God and morality

Is there a God? If so, what is She like?

Moderators: AMod, iMod

User avatar
FlashDangerpants
Posts: 9356
Joined: Mon Jan 04, 2016 11:54 pm

Re: God and morality

Post by FlashDangerpants »

Alexis Jacobi wrote: ↑Wed Nov 18, 2026 1:44 pm But because it is fun, and also interesting (and bizarre) I submit for your perusal if not your edification a short talk by a man who is part of a rising movement in the US. His ideas are radical, but he presents them as grounded in defensible Christian theology. Not unethical mind you, but ethical and moral.
Wow, the dud posing with the conspiracy-theorist book about "white genocide" there appears to be notorious white-supremacist hate preacher Joel Webbon, author of the far-right conspiracy book in question.

Apparently that would be the same Joel Webbon who recently claimed Charlie Kirk was a liberal for platforming Jews....
Jacobi's latest Nazi Friend wrote: “If you’re mad at the direction that TPUSA is going in [Kirk’s] absence, you have to recognize —it may be some betrayal, but it’s not entirely, it’s not exclusively TPUSA leadership betraying Charlie’s vision—part of it is TPUSA continuing Charlie’s vision because Charlie’s vision when Charlie was here included homosexuals being platformed, Orthodox Jews who believe Jesus is in hell being platformed, Hindus who believe in three million gods with bare feet being platformed, atheists—looking at you, James Lindsay—being platformed. Charlie was a moderate centrist, at best. I would argue in some of his ideology, he was a liberal. He was left, not center right, but kind of center left.”
Yeesh. With all that platforming Jacobi has been doing of Hindu stuff... I guess Jacobi is a liberal too.
MikeNovack
Posts: 1453
Joined: Fri Jul 11, 2025 1:17 pm

Re: God and morality

Post by MikeNovack »

Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Wed Nov 18, 2026 10:49 pm Not "like animals." But there was certainly a phase in which hunting and foraging were important activities...as was farming, making war...and a whole bunch of other such things. So far, so good.
Hard to say how humans thought and acted 20,000 years ago, but their morals and ethics arose in Nature and in a natural context.
You don't have the foggiest idea whether or not that's true. You're making it up.
No, not FARMING and not WAR (as we understand that -- the constant state of hostility to neighboring bands is something else) Do you have ANY sense of the time involved. FARMING maybe in some places a bit earlier than 10,000 years ago. But to give a counter example, the earliest walled settlement at Jericho was pre-agricultural! << there was a source of water and the wild grain growing around this rock produced 5-7 bu/acre, which was why a mass settlement and a wall to protect this "perfect site" existed --- you could just go out and within a mile harvest enough to feed a couple thousand people >> It was only THEN that we got wars. Sure, our pre-agricultural ancestor groups were in constant hostility with neighboring groups, but the experience different than "war"". Lost one, maybe two killed per decade (NOTE: this is actually a HIGH casualty rate since the groups so small and the chances high that a man would die this way, but experienced as a rare occurrence). A WAR requires more individuals.

And yes we DO know this is how it was, archeology/paleontology and studying existing hunter-gatherer groups (who DO exhibit systems of morality in spite lacking the benefit of knowledge of your God).

Look IC, this is all part and parcel of disagreeing over what is or is not EVIDENCE.
User avatar
Immanuel Can
Posts: 30600
Joined: Wed Sep 25, 2013 4:42 pm

Re: God and morality

Post by Immanuel Can »

MikeNovack wrote: ↑Thu Nov 19, 2026 12:15 am
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Wed Nov 18, 2026 10:49 pm Not "like animals." But there was certainly a phase in which hunting and foraging were important activities...as was farming, making war...and a whole bunch of other such things. So far, so good.
Hard to say how humans thought and acted 20,000 years ago, but their morals and ethics arose in Nature and in a natural context.
You don't have the foggiest idea whether or not that's true. You're making it up.
No, not FARMING and not WAR
Yes, both agriculture and warfare started very, very early.

You don't know what human society was like thousands of years ago. Even the best archaeologists struggle with patterning of the ancient artifacts. But tools for particular purposes turn out to be pretty much tools for particular purposes: and both agriculture and warfare are evident in the earliest of these.
Impenitent
Posts: 6398
Joined: Wed Feb 10, 2010 2:04 pm

Re: God and morality

Post by Impenitent »

Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Thu Nov 19, 2026 12:58 am ...tools for particular purposes turn out to be pretty much tools for particular purposes: and both agriculture and warfare are evident in the earliest of these.
I especially like the bows with arrows designed to get those pesky coconuts out of the trees...

