Page 83 of 94
Re: God and morality
Posted: Sun Nov 15, 2026 2:08 pm
by Alexis Jacobi
Stop your sniffling.
I would much rather that you respond by sticking to the ideas that are really the most important (the title of the thread being God and Morality), rather than diverting things into over-sensitive reaction.
Re: God and morality
Posted: Sun Nov 15, 2026 2:19 pm
by phyllo
Stop insulting people. (You routinely insult people. I'm just the latest target. )
Do that for a while and maybe there can be a discussion of ideas.
Re: God and morality
Posted: Sun Nov 15, 2026 2:31 pm
by Alexis Jacobi
God and Morality
Try this out: In popular culture you have heard people exclaiming Christ Is King. What does this
really mean?
Tenth Chapter of the Gita, third verse:
यो मामजमनादिं च वेत्ति लोकमहेश्वरम् ।
असम्मूढः स मर्त्येषु सर्वपापैः प्रमुच्यते ॥३॥
yo mām ajam anādiṁ ca vetti loka-maheśvaram
asammūḍhaḥ sa martyeṣu sarva-pāpaiḥ pramucyate
Translation
He who knows Me as unborn, without beginning, the great Lord of the worlds — he, undeluded among mortals, is freed from all sins.
Aurobindo’s commentary:
The Supreme who becomes all creation, yet infinitely transcends it, is not a will-less cause aloof from his creation. He is the mighty lord of the worlds and peoples, and governs all not only from within but from above, from his supreme transcendence. This is the theistic seeing of the universe.
All the perplexity of man's mind and action, àll the stumbling, insecurity and affliction of his mind can be traced back to the groping and bewildered cognition and volition natural tó his sense-obscured mortal mind in the body, sammoha. But when he sees the divine Origin of all things, when he looks steadily from the cosmic appearance to its transcendent Reality and back from that Reality to the appearance, he is then delivered from this bewilderment of the mind, will, heart and senses.
Assigning to everything its supernal and real and not any longer only its present and apparent value, he finds the hidden links and connections; he consciously directs all life and acts to their high and true object and governs them by the light and power which comes to him from the Godhead within him. Thus he escapes from the wrong cognition, the wrong mental and volitional reaction, the wrong sensational reception and impulse which here originate sin and error and suffering.
______________
Alexis Jacobi wrote: ↑Sun Nov 15, 2026 2:32 pm
phyllo wrote: ↑Sun Nov 15, 2026 2:19 pm
Do that for a while and maybe there can be a discussion of ideas.
You never “discuss ideas”.
Re: God and morality
Posted: Sun Nov 15, 2026 3:02 pm
by Alexis Jacobi
Sammohaḥ
Delusion. Confusion. The mind losing its light.
This is the essence of “the issue” as I see it. Because we have fallen away from
the possibility of understanding the underlying, guiding, undergirding metaphysical principles, we are stuck in a mental and spiritual zone that is delusion and confusion.
The attempt — I do not deny it or minimize it — in the culture revolves around rediscovery and rededication to serving Higher Principles. The impetus is noticed everywhere. Frankly, everyone is dealing in an ultimate sense with this question: On what ground, what grounding, is the genuine and trustworthy base for life to be found?
Re: God and morality
Posted: Sun Nov 15, 2026 3:06 pm
by Alexis Jacobi
[I’ve just increased my 1/2 hour rate to $250.00]
Re: God and morality
Posted: Sun Nov 15, 2026 3:19 pm
by MikeNovack
Alexis Jacobi wrote: ↑Sun Nov 15, 2026 1:48 pm
You (we) have to make the connection between the strengthening of the female-driven mood of offense and over-sensitivity that has given rise to “Woke” culture, and the weakening of analytical and intellectual fortitude. To the degree that men are influenced by and act like women is the degree that they neglect their responsibilities.
Except -- this "female driven mood of offense and over-sensitivity" and "weakening of analytical and intellectual fortitude", "men act like women" is purely cultural. And cultures change.
I'm sure you know your classics, Alexis. Take the culture described in the
Iliad (The Anger of Achilles). Isn't by the standards of our culture, emotional over-reaction to being slighted, Achilles is acting "womanly". Of course, that is a culture very remote in place and time. Take our own, 200 years ago. You would certainly consider say Hamilton or Galois "analytical". Yet both died in duels (Hamilton might have fancied his chances but Galois knew he was in effect committing suicide).
It is one thing to decry "cultural change". Another to act that cultural change shouldn't happen or is necessarily bad.
Re: God and morality
Posted: Sun Nov 15, 2026 3:22 pm
by Alexis Jacobi
Novak wrote:For example, the Bible is often described as a metanarrative
IC wrote:That would be incorrect. The Bible isn't even entirely narrative, for that matter. It contains didactic stuff, poetry, history, theology, prophecy, and other genres. But within it, a metanarrative that brackets all that exists: the poetry, the prophecy, the laws, etc. all coalesce around a particular grand "story" or metanarrative, that sweeps all the way from the origins of life to the end of chronological history, and directs the whole toward a teleological plan. So it's not that the Bible IS a meta-narrative, but it certainly presents and advocates one.
