true description of the elephant includes the possibility that there is no elephant.

Re: Can't both be right?

Posted: Tue Nov 03, 2026 10:03 pm
by FlashDangerpants
MikeNovack wrote: ↑Tue Nov 03, 2026 9:53 pm
FlashDangerpants wrote: ↑Tue Nov 03, 2026 7:10 pm But the question of why you would debate at all was based on the guarantee of failure built into that way of arguing not the comparative importance of the question. If the party on one side of a debate says that "If I am right, you can be right too" while the other says "If I am right, you must be wrong" then the first party cannot ever win.
No, the first party is saying "I may be right, or you may be right, AND THERE EXISTS NO POSSIBLE MEANS OF DETERMINING WHICH."

Saying "There exist no gods, or there exists exactly one god, or there exists more than one god means exactly one of these is true" says nothing of importance/use IF THERE IS NO POSSIBLE MEANS OF DETERMINING WHICH".

The true description of the elephant includes the possibility that there is no elephant.
That doesn't fix anything. Your question began with whether both, or perhaps more, could be right. Now you clearly have answered that with a negative.

So going back to your original question that opened this thread....
MikeNovack wrote: ↑Mon Oct 26, 2026 10:40 pm I've seen it expressed here, that if person A has beliefs about the divine, and person B has beliefs about the divine, and these beliefs are mutually contradictory, the following is certain ......... both can be false, one can be false and the other true, but both cannot be true.

Really? .
Indeed. Really. But at least now you agree with that.

You've got to agree with yourself if you want other people to be able to agree with you. That's the number one most important thing when debating stuff.

Re: Can't both be right?

Posted: Tue Nov 03, 2026 10:43 pm
by Immanuel Can
Alexis Jacobi wrote: ↑Tue Nov 03, 2026 7:51 pm No again.
"No" is a word that indicates you think somebody is wrong. That means you're invoking the Law of Non-Contradiction: that what is contrary to your view is necessarily wrong.
The worthy conversation is one where religious beliefs is examined from a wide, considerate POV.
And the "unworthy" one, presumably, is the one that depends on the Law of Non-Contradiction (LONC): except that your saying that IS an invocation of that same Law. So you've again contradicted yourself.
It is wise to locate and place emphasis on what a religion in the best sense demands of man.
This implies "wise" is good, and "unwise" is bad. My view, you suggest is not "not best." That means yours supposedly is, "best." Again, the LONC.
My endeavor is many many levels above yours.
So according to this claim, mine is, to some extent, wrong, and yours is more right. Again, you can't say such a thing unless you're imposing a hierarchy that contrasts to the thing you're believing.

You can't stop both resisting and, at the same time, using and relying on the LONC.

You can't stay consistent with yourself. How do you expect anybody else to believe you?

Re: Can't both be right?

Posted: Tue Nov 03, 2026 10:59 pm
by MikeNovack
You seem to think it matters whether A is true or B is true or C is true when we cannot even (because of the nature of A, B, and C) tell between them?
When it comes to religion and associated fundamentals, we are unlikely to agree what constitutes one god, exactly one god, or more than one god.

IC, you say your three are really one, you believe this.
The Hindu says his/her many are really one, he/she believes this.

But you, IC, do you say the Hindu believes in many gods? (or just one).
And of the pantheist, who believe there is nothing but God (that god does not exist separate from everything else). Do you say he/she believes in one god, or none?

Re: Can't both be right?

Posted: Tue Nov 03, 2026 11:01 pm
by Immanuel Can
MikeNovack wrote: ↑Tue Nov 03, 2026 10:59 pm You seem to think it matters whether A is true or B is true or C is true when we cannot even (because of the nature of A, B, and C) tell between them?
I think you're bright enough to understand that:

There is one X.
There is no X.
And there are many X's.

Are mutually exclusive propositions, regardless of the identity of X.

Aren't you?

Re: Can't both be right?

Posted: Tue Nov 03, 2026 11:22 pm
by FlashDangerpants
MikeNovack wrote: ↑Tue Nov 03, 2026 10:59 pm You seem to think it matters whether A is true or B is true or C is true when we cannot even (because of the nature of A, B, and C) tell between them?
When it comes to religion and associated fundamentals, we are unlikely to agree what constitutes one god, exactly one god, or more than one god.
You need to learn how to tell when an argument has fallen flat on it's face. That's a bizarrely rare talent around here for some reason.

There either is a reality or there isn't a reality. If there is a reality, then a truth claim such as "There exist exactly 7 gods, and all of them are called Jeremy" is either correctly descriptive of that reality, making it a true claim, or it fails to correctly describe reality, making it false.

Whether we have access to the knowledge of whether a truth claim is correct or not, or if need be, which among the innumerable claims that can be made best corresponds, is neither here nor there if you are relying on the standard common-sense correspondence theory of truth. If correspondence to reality is the sole criterion that determines truth, then human access to knowledge about that truth is not another criteria.

IC is using that common-sense truth theory. You are trying to skirt an obligation to explain why he must switch to some other theory of truth and just perform a switcheroo. Nobody is ever going to fall for that with something so basic as this. So yes, it does matter whether A or B or C is true if we are determining the truth. Again, you gave yourself away in the quoted text. You don't agree with yourself here and you can't help but tell on yourself as you go along.

This is why you will definitely get your arse handed to you with this whole thing. Jacobi will get similarly beaten up. Questions remain about whether either of you are smart to realise this has happened.

Seriously, it is a skill of its own to be able to re-assess your position once it has come under scrutiny and faltered. Gain that skill.

Re: Can't both be right?

Posted: Tue Nov 03, 2026 11:57 pm
by Alexis Jacobi
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Tue Nov 03, 2026 10:43 pm …
IC, stop all this play-acting. I cannot take you seriously.