-Imp
User avatar
Immanuel Can
Posts: 30600
Joined: Wed Sep 25, 2013 4:42 pm

Re: God and morality

Post by Immanuel Can »

Impenitent wrote: ↑Thu Nov 19, 2026 2:59 am
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Thu Nov 19, 2026 12:58 am ...tools for particular purposes turn out to be pretty much tools for particular purposes: and both agriculture and warfare are evident in the earliest of these.
I especially like the bows with arrows designed to get those pesky coconuts out of the trees...

-Imp
You can't get the coconuts out of the trees. The African swallows have taken them all.
User avatar
Alexis Jacobi
Posts: 9244
Joined: Tue Oct 26, 2021 3:00 am

Re: God and morality

Post by Alexis Jacobi »

AJ wrote:We continually veer into tangential topics. According to “the Vedanta school” (i.e. Yogananda) the Second Coming is the inner realization, or you could say the inner appearance of “Christ”.
IC wrote:Yeah, I know about all that nonsense. It's clearly not true, and it clearly grossly misrepresents what Jews and Christians know as "Christ."
I am uncertain if you or those who read here have paid attention to the militant Christian videos I posted that come from the NCR. In the most basic sense all men — humanity — seek a way to explain the world by way of a Cosmology and an Origin Story. And whether “philosophy” realizes it or not this explanatory impetus is so deep-rooted that it will never cease as a central motivator:
Thomas Carlyle wrote:But the thing a man does practically believe (and this is often enough without asserting it even to himself, much less to others); the thing a man does practically lay to heart, and know for certain, concerning his vital relations to this mysterious Universe, and his duty and destiny there, that is in all cases the primary thing for him, and creatively determines all the rest.
There is no way that any thinker can dismiss or side-step the tremendous consequences of the collapse of a story-system of the magnitude of Christianity. And I say this as, and in my way, a defender of the value of Christian mythology. And though that seems dismissive — Christian mythology — it is undeniably true: The belief-system is undergirded by myth. Now, men trained in the faculty of reason will have no choice but to see the fables upon which belief rests. And that is “our” situation. We cannot believe the unbelievable. Yet — and here I turn back to Carlyle — though the Cheshire Cat disappears, the smile remains. Though the supporting Stories become unbelievable, belief remains.

What is the most quintessential feature of Christian certainty? If you can isolate it you will then be better able to understand why men, why a man, will offer up his life to defend and uphold it. He would rather perish than relinquish that. The quintessential thing, the essence, is the belief in, the dedication to, ultimate strength of the spirit over the material and biological world. That is, Nature (Prakriti) when perceived, realized, as the “trap” which it is felt to be.

Jesus Christ conquered death and “returned” to demonstrate that all that we can and do refer to as Higher Values can be, must be, persevered in. So in this sense, the meaning of establishing a relationship with Christ, God, the Divine, is to keep the spirit alive and, to put it rather crassly, to keep one’s own self forever resurrected. Because spiritual death is a real thing.

It is obvious that this idealized picture transcends the Story even though (the Gospel) Story turns on this theme. If there is no Story would that indicate that what the Story represents is meaningless? I think the answer is “no”.

For this reason, once one has isolated the Core Meaning, the Core Value, the “living message” as it were, one either decides to take it seriously and live in it and through it, or one doesn’t. Those are the two poles and between them is a wide array.

Now, with that said, to realize on an inner plane the articulated, the sensed, the believed in value that is presented by the Story and which is confirmed and bolstered within one’s spiritual life — this is OBVIOUSLY the objective that is presented by way of conversion. Conversion is the praxis-aspect, is it not? You are converted from one mode of life into another which is understood to be of a higher sort. And as a result one simultaneously modifies one’s ethical behavior. The essence is there (and no place else).

If what I have said here is “true” then it follows that in a paradigmatic sense the notion of “the second coming” as an interior event within man, within a person, makes a good deal of sense. But how far can one go in merely stating the obvious? One either gets it, or one doesn’t not.

Now, what goes on in the political world and the social world — as for example with NCR and the movement that (for exampke) Fuentes is leading, is simply put very interesting to consider from a removed, neutral POV. But we know that political movements, especially today, are events in which Mass Man is pulled into cycles of activity or of “assent”.

However, there is another, as it were, domain of assent which is distinct because it is internal. What are you ultimately serving? There is no man that is not ultimately involved in this problem or question. Because there is no man not “in the soup” of incarnated existence. At some point it hinges on “assent”.