Fundamentally, this really is
The Question. And we struggle with it, and also against it, for various reasons. Either we succeed (if that is the right word) in defining what is, or what should be, at the base of the Meta-narrative, or we more or less abandon the field partially or entirely. On this forum — this is my impression — we witness the effusions of men who are in the latter category. All speech then becomes ironic and idiotic (Promethean) or intensely conflictuous and poisonous (Flash). But there is no concerted effort toward anything remotely resembling a higher ideal. It is all (basically) wallowing in a mire of Sammohaḥ.
Re: God and morality
Posted: Sun Nov 15, 2026 3:32 pm
by phyllo
MikeNovack wrote: ↑Sun Nov 15, 2026 3:19 pm
Alexis Jacobi wrote: ↑Sun Nov 15, 2026 1:48 pm
You (we) have to make the connection between the strengthening of the female-driven mood of offense and over-sensitivity that has given rise to “Woke” culture, and the weakening of analytical and intellectual fortitude. To the degree that men are influenced by and act like women is the degree that they neglect their responsibilities.
Except -- this "female driven mood of offense and over-sensitivity" and "weakening of analytical and intellectual fortitude", "men act like women" is purely cultural. And cultures change.
I'm sure you know your classics, Alexis. Take the culture described in the
Iliad (The Anger of Achilles). Isn't by the standards of our culture, emotional over-reaction to being slighted, Achilles is acting "womanly". Of course, that is a culture very remote in place and time. Take our own, 200 years ago. You would certainly consider say Hamilton or Galois "analytical". Yet both died in duels (Hamilton might have fancied his chances but Galois knew he was in effect committing suicide).
It is one thing to decry "cultural change". Another to act that cultural change shouldn't happen or is necessarily bad.
That was AJ saying that I am weak and womanly. It's not a comment on current culture, or an examination or exploration.
If you look around, it's not hard to find manly men being over-sensitive and easily taking offense.
And not taking responsibility ... we see volumes of that.

Re: God and morality
Posted: Sun Nov 15, 2026 3:48 pm
by Alexis Jacobi
phyllo wrote: ↑Sun Nov 15, 2026 3:32 pm
That was AJ saying that I am weak and womanly. It's not a comment on current culture, or an examination or exploration.
All ad hominem has to be directed to the self and then proceed adjacently. It is more useful to say our culture has become weak and womanly and we (as men) have relinquished responsibility. So, the real question (there are many) is What does it mean to reclaim responsibility? And from that a hundred different sub-questions arise.
Cease to react personally. Try to see a larger picture.
Re: God and morality
Posted: Sun Nov 15, 2026 3:50 pm
by phyllo
"We" is an abdication of personal responsibility.
Re: God and morality
Posted: Sun Nov 15, 2026 5:42 pm
by Alexis Jacobi
phyllo wrote: ↑Sun Nov 15, 2026 3:50 pm
"We" is an abdication of personal responsibility.
AJ wrote:Phyllo is quite simply digging down into a resistance posture, and very little more. I criticize his superficiality.
Getting any clearer?
Re: God and morality
Posted: Sun Nov 15, 2026 8:04 pm
by seeds
Alexis Jacobi wrote: ↑Sun Nov 15, 2026 3:22 pm
Either we succeed (if that is the right word) in defining what is, or what should be, at the base of the Meta-narrative, or we more or less abandon the field partially or entirely. On this forum — this is my impression — we witness the effusions of men who are in the latter category. All speech then becomes ironic and idiotic (Promethean) or intensely conflictuous and poisonous (Flash). But there is no concerted effort toward anything remotely resembling a higher ideal. It is all (basically) wallowing in a mire of Sammohaḥ.
Of course there is no...
..."concerted effort toward anything remotely resembling a higher ideal"...
...Why?
Because how can there be a "concerted effort" in the seeking of a "higher ideal" for humanity if everyone (especially you) has their own particular notion (or definition) of what a "higher ideal" for humanity might entail?
Anyway, just for the sake of clarification, how about you tell us what it is that you personally feel would be the absolute best and most beneficial "higher ideal" for us wallowers in the mire of Sammohaḥ to focus on?
_______
Re: God and morality
Posted: Sun Nov 15, 2026 8:24 pm
by promethean75
I hate wallowers in the mire of Sammohaḥ, seeds. When will they realize the full cosmic quantum infinite higher plane of creative quantum spirit self?
Re: God and morality
Posted: Sun Nov 15, 2026 10:48 pm
by Alexis Jacobi
seeds wrote: ↑Sun Nov 15, 2026 8:04 pm
…
Ptomethean nailed it.
Re: God and morality
Posted: Sun Nov 15, 2026 10:51 pm
by Alexis Jacobi
Anyway, just for the sake of clarification, how about you tell us what it is that you personally feel would be the absolute best and most beneficial "higher ideal" for us wallowers in the mire of Sammohaḥ to focus on?
How can you expect me or anyone to answer such a question!?! Everyone has their own private definition. Such basic stuff, Seeds!