Re: God and morality
Posted: Wed Nov 18, 2026 12:23 am
Well, butter my butt and call me a biscuit!!!
Now ^^that^^ (if only it were true) would be wonderful.Alexis Jacobi wrote: ↑Tue Nov 17, 2026 5:22 pm I attempt — singlehandedly! — to resurrect the possibility of belief in a source of intelligence outside and beyond the world of Nature, where we are inevitably stuck unless we can revision things. And I do this by attempting a newer, metaphysical definition: to revivify a Conceptual Pathway.
...has been made exceedingly clear to us by you not only admitting to being a Trump supporter, but also by you constantly referring us to the works of white nationalist racists such as Jonathan Bowden and Nick Fuentes, just to name a few.“...resurrect the possibility of belief in a source of intelligence outside and beyond the world of Nature..."
If so, then how about you stop with the Ageian hints and teases and present your proposal?“...metaphysical definition: to revivify a Conceptual Pathway...”
If Alexis Jacobi is to speak for all of humankind the answer tips toward the former and the latter is uniquely for special cases who are, I think, pretty rare.Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Tue Nov 17, 2026 9:02 pm Is the purpose of "religion" to "function" for "needs"? Or is it supposed to be a description of truth, no matter what "needs" it does or does not address?
What I can say, my most esteemed and reverend Seeds, is that my “intellectual journey” has been quite bizarre. I have to credit my reading of The Genealogy of Morals for its strong influence of blowing up inherited assumptions about, well, everything. (But I am not a Nietzschean if such really exists).
Where is 'whiteness' in Christian theology?His ideas are radical, but he presents them as grounded in defensible Christian theology.
Is this directed to me?!
[before 900; Middle English; Old English cyn; c. Old Saxon, Old High German kunni, Old Norse kyn, Gothic kuni; akin to Latin genus, Greek génos, Skt jánas. compare gender.]
See Phyllo? What happens when you (when one) begins to think about things that had been placed in a category of forbidden thought?• jána = a person, a creature, a folk, a tribe
• jánas = the people, in the collective sense — a people, a community, the folk
• jánāḥ (plural) = peoples, tribes
Well, you are asking ME that question? In Catholic social teaching (doctrine) the notion of kin (a people) is understood to be defensible and therefore ethical. Your people are your people.phyllo wrote: ↑Wed Nov 18, 2026 2:42 pm Where is that in Christian theology?
If one gives special status to one's 'tribe', the current logical replacement of 'tribe' would be the nation-state. So Americans would be the "kin" and that would be color-blind. White Americans, black Americans, Chinese Americans, etc would be sharing kinship. But oddly, the kinship proposed is based on skin-color. That's something which is divisive and is going to exclude large segments of the population of the nation-state.
AJ, as usual, it seems, has got Christian theology dead wrong here. He hasn't even apparently read Christ's response to the question, "And who is my neighbour?" (Luke 10:25-36)phyllo wrote: ↑Wed Nov 18, 2026 2:42 pm Where is that in Christian theology?
If one gives special status to one's 'tribe', the current logical replacement of 'tribe' would be the nation-state. So Americans would be the "kin" and that would be color-blind. White Americans, black Americans, Chinese Americans, etc would be sharing kinship. But oddly, the kinship proposed is based on skin-color. That's something which is divisive and is going to exclude large segments of the population of the nation-state.
My view? We have to see nearly everything going on in the States, and in Europe, by way of resistance and reaction. The reaction of these radical Christians arose by way of specific causes. For example the social engineering campaign known as “multiculturalism”. If my understanding is correct this was a big deal in the 80s and 90s. Didn’t Hillary Clinton write a book on The Global Village? These were (are they still?) mass cultural engineering projects directed by agencies which are directed by business interests. I.e. nothing “organic” about them, all too-down.If one gives special status to one's 'tribe', the current logical replacement of 'tribe' would be the nation-state. So Americans would be the "kin" and that would be color-blind. White Americans, black Americans, Chinese Americans, etc would be sharing kinship. But oddly, the kinship proposed is based on skin-color. That's something which is divisive and is going to exclude large segments of the population of the nation-state.
Maybe to you. But it's an obvious one.Alexis Jacobi wrote: ↑Wed Nov 18, 2026 1:06 pmYour question, when examined, is really kind of odd.Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Tue Nov 17, 2026 9:02 pm Is the purpose of "religion" to "function" for "needs"? Or is it supposed to be a description of truth, no matter what "needs" it does or does not address?
My view? I am referencing views expressed by American Chritian radicals. And trying to explain on what basis they present their notions.Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Wed Nov 18, 2026 3:52 pm There's a reason the parable is nowadays known as "The Good Samaritan." A "Samaritan" was a hated, sworn enemy of Jewish folks. That such a wretch would turn out to be "good" would have come as a total surprise to any Jew.
Christ's answer is that one's "neighbour" is the person in need, be he friend or enemy. In fact, Christ's "tribe" or "kin" come off much worse in the parable, since they ignore the wounded man, and the Samaritan shows the exemplary compassion Christ is encouraging.
The upshot is the the message there is the dead opposite of what AJ is saying it is: it's not "love your kin," or "love the person you want to love," but "love your enemy" -- a message Christ repeated quite often, much to everybody's surprise.