So IC, whatever you want to say — as response — you will surely say. And I fully understand the degree of your commitments to (what I refer to as) your God of Stone. All I can tell you is that in response to your Apologetics, which I consider deficient and misleading, there is necessitated a refinement of “the message”.
User avatar
Immanuel Can
Posts: 30600
Joined: Wed Sep 25, 2013 4:42 pm

Re: God and morality

Post by Immanuel Can »

Alexis Jacobi wrote: ↑Thu Nov 19, 2026 1:29 pm The quintessential thing, the essence, is the belief in, the dedication to, ultimate strength of the spirit over the material and biological world.
No, that's Gnosticism. Christianity has no contemptus mundi in it. It regards the material world as good, and as a gift from God...though now fallen. But it projects a salvation that is enacted within the material world, rather than some Hindu "heaven" or Buddhist soul extinction in Nirvana.

This is but one of the vast differences between Christian theology and your Vedantism. No contemptus mundi. But as I said earlier, the "Christ" concept also bears no real resemblance to the Hebrew Messiah or the Yeshua Hamashiach (which both mean "anointed one") of the Bible. If you think Krishna-consciousness is anywhere close to Christian salvation, you don't know much about one of the two, at least.
“the second coming” as an interior event within man,
Not Biblically, it isn't. Biblically, it's actual and external. That's yet another stark difference from Vedantism.
So IC, whatever you want to say — as response — you will surely say.
And you'll find I'm telling you the truth. Christianity has no correspondence to Vedantism, and what you're pulling is the old Jain trick again -- pretend that everybody else's religion is the same as one's own, replaceable with one's own, and with the implicit implication that Jainism or whatever other soft-headed ideology is superior.

That's nothing the liberals have been reluctant to do for a hundred or more years now. It's so convenient...it lets them pretend to be inclusive and comprehensive of everything, while never having to find their own liberalism or preferred other ideology challenged by anything.

But it's just a ruse. They're not taking anybody seriously. That's why they have to keep the particulars of other religions and ideologies is broad, fuzzy focus; it's the only way they can manage to continue to convince themselves of something obviously false.
User avatar
Alexis Jacobi
Posts: 9244
Joined: Tue Oct 26, 2021 3:00 am

Re: God and morality

Post by Alexis Jacobi »

FlashDangerpants wrote: ↑Thu Nov 19, 2026 12:06 am Wow, the dude posing with the conspiracy-theorist book about "white genocide" there appears to be notorious white-supremacist hate preacher Joel Webbon, author of the far-right conspiracy book in question.
If I have understood correctly, you are the Forum representative of “philosophy”. You know the ropes, you got it all worked out and your purpose is to jump in and make it plain that all those you confront have got it wrong. They just cannot think as you can.

The interesting thing however about you (from my own angle) is the degree to which you are blind to your own biases and prejudices. So to all appearances — and your stance is common ant typical — every position that is remotely non-progressive, or reactionary to Progressivism, is from a Nazi camp. It is that reductive, that mechanical.

You give no evidence at all of being capable of reasoning soundly and fairly within the domains of conservative thought, of concern over social issues, nor do you have any grasp at all about the ways-and-means people go about defining and defending what belongs to them. Their cities, their nations, the continuity of their civilization, the health and well-being of their children, et cetera.

I do not see how you can defend your stance, and your attitude, as being “genuinely philosophical”. Though I can see it and I do see it as defensive and reactionary in its own way.

The thing that interests me is just here and in this. The presuppositions of our Liberal societies are enforced with great conviction. And that conviction has, standing behind it, a powerful repressive mechanism and authoritarian basis. It is curious here to consider that when Fuentes at 18 years took a position that was critical of Israel (and reactionary in other areas) and that The System sought to DESTROY him. Banning from communication channels, banning by banks, put on the No-Fly list, and banning by dozens of other platforms. That is the ‘mechanism’ I refer to and the authoritarianism.

The point? When you close off channels of expression, and provided you are dealing with living, spirited men, the oppressive intent pushes them into evermore reactive postures.

That is basically where you reside. The more that “you” repress (and shame) the more you evoke reaction.

