God and morality
-
promethean75
- Posts: 8105
- Joined: Sun Nov 04, 2018 10:29 pm
Re: God and morality
Self-destruction. That's all we can do, bro. Some straight Fight Club style fractured self alter ego surrendering to fate shit. Just take your hands off the wheel and don't even steer the car, seeds. I do it all the time. I be still and surrender to fate. If I crash, so what. I am nothing. May I at least then be the author of my own destruction and will it? Can I have at least that much?
With your permission, would I be able to recite a poem by one Edgar Allen Poe at this moment, gentlemen?
With your permission, would I be able to recite a poem by one Edgar Allen Poe at this moment, gentlemen?
- Alexis Jacobi
- Posts: 9244
- Joined: Tue Oct 26, 2021 3:00 am
Re: God and morality
This seems to be the basic idea in your shtick: that the defense (the nuanced explanation rather) of Vedanta is an Occidental conceit. However I must mention some important qualifiers. My focus presently is on Aurobindo and so I focus on his school of thought. He had a very rigorous intellectual training in England. His base in “Occidental categories” preceded his return, as it were, to Vedic-based categories. And for those who have read his commentary on the BG, written in English, it is not had to see that he is undertaking, or performing, a synthesis and is explaining to the Occidental mind, and to his own mind really, what principles are being stated in this odd religious document that is the Bhagavad Gita (which is itself a synthesis of a long train of philosophical, religious and spiritual thought of the Indian Subcontinent).Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Tue Nov 17, 2026 1:59 am This is the very routine Western conceit...the belief that all religions somehow can be subsumed into the thing the Westerner already prefers to believe. It's what I call "Beatles Buddhism."
I do not believe that Aurobindo or any exponent of so-called Hinduism that has influenced the Occident beginning perhaps in the late 1800s (Vivekananda, Paramahansa Yogananda, Aurobindo being three who come to mind as arising out of that time) express “Western conceits”. It is fair to say however that they attempt an depth explanation of Occidental Christianity by way of metaphysical systems that far antecede Christianity. As I have said before it is not hard for the Vedic-grounded mind to see (i.e. to interpret) the Advent of Jesus as a manifestation of what Vishnu represents on a metaphysical plane. And what is that? The providing of a Key that allows man to transcend a fallen condition.
Now, if we see the influence of these Vedantists in a positive light, and in the precise context of the Nietzschean rebellion and the Nietzschean attempt to recover and redefine man’s genuine spiritual power, this involved the declaration that “God had died” — which is certainly true on a conceptual level. It was now impossible, by way of materialism, to “explain” God. You see, the Nietzschean outlook was not an overtly or maliciously destructive one. It had to occur as men came back into the truth of real existence, the honesty as to what really is. That is quite likely what occurred in all if us who were exposed to Nietzschean dynamiting. (I am pretty sure that you do not understand what I am talking about here).
Curiously, Aurobindo perhaps more than Vivekananda and Yogananda, began in a sense under a more Nietzschean mood: he was when young a Hindu nationalist revolutionary and was jailed at one time. The reason I bring this up is because Aurobindo’s definitions of the true man of “Arya” directly and without any doubt came to oppose that “Aryan-Nietzschean” definition that flowed out of Europe in the early 1900s and in the Interwar Period. It is in that definition — of the spiritual man — that Aurobindo’s definitions of God and, say, “what God wants” of man, best dovetail with the more exalted Christian definitions. (I am certain I can demonstrate this).
But here is the Key and this obviously cuts a little close to home in your case: Your religion, and your metaphysics, depend on a story-base that simply put cannot be upheld by the modern intellect. That’s it. We’ve been through this a hundred times. A metaphysics based on phantasy-pictures has collapsed — except for those of a literalist mind-frame. But I do not deny the zealous Pentecostal fires that sweep Africa, South America, and even Asia. But that is all among people who 1) succeed in thinking through collapsed stories and 2) among uneducated classes, or to put it another way pre-moderns.
