So is the crutch of cosplaying the quiz meister for others.
God and morality
- FlashDangerpants
- Posts: 9356
- Joined: Mon Jan 04, 2016 11:54 pm
Re: God and morality
Now you've introduced some incel shit to accompany your racist drivel? Strong choice.Alexis Jacobi wrote: ↑Sun Nov 15, 2026 3:48 pm our culture has become weak and womanly and we (as men) have relinquished responsibility.
Re: God and morality
Wow! Two flat and nonsensical posts (jokes?) in the span of 3 minutes.Alexis Jacobi wrote: ↑Sun Nov 15, 2026 10:51 pmHow can you expect me or anyone to answer such a question!?! Everyone has their own private definition. Such basic stuff, Seeds!Anyway, just for the sake of clarification, how about you tell us what it is that you personally feel would be the absolute best and most beneficial "higher ideal" for us wallowers in the mire of Sammohaḥ to focus on?
And you have the gall to expect us to pay $250.00 per half hour for such disappointing output?
_______
- Alexis Jacobi
- Posts: 9244
- Joined: Tue Oct 26, 2021 3:00 am
Re: God and morality
As it happens the relationship between men and women today, especially among the younger set, is in a severe crisis. If we are to be realistic and to speak in honest terms I do not see a way around talking about this crisis on this thread dealing with God and Morality. Is it ridiculous on my part to attempt to go beyond superficial declarations about the “immorality” of modern culture and to try to find a more universal conceptual structure that explains what is happening and why it is happening? It also must be stated — as far as Incels go — that Flash, Gary, Promethean and likely quite a few others who spend time here are men without women.FlashDangerpants wrote: ↑Mon Nov 16, 2026 12:03 am Now you've introduced some incel shit to accompany your racist drivel? Strong choice.
Unless my data is all wrong, the social crisis that has erupted in Europe and America has a direct root in the issue that families are not producing children. It then becomes necessary to encourage mass immigration so there will be enough of a labor pool to keep things running. The real core is therefore in the destruction of the family. What force is it — in essential terms — that acts so destructively against the family? What analytical tools shall be used to make this determination?
The other factor which does not seem to be widely discussed except by specialists is the issue of the extreme ubiquity of pornography and the immense destructive effect it is having on world cultures.
If you were to list all the severe problems that have beset not only the Occident but the world as well, you’d wind up with a list dealing exclusively on social issues with “morality” at the base. But here is the curious thing: The language of morality is tied up with the concept of God and the religious matrix. And when people — let’s say a given person — reacts to 1) external corruption and immorality and 2) their own corrupted, inner state, they inevitably have to avail themselves of some system of metaphysics that defines a sane order upon which to reconstruct themselves.
- Alexis Jacobi
- Posts: 9244
- Joined: Tue Oct 26, 2021 3:00 am
Re: God and morality
What I have tried to express over the years is really just about this. The interplay, the conflict, the battles, between Left and Right, and Left and Right when their extremes are considered — these all arise out of reaction.
- Alexis Jacobi
- Posts: 9244
- Joined: Tue Oct 26, 2021 3:00 am
Re: God and morality
Bhagavad Gita, Chapter 1:
1.40
In the annihilation of the family the eternal traditions of the family are destroyed; in the collapse of traditions, lawlessness overcomes [the family].
1.41
Owing to predominance of lawlessness, O Krishna, the women of the family become corrupt; women corrupted, O Varshneya, the confusion of the Varnas arises.
1.42
This confusion leads to hell the ruiners of the family, and the family; for their ancestors fall, deprived of pinda (rice offering) and libations.
1.43
By these misdeeds of the ruiners of the family leading to the confusion of the Varnas, the eternal laws of caste and the eternal traditions of the family are destroyed.
- Alexis Jacobi
- Posts: 9244
- Joined: Tue Oct 26, 2021 3:00 am
Re: God and morality
The problem of ‘the corruption of women’ is problematic since, in fact, it is not women who are the cause of corruption but rather that they become the victims of it. The real responsibility for corruption is in men’s hands. However, it does seem true that if as a result of the corruption of men that women are infected, then it does seem that the entire ship goes down.
