Page 80 of 94
Re: God and morality
Posted: Thu Nov 12, 2026 8:36 pm
by seeds
Alexis Jacobi wrote: ↑Thu Nov 12, 2026 2:43 pm
If the question is Why is it that we seem to exist in our world but without real, operative knowledge about Reality as a manifestation of the Divine, Aurobindo in his commentary on the Gita discusses “bewilderment”:
This bewilderment is a befooling of the soul in Nature by the deceptive ego. The evil-doer cannot attain to the Supreme, because he is for ever trying to satisfy the idol ego on the lowest scale of human nature; his real God is this ego.
His mind and will, hurried away in the activities of the Maya of the three Gunas [turbulent forces in the material realm], are not instruments of the spirit, but willing slaves or self-deceived tools of his desires. The Gita has laid it down from the beginning that the very first precondition of the divine birth, the higher existence, is the slaying of rajasic desire [intense material desire] and its children, and that means the exclusion of sin.
Sin is the working of the lower nature for the crude satisfaction of its own ignorance, dull or violent rajasic [striving] and tamasic [dulling] propensities in revolt against any high self-control and self-mastery of the nature by the spirit. And in order to get rid of this crude compulsion of the being by the lower Prakriti in its inferior modes we must have recourse to the highest mode of that Prakriti, the Sattwic [balance, peace, clear understanding], which is seeking always for a harmonious light of knowledge and for a right rule of action.
The Purusha, the soul within us which assents in Nature to the varying impulse of the gunas [material modes], has to give its sanction to that sattwic impulse and that sattwic will and temperament in our being which seeks after such a rule. The sattwic will in our nature has to govern us and not the rajasic and tamasic will. This is the meaning of all high reason in action as of all true ethical culture; it is the law of Nature in us striving to evolve from her lower and disorderly to her higher and orderly action, to act not in passion and ignorance with the result of grief and unquiet, but in knowledge and enlightened will with the result of inner happiness, poise and peace.
We cannot get beyond the three gunas [we are stuck in Nature], if we do not first develop within ourselves the rule of the highest guna, sattwa. Man, therefore, has first of all to become ethical, sukriti, and then to rise to heights beyond any mere ethical rule of living, to the light, largeness and power of the spiritual nature, where he gets beyond the grasp of the dualities and its delusion, dwandwa-moha.
There he no longer seeks his personal good or pleasure or shuns his personal suffering or pain, for by these things he is no longer affected, nor says any longer, "I am virtuous,” “I am sinful,” but acts in his own high spiritual nature by the will of the Divine for the universal good. We have already seen that for this end self-knowledge, equality, impersonality are the first necessities, and that that is the way of reconciliation between knowledge and works, between spirituality and activity in the world, between the ever immobile quietism of the timeless Self and the eternal play of the pragmatic energy of Nature. But the Gita now lays down another and greater necessity for the Karmayogin who has unified his Yoga of works with the Yoga of knowledge. Not knowledge and works alone are demanded of him now, but Bhakti [devotion, willingness to serve] also, devotion to the Divine, love and adoration and the soul’s desire of the Highest.
Thank you Sri Jacobinanda for providing us with that quote from Sri Aurobindo.
It's good to know that you weren't insulted or felt any shame (or self-awareness) at my pointing out the hypocrisy of you complaining about my posts being too long.
Anyway, I always find it amusing...
(make that presumptuous and annoying)
...that the promoters of Hinduism seem to assume that if they include the corresponding Sanskrit words in their apologetics, words such as the following taken from the Aurobindo quote,...
"Gunas” “Gita” “rajasic” “tamasic” “Prakriti” “Sattwic” “Purusha” “sattwa” “sukriti” “dwandwa-moha” “Karmayogin”, and “Bhakti"
...then the “Truth” of Hinduism will be obvious to their English speaking audiences.
I know that when I read Hindu apologetics, I always think to myself...
...ah, so when you speak of, say, “...balance, peace, clear understanding...,” what you really mean is “sattwic.” Or when you speak of “striving,” you mean “rajasic,” and “dulling” means “tamasic,” and, of course, when you speak of “material modes” you mean “gunas”...
...got it.
Because the words are exotic (maybe even mystical) sounding to English speakers, they therefore imply truths about reality that only the ancients understood.
And now you can too,...
...all you have to do is strip down to your underdrawers - assume the lotus position - shun modernity, and then hope that other humans will bring you food while you meditate on how to escape from this incarnating/excarnating trap that, for some mysterious reason, your soul has somehow gotten drawn into.
Sri Jacobinanda wrote:
Our souls are eternal. We circle in and out of incarnation many many times.
Granted, I have not read every jot and tittle of Hinduism, so I may have missed it. In which case, if you are going to make such a claim, then would you please be so kind as to tell us,...
- 1. How (and when) an individual soul is first awakened into existence?