- Alexis Jacobi
- Posts: 9244
- Joined: Tue Oct 26, 2021 3:00 am
Re: God and morality
Because I like to keep things “topical” (even though few and even perhaps no one is really interested in these issues) I wish to remind my imagined reader that all the ideas we are discussing here are not long dead and forgotten, but are playing out in front of us right now. There is in this sense a “Nietzschean Christianity” very much afoot today in the US. It is not going to get weaker as a result of the Democrat Tsunami but quite the opposite is going to grow stronger. I submit as evidence this speech given by Joel Webbon at the recent (post-Mid-term) conference of Christian nationalism (New Christian Right).
I sort of direct this to our own forum star and deep-thinking philosophical Doctor Flash because he is so very interested in these regressive, traditionalist, backward/forwards movements within contemporary culture.
Webbon deals on Christian Identity, national identity, race-realism, and an obvious and overt ant-Zionist and Judaic-critical posture — capping it off with a critique of feminism. Whew! The whirlwinds begin to pick up sone autumnal leaves!
The conference was titled Christ Is King and as I say, and myself believe, the definition of a King on a metaphysical level is necessary, but as it is being used — overtly on the political plane — it is certainly dangerous.
I sort of direct this to our own forum star and deep-thinking philosophical Doctor Flash because he is so very interested in these regressive, traditionalist, backward/forwards movements within contemporary culture.
Webbon deals on Christian Identity, national identity, race-realism, and an obvious and overt ant-Zionist and Judaic-critical posture — capping it off with a critique of feminism. Whew! The whirlwinds begin to pick up sone autumnal leaves!
The conference was titled Christ Is King and as I say, and myself believe, the definition of a King on a metaphysical level is necessary, but as it is being used — overtly on the political plane — it is certainly dangerous.
- Alexis Jacobi
- Posts: 9244
- Joined: Tue Oct 26, 2021 3:00 am
Re: God and morality
Well, the entire decade-long conversation on this Forum directly deals on “what is true”. I do not think that we have established in any final form “that which is true”. I am aware that you definitely believe you have and hold “what is true” and can and do present it to your audience. That much is clear. And everyone is aware that I “share agreements” with much in Christian philosophy and spirituality … but we do not have AGREEMENTS as to the genuine metaphysical base.
So we are sort of back in that situation where Jain blind men touch & feel & present definitions as to “what is”.
And I know you do couch the solidity of your position in a non-contradiction assertion. Haven’t forgotten!Talk and song from tongues of lilting grace, whose sounds caress my ear / But not a word I heard could I relate, the story was quite clear
- Immanuel Can
- Posts: 30600
- Joined: Wed Sep 25, 2013 4:42 pm
Re: God and morality
Not at all. It's a Hindu job. Ironically, a lot of Westerners (like yourself) have taken it up, and have tried to speak for the Hindus, as if their failure to do what job meant that you were the right one to tell them what they believe, instead. I find that a bit ironic.Alexis Jacobi wrote: ↑Tue Nov 17, 2026 1:53 pmThis seems to be the basic idea in your shtick: that the defense (the nuanced explanation rather) of Vedanta is an Occidental conceit.Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Tue Nov 17, 2026 1:59 am This is the very routine Western conceit...the belief that all religions somehow can be subsumed into the thing the Westerner already prefers to believe. It's what I call "Beatles Buddhism."
That's only because they don't really know anything about Jesus. He, Himself, ruled out any such nonsense reading. And one pass through the gospels would be enough to show that abundantly....it is not hard for the Vedic-grounded mind to see (i.e. to interpret) the Advent of Jesus as a manifestation of what Vishnu represents on a metaphysical plane.
So whatever your "Vedantists" are doing, it's not repeating the Scripture; it's "co-opting" it for some purpose of their own, namely, for insisting that the Gita and such are the ultimate revelation, and what Christians and Jews believe is just some palid and partial attempt to come up to the wisdom of the Hindus.
That's the problem. Nietzsche did nothing at all to PROVE that "God is dead": what he did, instead, is just spin an "alternate history" of God, so to speak...namely, the possibility that mere men had made the whole God concept up, and that now, modern man having outgrown his need for gods, was logically in a position to recognize he'd been fooling himself all along.You see, the Nietzschean outlook was not an overtly or maliciously destructive one. It had to occur as men came back into the truth of real existence, the honesty as to what really is.