-
promethean75
- Posts: 8105
- Joined: Sun Nov 04, 2018 10:29 pm
Re: God and morality
'Fraid no matter what we do, we're doomed because of reproductive competition. We may have stood a chance if we were asexual organisms, but that's not the hand we were dealt, chief.
Best and only thing you can do now is bring on the next generation of surrogate AI companion sex robots. If you don't, hypergamy will cause exponential spikes in the incel population, and there will be pock-marked middle-aged gamers who know how to code everywhere like locusts.
Best and only thing you can do now is bring on the next generation of surrogate AI companion sex robots. If you don't, hypergamy will cause exponential spikes in the incel population, and there will be pock-marked middle-aged gamers who know how to code everywhere like locusts.
- Alexis Jacobi
- Posts: 9244
- Joined: Tue Oct 26, 2021 3:00 am
Re: God and morality
Wise words wisely spoken …
Re: God and morality
The force is the philosophy of 'always more'.Unless my data is all wrong, the social crisis that has erupted in Europe and America has a direct root in the issue that families are not producing children. It then becomes necessary to encourage mass immigration so there will be enough of a labor pool to keep things running. The real core is therefore in the destruction of the family. What force is it — in essential terms — that acts so destructively against the family?
That means ...
The economy has to keep growing 2-3% GDP every year.
On a personal level, people have to have more objects, more experiences.
So ...
The population has to grow in order to do the grunt work.
Why don't people just have more children instead of taking in immigrants?
Children are expensive and raising children is boring. Children reduce the opportunity to get more objects and to have exciting experiences.
Enter technology ... It has made it possible to control reproduction. It has also made it possible to produce a lot more objects and higher quality objects. It had also made travel much easier and faster so that exciting experiences are more accessible.
Enter social programs ... In the past it was necessary to have children as a form of insurance for old age. The children would take care of elderly parents. The elderly were dependent on their children. That need has been greatly reduced by government programs, pension plans, government medical insurance.
Enter equality ... Women have the opportunity to earn money in the workplace. They are not dependent on a husband providing for them.
How does it destroy family? By reducing the desire and need for children. By reducing the mutual dependence of the family members.
How to 'restore' the family?
Re: God and morality
Indeed.By these misdeeds of the ruiners of the family leading to the confusion of the Varnas, the eternal laws of caste and the eternal traditions of the family are destroyed.
The "eternal" systems which kept everyone in their place. The rich stay rich, the poor stay poor, the enslaved stay enslaved. All accept the arrangement.
That is a solution to the breakup of family and a restoration of family.
- Alexis Jacobi
- Posts: 9244
- Joined: Tue Oct 26, 2021 3:00 am
Re: God and morality
One of IC’s objections to the Gita is in it’s depiction of God as a giant “maw”. This view comes from the 11th chapter where Krishna reveals to Arjuna his Universal or Cosmic form, and Arjuna sees the Divine Being behind everything. Also including God in his (necessary) aspect as destroyer. The idea of Christianity is that man’s error (literally) turned the world from a divine place to the painful and difficult place it is. That’s the Fall: man fell and dragged creation down with him. It is man’s fault. What a burden to bear. And the Second Coming is the beginning of the process of literal restoration of the world, but a new Heaven and earth.Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Wed Nov 04, 2026 4:09 pm If you'd been paying any attention, you'd already know I not only read the Gita, but have it here. And no, "sacrifice" is not its central message, unless you mean sacrificing your enemies to the giant, slavering maw of "Fate."
The Gita has some very pretty and well-written passages -- unlike the Koran, which is uniformly ugly and clumsy -- but its message is still horrendous.
The Vedic cosmic picture is quite different. The following is Aurobindo’s comments on that segment where, in his vision, Arjuna sees the wonderful and the terrible side of what God creates (i.e. created worlds) and exclaims how strange and marvelous it all is:
This last cry of Arjuna indicates the double intention in the vision. This is the figure of the supreme and universal Being, this is he who forever creates, for Brahma the Creator is one of the Godheads seen in his body, he who keeps the world always in existence, for he is the guardian of the eternal laws, but who is always too destroying in order that he may new-create, who is Time, who is Death, who is Rudra the Dancer of the calm and awful dance, who is Kali with her garland of skulls trampling naked in battle and flecked with the blood of the slaughtered Titans, who is the cyclone and the fire and the earthquake and pain and famine and revolution and ruin and the swallowing ocean.