2. What does a soul do (or experience) in-between incarnations?
3. Other than an eternity of "navel-gazing" implied in the concept of Nirvana, what possible (non-boring / useful) purpose would a soul have living trillions of years into the future once it finally achieves “moksha”?
_______
Re: God and morality
Posted: Thu Nov 12, 2026 8:53 pm
by Alexis Jacobi
seeds wrote: ↑Thu Nov 12, 2026 8:36 pm
...
There was a
LOT of normality in that post, Seeds, but also a lot of your typical sod. I read it and I have no idea what the hell you are asking that has any relevance.
The book deals in Sanskrit terms because --
wait for it! -- the
Bhagavad Gita is written in Sanskrit!
To understand it you have to grasp some of the vocabulary. And since he is commenting on specific slokas in which specific terms were used, in his commentary he refers to the terms or phrases. Not too much different when one reads some erudite person commenting on Greek, Hebrew or Latin texts.
Your questions, even for you, are surprisingly non-intelligent. How could I possibly hold them against you?
Re: God and morality
Posted: Thu Nov 12, 2026 9:26 pm
by phyllo
My recent posts relied heavily on a peculiar living example from an interesting woman’s real life. It seems to me it is right up the alley of the present thread, but moreover our cultural and social situation.
You realize that one account of one person's experience does not count as argument or evidence, right?
Re: God and morality
Posted: Thu Nov 12, 2026 9:30 pm
by seeds
Alexis Jacobi wrote: ↑Thu Nov 12, 2026 8:53 pm
Your questions, even for you, are surprisingly non-intelligent.
You made the following, unequivocal (seemingly authoritative) claim...
Our souls are eternal. We circle in and out of incarnation many many times.
How in the world can perfectly logical questions that seek clarification of such a cocksure claim be "non-intelligent"?
Instead of your feeble attempt at trying to insult me, why don't you answer the questions?
Here they are again...
Please be so kind as to tell us,...- 1. How (and when) an individual soul is first awakened into existence?
2. What does a soul do (or experience) in-between incarnations?
3. Other than an eternity of "navel-gazing" implied in the concept of Nirvana, what possible (non-boring / useful) purpose would a soul have living trillions of years into the future once it finally achieves “moksha”?
_______
Re: God and morality
Posted: Thu Nov 12, 2026 10:34 pm
by MikeNovack
seeds wrote: ↑Thu Nov 12, 2026 8:36 pm
2. What does a soul do (or experience) in-between incarnations?
For this one you want not Hinduism (which as far as I know does not tackle the subject) but Tibetan Buddhism. Read the
Bardo Thodol if you want to know (what they think)
Re: God and morality
Posted: Thu Nov 12, 2026 10:51 pm
by phyllo
How do people know what the soul does between incarnations?
How do people know what happens in an afterlife?
Some have claimed to have been there and done that, but ...
Re: God and morality
Posted: Thu Nov 12, 2026 11:52 pm
by Alexis Jacobi
phyllo wrote: ↑Thu Nov 12, 2026 9:26 pm
My recent posts relied heavily on a peculiar living example from an interesting woman’s real life. It seems to me it is right up the alley of the present thread, but moreover our cultural and social situation.
You realize that one account of one person's experience does not count as argument or evidence, right?
Oh but it does
count, and in fact it is
paradigmatic, that being why I submitted it. But of course, one person’s “near death experience” proves nothing. At least not to a second or third person. What counted is what happened to her. For the “proofs” of the existence of Divinity are always stories told by persons.
Re: God and morality
Posted: Fri Nov 13, 2026 12:26 am
by Alexis Jacobi
seeds wrote: ↑Thu Nov 12, 2026 9:30 pm…
Not interested in the interrogative mode. It’s classic but boring. Tell me your thoughts about the question.
Re: God and morality
Posted: Fri Nov 13, 2026 1:17 pm
by Alexis Jacobi
I must reiterate: The modern position as it pertains to metaphysics is a determined and established outlook which is found abundantly in most who comment against the realness of metaphysics. I do not ‘blame’ anyone for seeing perceiving thinking and expressing what they believe to be true, nor of opposing religious constructs in their negative manifestation: huge, imagined and embellished pictures which, like the images projected on the wall of Plato’s Cave, capture people’s attention and are conceived of as being “real”.
Since I am presently working my way through Aurobindo’s commentary on the Bhagavad Gita, I perceive a man who is working in the realm of synthesis between one system of organizing the understanding and perception of “Reality” — the ancient Indian one — and the modern one which in Aurobindo’s case is philosophical in an Occidental sense and reliant on lengthy and dense explanations and commentary.
What is the value of exploring and exposing oneself to such a metaphysical inquiry? In my view: For the insight it provides to understand a) our own metaphysical origins and Occidental Europe’s long relationship with metaphysics (we constructed ourselves through this) and b) the collapse of having and ‘believing in’ realness of that, which necessarily undermines the possibility of believing in this thing, this word-concept, this sēmeîon (σημεῖον) = sign, mark, token) that we use here constantly: God.
