Page 78 of 94

Re: God and morality

Posted: Wed Nov 11, 2026 11:07 pm
by Alexis Jacobi
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Wed Nov 11, 2026 11:02 pm "One can choose," is not the way it's expressed in Scripture.
Yeah well, one does choose. But Grace is completely real. And I refuse to debate these issues with you.

Re: God and morality

Posted: Wed Nov 11, 2026 11:10 pm
by promethean75
I have an aside question for you twos. Can either of you choose not to believe what you do about the subject of argument here?

Re: God and morality

Posted: Wed Nov 11, 2026 11:14 pm
by Immanuel Can
Alexis Jacobi wrote: ↑Wed Nov 11, 2026 11:07 pm
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Wed Nov 11, 2026 11:02 pm "One can choose," is not the way it's expressed in Scripture.
Yeah well, one does choose.
One can choose to be evil, of course. But one cannot choose to free oneself from one's fallenness, and previous evils, and ongoing inclination to evil. That's what salvation is all about. And that's what "grace" actually means -- God's free gift of forgiveness, healing and help.

Re: God and morality

Posted: Wed Nov 11, 2026 11:15 pm
by Alexis Jacobi
promethean75 wrote: ↑Wed Nov 11, 2026 11:10 pm I have an aside question for you twos. Can either of you choose not to believe what you do about the subject of argument here?
Wait, which twos, bro?

If you mean IC and myself, I think you must distinguish between our respective positions. However, I do share numerous points of agreement with his structured ultra-rigid views.

But what really are you aksing? If I could turn against what “life” has presented and taught me? Deny it? Try to undermine it?

Re: God and morality

Posted: Wed Nov 11, 2026 11:16 pm
by Immanuel Can
promethean75 wrote: ↑Wed Nov 11, 2026 11:10 pm I have an aside question for you twos. Can either of you choose not to believe what you do about the subject of argument here?
You mean, "just choose" to believe something? For no reason? With no evidence or argument?

I would say that nobody can really do that. The closest you can come to it is double-mindedness, where one part of you believes something, and the other knows you really don't. People can do that much, come that close to it. I don't recommend it.

Re: God and morality

Posted: Wed Nov 11, 2026 11:21 pm
by Alexis Jacobi
promethean75 wrote: ↑Wed Nov 11, 2026 11:10 pm …about the subject of argument here?
How would you describe (in philosophical Ebonics if it please thee) what is being “argued”?

Re: God and morality

Posted: Thu Nov 12, 2026 12:54 pm
by phyllo
phyllo wrote: ↑
The first test you encounter is showing that God or god or gods exist.
You have not been paying attention to years of discussions here: there is absolutely no way to “prove” such a thing in the sense that you mean. Therefore if one is, say, interested in the question a completely different methodology will be needed. So, in your case, you are back to square one.
I didn't write "prove", I wrote "show".

You're trying to suggest that I'm asking for something impossible and unreasonable. When in fact, all I'm asking is for you to show that it's reasonable to think gods exist.

After that, comes the step of showing that your description of the god(s) is reasonably correct.

But you skip those steps and jump into a metaphysics with gods. You probably find that more interesting than the prep work.

It's like painting which is 90% preparation and 10% painting. People often skip most of the preparation work and just put paint on the wall.

Re: God and morality

Posted: Thu Nov 12, 2026 1:41 pm
by Alexis Jacobi
Phyllo wrote:You're trying to suggest that I'm asking for something impossible and unreasonable. When in fact, all I'm asking is for you to show that it's reasonable to think gods exist.
I do not think it ‘reasonable’ to believe and to understand that the created world is, at the back of it, and in an inconceivable way, a creation of a divine power which cannot be named or reduced to a meaningless title such as “god” is. But again I refer to ‘the time we are in’ as a determining temporal modality. It is hardly necessary for a man to think deeply about metaphysical issues when 1) we live relatively healthy lives and 2) there are a nearly infinite array of things that draw and occupy our attention.

