Page 87 of 94

Re: God and morality

Posted: Tue Nov 17, 2026 4:36 pm
by Alexis Jacobi
AJ wrote:You have missed the point.
IC wrote:No, I got it. I saw the point he didn't want me to note. Did you?
Can you please explain? What point is that?

Re: God and morality

Posted: Tue Nov 17, 2026 4:45 pm
by Immanuel Can
Alexis Jacobi wrote: ↑Tue Nov 17, 2026 4:36 pm
AJ wrote:You have missed the point.
IC wrote:No, I got it. I saw the point he didn't want me to note. Did you?
Can you please explain? What point is that?
I did explain. Nietzsche wants you to believe something he says about what God is, and how God came to be, and that God is "dead", merely as a just-so story, without him having to present one shred of evidence it's even true! :shock:

Did you catch him out at his game? No. Did I? Yes.

Re: God and morality

Posted: Tue Nov 17, 2026 5:22 pm
by Alexis Jacobi
Nietzsche wants you to believe something he says about what God is, and how God came to be, and that God is "dead", merely as a just-so story, without him having to present one shred of evidence it's even true!
This is a part of it, but the parts you leave out must be included. I am uncertain if you can acknowledge them.

What Nietzsche deals on, mostly, is that for many, and maybe most (in influential circles), it became impossible to believe in the Story of Christianity exactly because it is a “Just so” story.

The God that sustained a civilization for centuries, in the sense of the supporting story, became impossible to believe. These are facts, IC. And significantly we now live in the aftermath of that.

Now, surely there is more much mire to Nietzsche but this is what “God died” means.

I attempt — singlehandedly! — to resurrect the possibility of belief in a source of intelligence outside and beyond the world of Nature, where we are inevitably stuck unless we can revision things. And I do this by attempting a newer, metaphysical definition: to revivify a Conceptual Pathway.

Re: God and morality

Posted: Tue Nov 17, 2026 5:35 pm
by Immanuel Can
Alexis Jacobi wrote: ↑Tue Nov 17, 2026 5:22 pm
Nietzsche wants you to believe something he says about what God is, and how God came to be, and that God is "dead", merely as a just-so story, without him having to present one shred of evidence it's even true!
This is a part of it, but the parts you leave out must be included. I am uncertain if you can acknowledge them.

What Nietzsche deals on, mostly, is that for many, and maybe most (in influential circles), it became impossible to believe in the Story of Christianity exactly because it is a “Just so” story.
Yes, this is his claim. I've already mentioned that. But he makes it without evidence.
The God that sustained a civilization for centuries, in the sense of the supporting story, became impossible to believe. These are facts, IC.
"These are facts" is another telling phrase. :D No, these are not "facts." These are suppositions, pseudo-history, and a kind of false prophecy, since God did not disappear from human affairs as the Modern period progressed; rather, the trend reversed, and there are now more believers in God in the world than at any time in history.

Somehow, Nietzsche got it exactly wrong. But I think we can see his error. He was inducing from the fact that modern life had become much more convenient and self-sufficient by the turn of the 20th Century (Nietzsche died without seeing it) than in previous history. But what Nietzsche did not see, what he could not foresee, were the disasters that century would visit on humanity, and all in the name of Modern Rationalism. For one thing, there were two world wars of such hideous violence that men were driven away from their confidence in the progressive rationalization of human independence, and were thrown back viciously, by the excesses of their own nature, into questioning the Modern project.

Hence, we now live in the Post-Modern period, in which the excesses and follies of Modernism are daily rehearsed. And all this is in the secular realm, as well; it is no Christian who has pulled down the false tower of Modernity, but rather it has been the secularists who observed the choices made by those who believed in it, and the persistent cruelty of human nature, and thus sought out and found the irrationalities of Modernism itself.

Nietzsche could not foresee that belief in God is far more durable than he imagined, and far more necessary than he had conceived, or that Modernism itself would prove such a human disaster; and that he would be proved conclusively wrong by the middle of the last century. But we can see it today.

Re: God and morality

Posted: Tue Nov 17, 2026 7:13 pm
by Alexis Jacobi
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Tue Nov 17, 2026 5:35 pm These are facts" is another telling phrase. No, these are not "facts." These are suppositions, pseudo-history, and a kind of false prophecy, since God did not disappear from human affairs as the Modern period progressed; rather, the trend reversed, and there are now more believers in God in the world than at any time in history.
Yes, I am aware: but the shift is to the Global South: sub-Saharan Africa, South America, and South Asia. Peasant cultures and post-peasant cultures. I am aware of this because I live in S. America. I pass the Pentecostal churches regularly. It is a bizarre, cultish expression of enthusiastic religiosity.

Similarly, Islam is also expanding and more than Evangelical Christianity. Religion meets all kinds of needs and has “functions” that are not necessarily spiritual. And though I doubt you will pay attention to the New Christian Right videos, were you to watch them you would see that that enthusiasm is not without some problematic aspects.

But my own concern, the culture I am concerned about, are the post-religious and the post-Christian.
Nietzsche could not foresee that belief in God is far more durable than he imagined, and far more necessary than he had conceived, or that Modernism itself would prove such a human disaster; and that he would be proved conclusively wrong by the middle of the last century. But we can see it today.
I do not see the Pentecostal or the Islamic religiousness as being necessarily very positive, nor is such conversion very durable. Because it is grounded, based on, silly Just So stories.