And it is this last aspect of him which he puts forward at the moment. It is an aspect from which the mind in men willingly turns away and ostrich-like hides its head so that perchance, not seeing, it may not be seen by the Terrible.
The weakness of the human heart wants only fair and comforting truths or in their absence pleasant fables; it will not have the truth in its entirety because there there is much that is not clear and pleasant and comfortable, but hard to understand and harder to bear.
To put away the responsibility for all that seems to us evil or terrible on the shoulders of a semi-omnipotent Devil, or to put it aside as part of Nature, making an unbridgeable opposition between world-nature and God-Nature, as if Nature were independent of God, or to throw the responsibility on man and his sins, as if he had a preponderant voice in the making of this world or could create anything against the will of God, are clumsily comfortable devices in which the religious thought of India has never taken refuge.
We have to look courageously in the face of the reality and see that it is God and none else who has made this world in his being and that so he has made it. The torment of the couch of pain and evil on which we are racked is his touch as much as happiness and sweetness and pleasure. The discords of the worlds are God's discords and it is only by accepting and proceeding through them that we can arrive at the greater concords of his supreme harmony, the summits and thrilled vastnesses of his transcendent and his cosmic Ananda.
The problem raised by the Gita and the solution it gives demand this character of the vision of the World-Spirit. Why should it be thus that the All-Spirit manifests himself in Nature? What is the significance of this creating and devouring flame that is mortal existence, this world-wide struggle, these constant disastrous revolutions, this labour and anguish and travail and perishing of creatures? Arjuna here puts the ancient question and breathes the eternal prayer.
- Immanuel Can
- Posts: 30600
- Joined: Wed Sep 25, 2013 4:42 pm
Re: God and morality
Yes. And?Alexis Jacobi wrote: ↑Mon Nov 16, 2026 6:29 pm One of IC’s objections to the Gita is in it’s depiction of God as a giant “maw”. This view comes from the 11th chapter where Krishna reveals to Arjuna his Universal or Cosmic form, and Arjuna sees the Divine Being behind everything. Also including God in his (necessary) aspect as destroyer.
It's not because it's not what I want "the god" to be. It's because it's a distorted and demented view of what God IS. Just like you wouldn't like me telling lies about somebody you loved, I find it distasteful when people lie about God. It makes people relate to God in wrong and deluded ways...and that's about as nasty a thing as one can do to them, and toward God.
Seems reasonable.
- Alexis Jacobi
- Posts: 9244
- Joined: Tue Oct 26, 2021 3:00 am
Re: God and morality
My first comment is: I do not think you are aware, nor do you choose to be aware, of the degree to which the Vedantic view concords in relevant ways with Christian ideas about “God’s nature”. So this leads you inevitably, inexorably, to the mistaken idea that the God of the Oriental conception (take as an example Aurobindo’s synthesis) is contradictable by whatever notion of Yahweh or Jesus that you have.Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Mon Nov 16, 2026 7:10 pm Yes. And?
It's not because it's not what I want "the god" to be. It's because it's a distorted and demented view of what God IS. Just like you wouldn't like me telling lies about somebody you loved, I find it distasteful when people lie about God. It makes people relate to God in wrong and deluded ways...and that's about as nasty a thing as one can do to them, and toward God.
Seems reasonable.
Your mistakes are not innocent however. And this has always been, and will likely always be, the core reason why I reject your religious narrowness.
Now, the other side of this — my rejection of your religious and dogmatic stance — is that it is possible to say exactly the same thing that you say about your own narrow attitude and prejudice: that you are lying. You said “I find it distasteful when people lie about God”. But I do not perceive that Aurobindo is lying when he relates his spiritual experience. Your implication is that he “lies” and lying is a malicious deed.
This merits a “chef’s kiss” (thinking of Big Mike!) for its prejudice and (I think) its ignorance.It makes people relate to God in wrong and deluded ways...and that's about as nasty a thing as one can do to them, and toward God.
However, I am not interested in changing your view. I have been unofficially studying Christianity and Catholicism in a long process of better understanding the Occident (and my own roots). The “debate” about these issues is non-useful, I am only interested in the conclusions I can put to use.