But a possibility-story isn't an argument. In fact, it may well be no more than a "just-so" story, like the children's story about how the giraffe got his long neck, or how the cat lost his tail. That, let us say, it could have happened that way does not imply it did happen that way. What's lacking is the demonstration that Nietzsche's fable was ever the truth. And I think there are serious reasons to doubt Nietzsche's fable, such as the universality of belief in gods or God, or the manifest evidence of intelligent design in the natural world.
Before you do, justify your claim that some "Christian definitions" are "more exalted" than others. I'd be interested to see how you're doing that....“what God wants” of man, best dovetail with the more exalted Christian definitions. (I am certain I can demonstrate this)...
Apparently, it can. There are more Christian people in this world today than at any time in history. How is it that you don't know that? You could know it. The stats are available to you....But here is the Key and this obviously cuts a little close to home in your case: Your religion, and your metaphysics, depend on a story-base that simply put cannot be upheld by the modern intellect.
- Immanuel Can
- Posts: 30600
- Joined: Wed Sep 25, 2013 4:42 pm
Re: God and morality
Seriously? Are you still operating with theology at the level of Doctor Seuss?
Let me know when you get up to "Horton Hears a Who." That's a good one.
But let's parse that Jain story, so you can see the co-opting that's going on: because it is.
The story self-presents as "tolerant" or "inclusive," precisely because all the various "wise men" are supposedly blind, as well. So they can only grasp part of the elephant, and see it as "a rope," or "a post," or whatever. (This is a problem of epistemology: that men do not know everything.)
But step back to the ontological level. The story only works because there is an elephant there. And it's a whole elephant, which is neither rope, nor post, nor snake, nor any other partial bit. And who knows? Who has solved the epistemic problem? The Jain. Only the Jain. Not the others.
If the Jain were just another "blind man," the story would not even work. Then, the Jain would maybe grab an eyeball, and declare, "This elephant is a jelly-like creature," or some other partial and erroneous view. But the story allows the smug position of superiority solely to the Jain narrator, who among all the participants, is the only one who understands the whole elephant.
The rest are not merely only partially right; they aren't really right AT ALL, since each comes away with a completely distorted picture of the whole: only the Jain narrator escapes that trap.
Thus, the story turns out to be that the Jains are right, and everybody else is, not partially right, but ultimately really wrong about the general nature of what an elephant is. They're all blind except the Jain.
Thus, even in this Jainist parable, you find the same features of all religions: denial of the validity of the others. You also find a surreptitious attempt to co-opt all other religions into service of the Jain narrative. But only the Jains get to win.
That's why I point out to you that all religions are ultimately exclusivist. Even this seemingly-inclusive Jain parable turns out not to be, and is offensive in its implications to all the other beliefs it attempts to include, precisely because it co-opts them to its own narrative, and subordinates them, making them beneath Jainism.
- Alexis Jacobi
- Posts: 9244
- Joined: Tue Oct 26, 2021 3:00 am
Re: God and morality
That’s a misunderstanding, a misconstruing. The Hindus were capable enough on their own. My view is that as a result of Christian failure, and the success as it were of Occidental materialistic science, that recourse to a better metaphysical picture was the only move possible.Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Tue Nov 17, 2026 3:19 pm Not at all. It's a Hindu job. Ironically, a lot of Westerners (like yourself) have taken it up, and have tried to speak for the Hindus, as if their failure to do what job meant that you were the right one to tell them what they believe, instead. I find that a bit ironic.
How would you express this? What is it that must be known to fill that gap?That's only because they don't really know anything about Jesus.
What is expressed in Christian scripture is equally well expressed in Aurobindo’s Vedic philosophy. There is no doubt about this. And when one has realized this, the only next step possible is to ‘practice’ what one understands to be the most important, the most significant.So whatever your "Vedantists" are doing, it's not repeating the Scripture; it's "co-opting" it for some purpose of their own, namely, for insisting that the Gita and such are the ultimate revelation, and what Christians and Jews believe is just some pallid and partial attempt to come up to the wisdom of the Hindus.
Because of your acute prejudices — these are legion — you seem not to be able to get beyond yourself.