That is why I say: the real hope for both religiousness and spirituality is by way of deepening one’s metaphysical grasp. And that can easily be noted in what I have posted of Aurobindo’s commentary.

Here, IC, you are not among peasants of S. America or Africa. You have so little self-consciousness about this.
But we can see it today.
We see many different things. And many of them I attempt to discuss.

Re: God and morality

Posted: Tue Nov 17, 2026 7:30 pm
by Alexis Jacobi
AJ wrote:The God that sustained a civilization for centuries, in the sense of the supporting story, became impossible to believe. These are facts, IC.
IC wrote:"These are facts" is another telling phrase.
Here’s the key, here is the truth: It is impossible to explain God to any modern person, and any denizen on this forum, if and when the terms of belief, the supports, are the Genesis story elements. There is not ONE PERSON here who is capable of belief in God on that basis!

So, if “God” is to be explained it cannot be by way of these elements, it will have to be by some other apologetic means.

Yes IC, you can influence and convince a semi-educated peasant in Latin America or Africa. Yes! And your rhetorical skills will have some successes. But it cannot hold!

This is the core of my opposition to your position. To achieve “belief” you must necessarily demand a regressive step.

I desire steps and movements that are durable. Thus: the reconstruction of metaphysics. The “stories” fall away. The ideas remain.

Re: God and morality

Posted: Tue Nov 17, 2026 7:40 pm
by phyllo
Why would Genesis be the basis of belief in God for anyone?

Re: God and morality

Posted: Tue Nov 17, 2026 7:49 pm
by Alexis Jacobi
On what basis could you construct a way to believe in God or explain God if you did not have a Genesis-like story?

Re: God and morality

Posted: Tue Nov 17, 2026 7:51 pm
by promethean75
"An intelligent man thinks God would not be so insulting to him as to have him believe any of the crude rubbish in the bible... nor so insulting to itself as to expect such rubbish to be accepted by anyone as evidence of it." - Johannes Habbletrap

Re: God and morality

Posted: Tue Nov 17, 2026 8:14 pm
by Alexis Jacobi
He really was a great man …

Re: God and morality

Posted: Tue Nov 17, 2026 8:59 pm
by phyllo
Alexis Jacobi wrote: ↑Tue Nov 17, 2026 7:49 pm On what basis could you construct a way to believe in God or explain God if you did not have a Genesis-like story?
Assume that my posts are directed at anyone except you.

Re: God and morality

Posted: Tue Nov 17, 2026 9:02 pm
by Immanuel Can
Alexis Jacobi wrote: ↑Tue Nov 17, 2026 7:13 pm Islam is also expanding and more than Evangelical Christianity.
It's not, actually; and it's primarily "expanding" by reproduction, not by voluntary conversion.
Religion meets all kinds of needs and has “functions” that are not necessarily spiritual. And though I doubt you will pay attention to the New Christian Right videos, were you to watch them you would see that that enthusiasm is not without some problematic aspects.
Is the purpose of "religion" to "function" for "needs"? Or is it supposed to be a description of truth, no matter what "needs" it does or does not address?
Nietzsche could not foresee that belief in God is far more durable than he imagined, and far more necessary than he had conceived, or that Modernism itself would prove such a human disaster; and that he would be proved conclusively wrong by the middle of the last century. But we can see it today.
I do not see the Pentecostal or the Islamic religiousness as being necessarily very positive, nor is such conversion very durable.
I agree with you about Islam. And Pentecostalism seems to me more of a "gateway" kind of religiosity. But how durable is it? That's a good question. Does it issue in agnostics or Atheists later? Or do Pentecostals tend to grow into more dedicated and informed versions of Christianity?

In my experience, it's often the latter. Pentecostalism gets people started, sometimes; but as their knowledge increases, I find they tend to migrate towards more cerebral forms of Christian expression, rather than becoming cynics.
Here, IC, you are not among peasants of S. America or Africa. You have so little self-consciousness about this.
:lol: How often you are wrong!

Oh, man...if only you knew. Oh well. Keep thinking that, if you want to.

Re: God and morality

Posted: Tue Nov 17, 2026 10:49 pm
by Alexis Jacobi
phyllo wrote: ↑Tue Nov 17, 2026 8:59 pm
Alexis Jacobi wrote: ↑Tue Nov 17, 2026 7:49 pm On what basis could you construct a way to believe in God or explain God if you did not have a Genesis-like story?
Assume that my posts are directed at anyone except you.
Harumph! 😤

Re: God and morality

Posted: Tue Nov 17, 2026 11:15 pm
by phyllo
Every religion has a creation myth.

Even non-religions have creation myths. Science has a creation myth.

What does a creation myth say about god? Nothing. It says something about the people who create and sustain the myth.

Re: God and morality

Posted: Wed Nov 18, 2026 12:22 am
by MikeNovack
phyllo wrote: ↑Tue Nov 17, 2026 11:15 pm What does a creation myth say about god? Nothing. It says something about the people who create and sustain the myth.
Absolutely, which means if we study a myth, we learn something about the people who created the myth.

We might also learn something about a second people, who adopt the myth, and sustain it as their own (often with different meaning than the people who created the myth.