You have to hold in your mind that the conversation I attempt here is in numerous senses directly opposed to the “preaching efforts” of Immanuel Can. This is my wee rehearsal of opposition but also of explanation. See, the Evangelical Christian picture is, when examined in a certain light, kind of evil and dark. At the bottom of Christian preaching is a formidable and terrible curse: Refuse to accept “the gift” and I (the Godhead of Mercy) will torture you endlessly and with terrifying savagery and sadism. Naturally, this false assertion, this Curse, produces opposition. It is all bound up in terrible apologetics.

What I am actually attempting to “do” is to propose that traditional Christianity has to be “seen through” and that the way to do this in by working with metaphysical principles, explanations and descriptions that a) define what is elevated and even supernal in the Christian Vision, yet b) correct and explain its horrifying, misleading and misguiding errors. So as it happens because I defend metaphysics I am associated (in rather dull minds — sorry Promethean) with Ic’s long-standing shtick. But this is not so.

It is not unreasonable to veer away from the various Christian forms of religious view and practice and, if these are one’s sole source of knowledge, to see the whole charade as a manipulative, conniving, low-level, even brutish attempt to ‘capture’ people and in a sense to blind them.

What I just did (you have not acknowledged it) was to present a case of one woman’s process of self-realization that involved healing. I suggest her story, her experience, is infused from top to bottom with “meaning and value” that transcends dogmatism. Her Story gets right to the heart of it. So the question I ask is: What do you think stands behind the intelligence that guided her? (It is quite likely you did not bother to listen to her story but I proceed as if you did). Did “God” appear out of some golden palace and shake his fist at her? No. Very very different was her experience. And it was mediated or facilitated by those who could be said to serve “higher purposes” and yet “God”, whatever this is taken to be, is not precisely present. So, what is present? Directives. Intelligence. Processes of growth. Realization. Revelation. But all directed not away from our incarnated life, but toward the fulfillment of those purposes.

Re: God and morality

Posted: Thu Nov 12, 2026 1:55 pm
by Alexis Jacobi
I am not really asking anything of you or anyone. I have said a dozen times I am strictly out for myself. If I leave here and cone back in a decade ‘you’ will likely all be here. Bickering, bitching, complaining and among the really benighted defending a “philosophy” that is mental and spiritual death (if I am to be honest).

I reveal then my basic assertion: By eliminating metaphysics, by perverting the principles of ‘meaning & value’ present in a religious modality, by destructive egocentric apologetics, the actual field to which these things pertain, is obscured. The Christian religious picture collapsed under its own weight. And I suggest (sorry Old Bean) that IC’s branch is rotting at the trunk. And the upshot? That the real issues at stake, which is to say our conscious lives within the realm of life on Earth, requires a process of clarification, and stripping away of dogmatism.

Re: God and morality

Posted: Thu Nov 12, 2026 2:05 pm
by Alexis Jacobi
Phyllo wrote:After that, comes the step of showing that your description of the god(s) is reasonably correct.

But you skip those steps and jump into a metaphysics with gods. You probably find that more interesting than the prep work.
To speak of God and “gods” is diversionary. There is more to be gained by way of the proposition and the realization that we are when the “plane of existence” (the Earth, this Loka) is understood in a certain way, that it is (that we are) obviously and undeniably ruled by an Intelligence that has, so to speak, set everything up. You and I and all the rest find ourselves here. And our entire experience is determined by ‘the nature of the place’.

The steps that I assert should not be skipped are exactly those which refrain from idolizing abstractions (the word God is an abstraction) and instead focusing on what is real and evident. Life, consciousness, awareness infuse everything here.

Re: God and morality

Posted: Thu Nov 12, 2026 2:26 pm
by phyllo
I do not think it ‘reasonable’ to believe and to understand that the created world is, at the back of it, and in an inconceivable way, a creation of a divine power which cannot be named ir reduced to a meaningless title such as “god” is. Put again I refer to ‘the time we are in’ as a determining temporal modality. It is hardly necessary for a man to think deeply about metaphysical issues when 1) we live relatively healthy lives and 2) there are a nearly infinite array of things that draw and occupy our attention.
As soon as you say that it's not "reasonable to believe", then all reasoning about the subject goes out the window. All babble becomes valid.