Unlike you, my position is to try to understand how and on what people ground their convictions. Great Replacement is a good area to start (you bring up his book on “White genocide”). Each issue has a basis in an idea, a perception, a description. And you cannot understand the concern unless and until you acknowledge its validity.
User avatar
Alexis Jacobi
Posts: 9244
Joined: Tue Oct 26, 2021 3:00 am

Re: God and morality

Post by Alexis Jacobi »

Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Thu Nov 19, 2026 1:46 pm No, that's Gnosticism.
Here, by attaching a term that you define as negative, you simply push 100% to the side the essence that I communicated to you. That is how your mental system works. And though this is demonstrated time and again, and you will not move and indeed cannot be moved, the argumentation just goes round & round unendingly.

When you “hear” opposition (you hear but you don’t really listen) you launch into a defense that has nothing to do with what I have said.

That is the nature if your zealousness. It is impenetrable.
And you'll find I'm telling you the truth.
What I find is neither more nor less than what I clearly express. There is no part of your system, and the zealous positions it is based in, that I find to be “truthful” in a complete sense. You are are extremely invested in non-truthful things!

And that is really my point: the Edifice of Christian belief is constructed on partial truths, tendentious assertions, that are clarified by a more inclusive metaphysics.

And beyond doubt the more comprehensive understanding is certainly gnostic (involving clarifying knowledge) but is not Gnostic which is a specific system of belief that shadows Christianity.
Last edited by Alexis Jacobi on Thu Nov 19, 2026 2:30 pm, edited 1 time in total.
User avatar
Immanuel Can
Posts: 30600
Joined: Wed Sep 25, 2013 4:42 pm

Re: God and morality

Post by Immanuel Can »

Alexis Jacobi wrote: ↑Thu Nov 19, 2026 2:20 pm
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Thu Nov 19, 2026 1:46 pm No, that's Gnosticism.
Here, by attaching a term that you define as negative, you simply push 100% to the side the essence that I communicated to you.
Not at all. I'm not using "Gnostic" as a pejorative, but as a precise descriptive.

Anybody who opts for mind-body dualism, especially with the physical being regarded as a "trap" and negative, as something to be escaped, as you do, is by definition, channelling some kind of Gnosticism. That's just definitionally the case.
User avatar
Alexis Jacobi
Posts: 9244
Joined: Tue Oct 26, 2021 3:00 am

Re: God and morality

Post by Alexis Jacobi »

To a degree this is true. I wrote:
And beyond doubt the more comprehensive understanding is certainly gnostic (involving clarifying knowledge) but is not Gnostic which is a specific system of belief that shadows Christianity.
User avatar
Immanuel Can
Posts: 30600
Joined: Wed Sep 25, 2013 4:42 pm

Re: God and morality

Post by Immanuel Can »

Alexis Jacobi wrote: ↑Thu Nov 19, 2026 2:31 pm To a degree this is true. I wrote:
And beyond doubt the more comprehensive understanding is certainly gnostic
So you say.

So what you just characterized as a pejorative, you even use of yourself. So if it's an insult, it's you insulting yourself. The label was quite descriptively correct, apparently.

Try not to be so thin-skinned, AJ. Sometimes you really go off half-cocked, when what's being said is only accurate.
User avatar
phyllo
Posts: 3425
Joined: Sun Oct 27, 2013 5:58 pm
Location: Victory in Ukraine

Re: God and morality

Post by phyllo »

Anybody who opts for mind-body dualism, especially with the physical being regarded as a "trap" and negative, as something to be escaped, as you do, is by definition, channelling some kind of Gnosticism. That's just definitionally the case.
All Christianity believes in mind-body dualism. At least in the modern age.
Impenitent
Posts: 6398
Joined: Wed Feb 10, 2010 2:04 pm

Re: God and morality

Post by Impenitent »

phyllo wrote: ↑Thu Nov 19, 2026 2:49 pm
Anybody who opts for mind-body dualism, especially with the physical being regarded as a "trap" and negative, as something to be escaped, as you do, is by definition, channelling some kind of Gnosticism. That's just definitionally the case.
All Christianity believes in mind-body dualism. At least in the modern age.
pistols at dawn!

some duelisms are better than others...

-Imp
User avatar
Immanuel Can
Posts: 30600
Joined: Wed Sep 25, 2013 4:42 pm

Re: God and morality

Post by Immanuel Can »

phyllo wrote: ↑Thu Nov 19, 2026 2:49 pm
Anybody who opts for mind-body dualism, especially with the physical being regarded as a "trap" and negative, as something to be escaped, as you do, is by definition, channelling some kind of Gnosticism. That's just definitionally the case.
All Christianity believes in mind-body dualism. At least in the modern age.
Nope. We don't.
Post Reply