You have missed the point. He demonstrated how a series of outdated stories no longer could uphold a phantasy-picture that supported the notion of the God so portrayed. This is really your problem as well. To your listening audience the God you preach is indeed dead.Nietzsche did nothing at all to PROVE that "God is dead"
This is where I come in, of course. I see that you apologetics does not achieve the result you desire. My endeavor has been to re-explain and clarify what is really meant. To that end, as I tire of repeating, a fuller metaphysical picture helps.
As we go on I think more will be clarified.
-
promethean75
- Posts: 8105
- Joined: Sun Nov 04, 2018 10:29 pm
Re: God and morality
"Let me know when you get up to "Horton Hears a Who." That's a good one."
Speaking of great children's books, have you read the Jew and the Hat. There's this one scene where a bunch of people are getting ready to eat, but there aren't enough fish. Another guy performs a magic trick and says something like "one fish, two, fish, three fish, four. To have nine fish, I would need five more!"
I used to love that one as a kid. Teacher would read it to us when we we're learning to count.
Speaking of great children's books, have you read the Jew and the Hat. There's this one scene where a bunch of people are getting ready to eat, but there aren't enough fish. Another guy performs a magic trick and says something like "one fish, two, fish, three fish, four. To have nine fish, I would need five more!"
I used to love that one as a kid. Teacher would read it to us when we we're learning to count.
- Alexis Jacobi
- Posts: 9244
- Joined: Tue Oct 26, 2021 3:00 am
Re: God and morality
I really REALLY get your view of the story and the epistemological and ontological distinction. I just do not agree with how you use it.Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Tue Nov 17, 2026 3:21 pm
Thus, even in this Jainist parable, you find the same features of all religions: denial of the validity of the others. You also find a surreptitious attempt to co-opt all other religions into service of the Jain narrative. But only the Jains get to win.
That's why I point out to you that all religions are ultimately exclusivist. Even this seemingly-inclusive Jain parable turns out not to be, and is offensive in its implications to all the other beliefs it attempts to include, precisely because it co-opts them to its own narrative, and subordinates them, making them beneath Jainism.
- Immanuel Can
- Posts: 30600
- Joined: Wed Sep 25, 2013 4:42 pm
Re: God and morality
I'm pointing out the features of the story that the Jains wouldn't want you to notice.Alexis Jacobi wrote: ↑Tue Nov 17, 2026 3:48 pmI really REALLY get your view of the story and the epistemological and ontological distinction. I just do not agree with how you use it.Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Tue Nov 17, 2026 3:21 pm
Thus, even in this Jainist parable, you find the same features of all religions: denial of the validity of the others. You also find a surreptitious attempt to co-opt all other religions into service of the Jain narrative. But only the Jains get to win.
That's why I point out to you that all religions are ultimately exclusivist. Even this seemingly-inclusive Jain parable turns out not to be, and is offensive in its implications to all the other beliefs it attempts to include, precisely because it co-opts them to its own narrative, and subordinates them, making them beneath Jainism.
But this sort of co-opting is common among "inclusive" religious views. Unitarians do it, the United do it, the Hindus and Sikhs do it...so do some Catholics (though their idea of "general grace" and Karl Rahner's "anonymous Christian" concept). It's very usual for an "inclusive" religious view to use some strategy to explain how that everybody else is second-class, at best, relative to themselves, or that everybody's the same as them even if they don't know they are.
The problem is that the strategy itself is not inclusive but very hegemonic. Everybody else turns out not only to have nothing special to offer, but also just be an accidental or ignorant Hindu, or Catholic, or Unitarian, or Jain.
And, of course, the Hindus, the Jains, the Catholics, the Unitarians...they're not going to agree on which one of them is the FULL truth that the others are partially missing.
Exclusivism again. It's inevitable, because to believe something means, automatically, NOT to believe contrary things.
Re: God and morality
The narrator is not a Jain.The story self-presents as "tolerant" or "inclusive," precisely because all the various "wise men" are supposedly blind, as well. So they can only grasp part of the elephant, and see it as "a rope," or "a post," or whatever. (This is a problem of epistemology: that men do not know everything.)
But step back to the ontological level. The story only works because there is an elephant there. And it's a whole elephant, which is neither rope, nor post, nor snake, nor any other partial bit. And who knows? Who has solved the epistemic problem? The Jain. Only the Jain. Not the others.