You're not at the mall talking to Bob the accountant. One can expect more interest in metaphysical issues on a philosophy site. Although this place may be too casual with too few participants to offer much depth.
You have to hold in your mind that the conversation I attempt here is in numerous senses directly opposed to the “preaching efforts” of Immanuel Can. This is my wee rehearsal of opposition but also of explanation. See, the Evangelical Christian picture is, when examined in a certain light, kind of evil and dark. At the bottom of Christian preaching is a formidable and terrible curse: Refuse to accept “the gift” and I (the Godhead of Mercy) will torture you endlessly and with terrifying savagery and sadism. Naturally, this false assertion, this Curse, produces opposition. It is all bound up in terrible apologetics.

What I am actually attempting to “do” is to propose that traditional Christianity has to be “seen through” and that the way to do this in by working with metaphysical principles, explanations and descriptions that a) define what is elevated and even supernal in the Christian Vision, yet b) correct and explain its horrifying, misleading and misguiding errors. So as it happens because I defend metaphysics I am associated (in rather dull minds — sorry Promethean) with Ic’s long-standing shtick. But this is not so.
You're not going through the errors of Christianity and providing reasons for a 'correct' Christianity. Or at least I haven't seen you doing it.

The eternal punishment by God for those who do not obey God is an example as you state. But can you actually argue against it? On metaphysical principles?
What I just did (you have not acknowledged it) was to present a case of one woman’s process of self-realization that involved healing.
I didn't acknowledge it because I did not watch it.

I have watched many YouTube videos which were recommended on philosophy sites and a lot of them have been a complete waste of time.

Do I want to invest 42 minutes of my life in your video recommendation? No. Life is short, I need those minutes.

Re: God and morality

Posted: Thu Nov 12, 2026 2:30 pm
by phyllo
Alexis Jacobi wrote: ↑Thu Nov 12, 2026 2:05 pm
Phyllo wrote:After that, comes the step of showing that your description of the god(s) is reasonably correct.

But you skip those steps and jump into a metaphysics with gods. You probably find that more interesting than the prep work.
To speak of God and “gods” is diversionary. There is more to be gained by way of the proposition and the realization that we are when the “plane of existence” (the Earth, this Loka) is understood in a certain way, that it is (that we are) obviously and undeniably ruled by an Intelligence that has, so to speak, set everything up. You and I and all the rest find ourselves here. And our entire experience is determined by ‘the nature of the place’.

The steps that I assert should not be skipped are exactly those which refrain from idolizing abstractions (the word God is an abstraction) and instead focusing on what is real and evident. Life, consciousness, awareness infuse everything here.
Often you write as if you don't believe in God/gods.

It reminds me of the Christian churches that want to remove references to God from Christianity. Atheist Christianity. :lol:

Re: God and morality

Posted: Thu Nov 12, 2026 2:43 pm
by Alexis Jacobi
If the question is Why is it that we seem to exist in our world but without real, operative knowledge about Reality as a manifestation of the Divine, Aurobindo in his commentary on the Gita discusses “bewilderment”:
This bewilderment is a befooling of the soul in Nature by the deceptive ego. The evil-doer cannot attain to the Supreme, because he is for ever trying to satisfy the idol ego on the lowest scale of human nature; his real God is this ego.

His mind and will, hurried away in the activities of the Maya of the three Gunas [turbulent forces in the material realm], are not instruments of the spirit, but willing slaves or self-deceived tools of his desires. The Gita has laid it down from the beginning that the very first precondition of the divine birth, the higher existence, is the slaying of rajasic desire [intense material desire] and its children, and that means the exclusion of sin.