That word itself is completely distracting and sets up immediate opposition. And I do not think I blame anyone for standing in opposition.
Re: God and morality
Posted: Fri Nov 13, 2026 1:27 pm
by phyllo
Alexis Jacobi wrote: ↑Thu Nov 12, 2026 11:52 pm
phyllo wrote: ↑Thu Nov 12, 2026 9:26 pm
My recent posts relied heavily on a peculiar living example from an interesting woman’s real life. It seems to me it is right up the alley of the present thread, but moreover our cultural and social situation.
You realize that one account of one person's experience does not count as argument or evidence, right?
Oh but it does
count, and in fact it is
paradigmatic, that being why I submitted it. But of course, one person’s “near death experience” proves nothing. At least not to a second or third person. What counted is what happened to her. For the “proofs” of the existence of Divinity are always stories told by persons.
I might watch that video after all. She (Betty Guadagno
www.buddhabetty.com) makes some interesting and curious statements.
She can charge $175 for 30 minutes of 'coaching'. A six month course is $6500. Not too shabby.
God doesn't just bring peace, He brings cash.
Rags to riches in America.
Re: God and morality
Posted: Fri Nov 13, 2026 1:43 pm
by Alexis Jacobi
I think my primary observation and conclusion is the following and rather simple one: If and when man’s relationship to metaphysical principles, which does connote Divinity and Originating Intelligence, is disrupted, damaged and destroyed, the result is multivalent but decidedly negative. Why? Because it is by way of the recognition of Metaphysical Realness that man conceives of obligation to serve it.
[Middle English obligen, from Old French obligier, from Latin obligāre : ob-, to; see ob- + ligāre, to bind; see leig- in Indo-European roots.]
The notion of authority and command extend from being bound. Thus the question about God and Morality is still very much at the center. My view is that until one clears the table of the unnecessary accumulation of junk-concepts about “God” and also perhaps of social conventions about ethics, that there will be no means to restructure a relationship to metaphysics but also, allow me to say, to the soul’s obligation.
This is the reason I submitted the case of a woman who, obviously to all of us, and by her own recounting, had gone to the very bottom of human destructiveness. And what was, and what is, that? The nexus of addiction. But what stands behind that? She was an addict, a manipulator, a thief, a pimp, a prostitute, and worst of all she actively and consciously sought to trap other (women) into addiction so that she could profit from their bondage. In this smorgasbord of “defects” there seem to be contained the essence of the human problem of sin and evilness. I hesitate to use that word “sin” because of its connotations. But there has to be some designating term that dovetails with “morality”.
Re: God and morality
Posted: Fri Nov 13, 2026 1:55 pm
by Alexis Jacobi
phyllo wrote: ↑Fri Nov 13, 2026 1:27 pm
I might watch that video after all. She (Betty Guadagno
www.buddhabetty.com) makes some interesting and curious statements.
It is part of your nature, Phyllo, to seek out a negative angle as part of what seems to amount to a larger effort to undermine or devalue the notion of relationship to that which we refer to when employing the word “God”.
I cannot blame you for one aspect of your cynicism — suspicion about how people earn money in the “recovery industry” — but that issue is not the reason I brought her up.
Re: God and morality
Posted: Fri Nov 13, 2026 2:08 pm
by phyllo
Alexis Jacobi wrote: ↑Fri Nov 13, 2026 1:55 pm
phyllo wrote: ↑Fri Nov 13, 2026 1:27 pm
I might watch that video after all. She (Betty Guadagno
www.buddhabetty.com) makes some interesting and curious statements.
It is part of your nature, Phyllo, to seek out a negative angle as part of what seems to amount to a larger effort to undermine or devalue the notion of relationship to that which we refer to when employing the word “God”.
I cannot blame you for one aspect of your cynicism — suspicion about how people earn money in the “recovery industry” — but that issue is not the reason I brought her up.
I thing that is interesting is that her experience is a mashup of God, Jesus, kundalini, matrix, 5D, etc. A lot trendy stuff. One would think it would be contradictory in a metaphysical sense but not in a marketing sense.
Re: God and morality
Posted: Fri Nov 13, 2026 2:21 pm
by Alexis Jacobi
phyllo wrote: ↑Fri Nov 13, 2026 2:08 pm
[The] thing that is interesting is that her experience is a mashup of God, Jesus, kundalini, matrix, 5D, etc. A lot [of] trendy stuff. One would think it would be contradictory in a metaphysical sense but not in a marketing sense.
In fact the modern person, and the modern “subjective hookup” to any view of reality, is by way of “mashups”.
Re: God and morality
Posted: Fri Nov 13, 2026 2:57 pm
by phyllo
So she's modern.
Got it.