If the Jain were just another "blind man," the story would not even work. Then, the Jain would maybe grab an eyeball, and declare, "This elephant is a jelly-like creature," or some other partial and erroneous view. But the story allows the smug position of superiority solely to the Jain narrator, who among all the participants, is the only one who understands the whole elephant.
The rest are not merely only partially right; they aren't really right AT ALL, since each comes away with a completely distorted picture of the whole: only the Jain narrator escapes that trap.
Thus, the story turns out to be that the Jains are right, and everybody else is, not partially right, but ultimately really wrong about the general nature of what an elephant is. They're all blind except the Jain.
The narrator represents the god's eye view, the absolute truth.
Neither the Jains nor others have access to that absolute truth.
That's the point of the story.
- Immanuel Can
- Posts: 30600
- Joined: Wed Sep 25, 2013 4:42 pm
Re: God and morality
Actually, he is. He's just not declared so -- precisely so that you will not notice the eighth participant in the story, among the seven "wise men". But somebody is telling it, and that somebody is standing somewhere, looking from an objective, outsider perspective.phyllo wrote: ↑Tue Nov 17, 2026 4:00 pmThe narrator is not a Jain.The story self-presents as "tolerant" or "inclusive," precisely because all the various "wise men" are supposedly blind, as well. So they can only grasp part of the elephant, and see it as "a rope," or "a post," or whatever. (This is a problem of epistemology: that men do not know everything.)
But step back to the ontological level. The story only works because there is an elephant there. And it's a whole elephant, which is neither rope, nor post, nor snake, nor any other partial bit. And who knows? Who has solved the epistemic problem? The Jain. Only the Jain. Not the others.
If the Jain were just another "blind man," the story would not even work. Then, the Jain would maybe grab an eyeball, and declare, "This elephant is a jelly-like creature," or some other partial and erroneous view. But the story allows the smug position of superiority solely to the Jain narrator, who among all the participants, is the only one who understands the whole elephant.
The rest are not merely only partially right; they aren't really right AT ALL, since each comes away with a completely distorted picture of the whole: only the Jain narrator escapes that trap.
Thus, the story turns out to be that the Jains are right, and everybody else is, not partially right, but ultimately really wrong about the general nature of what an elephant is. They're all blind except the Jain.
You say it's "the god" maybe. Or "absolute truth." But that only makes the situation even worse. Because the story has to belong to some tradition; somebody told it first. And whatever tradition it is, that tradition is then above and outside of not only the "wise men," but also of the "absolute truth," looking down objectively on the whole lot of them together.
- Immanuel Can
- Posts: 30600
- Joined: Wed Sep 25, 2013 4:42 pm
Re: God and morality
"There is no doubt."Alexis Jacobi wrote: ↑Tue Nov 17, 2026 3:45 pm What is expressed in Christian scripture is equally well expressed in Aurobindo’s Vedic philosophy. There is no doubt about this.
No, I got it. I saw the point he didn't want me to note. Did you?You have missed the point.Nietzsche did nothing at all to PROVE that "God is dead"
Re: God and morality
Somebody is telling it because you can't make the point without contrasting what the blind men experience and the absolute truth of the situation.Actually, he is. He's just not declared so -- precisely so that you will not notice the eighth participant in the story, among the seven "wise men". But somebody is telling it, and that somebody is standing somewhere, looking from an objective, outsider perspective.
- Alexis Jacobi
- Posts: 9244
- Joined: Tue Oct 26, 2021 3:00 am
Re: God and morality
Phhhhtttt!Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Tue Nov 17, 2026 4:16 pm "There is no doubt."I love to see that phrase. What it really means is, "Don't test me on this, because you're scaring me that you might be right."
You have as of yet done very little challenging but I do register the exhortations.
What There is no doubt means, from me, is that I have done my research and, in my present view, there is no doubt.
I know what is valuable in Christian doctrine and spirituality and I do not set up oppositions. That’s your issue, isn’t it?
Please, proceed with the testing.
And meanwhile here is Nick Fuentes at the New Christian Right conference. We live in interesting times!