Sin is the working of the lower nature for the crude satisfaction of its own ignorance, dull or violent rajasic [striving] and tamasic [dulling] propensities in revolt against any high self-control and self-mastery of the nature by the spirit. And in order to get rid of this crude compulsion of the being by the lower Prakriti in its inferior modes we must have recourse to the highest mode of that Prakriti, the Sattwic [balance, peace, clear understanding], which is seeking always for a harmonious light of knowledge and for a right rule of action.

The Purusha, the soul within us which assents in Nature to the varying impulse of the gunas [material modes], has to give its sanction to that sattwic impulse and that sattwic will and temperament in our being which seeks after such a rule. The sattwic will in our nature has to govern us and not the rajasic and tamasic will. This is the meaning of all high reason in action as of all true ethical culture; it is the law of Nature in us striving to evolve from her lower and disorderly to her higher and orderly action, to act not in passion and ignorance with the result of grief and unquiet, but in knowledge and enlightened will with the result of inner happiness, poise and peace.

We cannot get beyond the three gunas [we are stuck in Nature], if we do not first develop within ourselves the rule of the highest guna, sattwa. Man, therefore, has first of all to become ethical, sukriti, and then to rise to heights beyond any mere ethical rule of living, to the light, largeness and power of the spiritual nature, where he gets beyond the grasp of the dualities and its delusion, dwandwa-moha.

There he no longer seeks his personal good or pleasure or shuns his personal suffering or pain, for by these things he is no longer affected, nor says any longer, "I am virtuous,” “I am sinful,” but acts in his own high spiritual nature by the will of the Divine for the universal good. We have already seen that for this end self-knowledge, equality, impersonality are the first necessities, and that that is the way of reconciliation between knowledge and works, between spirituality and activity in the world, between the ever immobile quietism of the timeless Self and the eternal play of the pragmatic energy of Nature. But the Gita now lays down another and greater necessity for the Karmayogin who has unified his Yoga of works with the Yoga of knowledge. Not knowledge and works alone are demanded of him now, but Bhakti [devotion, willingness to serve] also, devotion to the Divine, love and adoration and the soul’s desire of the Highest.

Re: God and morality

Posted: Thu Nov 12, 2026 2:45 pm
by Alexis Jacobi
phyllo wrote: ↑Thu Nov 12, 2026 2:30 pm Often you write as if you don't believe in God/gods.
I do not think that is quite right. The word “God” is used extremely vulgarly when really what is being referred to is something else.

Re: God and morality

Posted: Thu Nov 12, 2026 3:06 pm
by Alexis Jacobi
phyllo wrote: ↑Thu Nov 12, 2026 2:26 pm As soon as you say that it's not "reasonable to believe", then all reasoning about the subject goes out the window. All babble becomes valid.
Oh no, you constantly misunderstand. You, Phyllo, cannot believe, that is cannot understand, because you are obviously held in the sway of your presuppositions. These presuppositions are the modes in which we have been trained to think, perceive and see. And this “reasonableness”, though I assert it is defective, is our shared mode.

In this sense it is not reasonable, given these presuppositions, to start to see things in different ways.
You're not going through the errors of Christianity and providing reasons for a 'correct' Christianity. Or at least I haven't seen you doing it.
This conversation has been on-going for over a DECADE. And you really do not have any good reason to have paid attention. Of the many things you miss this is just one, bro. 😎
The eternal punishment by God for those who do not obey God is an example as you state. But can you actually argue against it? On metaphysical principles?
Our souls are eternal. We circle in and out of incarnation many many times. I can certainly suggest that the notion of eternal punishment is a product of a deranged human mind.
I didn't acknowledge it because I did not watch it.

I have watched many YouTube videos which were recommended on philosophy sites and a lot of them have been a complete waste of time.

Do I want to invest 42 minutes of my life in your video recommendation? No. Life is short, I need those minutes.
If life is so “short” you waste vast amounts of it here! My view is that if we take these conversations seriously, we will be doing lots of reading, study and meditation on the side.

Yes, I would prefer that you listen to her story as a context for what is being discussed. But obviously if you don’t want to, don’t.