Page 76 of 94

Re: God and morality

Posted: Wed Nov 11, 2026 4:23 pm
by phyllo
That's a society agreeing on what ought to be punished. They can leave God out of it entirely. God didn't say that what He wills. God is remarkably quiet.
Again, you simply put do not accept the core premise that God (metaphysical reality) exists. And “the silence of God” certainly appears real — to you.
Why would one accept the premise that God exists if one does not see evidence that God exists?

Let's try this ...

Let's assume that God exists.

How do we know what God's will is?

How do we know that all the religious texts describing God and the will of God, are not merely the fabrications of men and women? Do we have to assume that they are the true and correct descriptions of God and God's will?

Where do our assumptions and the acceptance of premises end?

Re: God and morality

Posted: Wed Nov 11, 2026 4:39 pm
by Alexis Jacobi
phyllo wrote: ↑Wed Nov 11, 2026 4:23 pm 1) Why would one accept the premise that God exists if one does not see evidence that God exists?

2) Let's assume that God exists.

3) How do we know what God's will is?
The answers I will attempt are these:

1) First, your position must be defined. It is subjective. It is modern, typical and rather common. Atheism of the day. And it is your subjective position. It would have to be analyzed as such. Then, answers would likely cone from people who have background in surmounting that potentially limited perspective. You would have to conditionally entertain the possibility that a) God does exist and b) that God might communicate to you. If you never modified your initial assertion, obviously nothing would change.

There is the “intuited approach”.

And there is the “studied approach” (reading literature that “explains God”).

2) Are you crazy?!? You think I’m going to just go along with that shit?!? No way José! I’m with Promethean, bro.

3) Typically, by internal, intuitive process. Also by “logical reasoning”.

Re: God and morality

Posted: Wed Nov 11, 2026 4:53 pm
by phyllo
1) Why would one accept the premise that God exists if one does not see evidence that God exists?
1) First, your position must be defined. It is subjective. It is modern, typical and rather common. Atheism of the day. And it is your subjective position.
Subjective???

The requirement for having objective evidence is subjective???

You don't know what the word "subjective" means.

There's nothing "modern" here. The question has been around since ancient times.
3) How do we know what God's will is?
3) Typically, by internal, intuitive process. Also by “logical reasoning”.
Okay, go ahead and show the "logical reasoning".

The "internal, intuitive process" sounds subjective and unverifiable so let's skip it for now.

Re: God and morality

Posted: Wed Nov 11, 2026 5:08 pm
by Alexis Jacobi
Yes, your position is subjective: it arises from your premises. If the premises were to change, it could follow that the subjective stance might change.

The “question” may have been around since ancient times, but our positions are supported by modern pre-suppositions.

Re: God and morality

Posted: Wed Nov 11, 2026 5:15 pm
by Alexis Jacobi
phyllo wrote: ↑Wed Nov 11, 2026 4:53 pm Okay, go ahead and show the "logical reasoning".
No one shows anything to you, i.e. there is no verbal configuration that can move Phyllo.

Solution? Only if Phyllo (our “modern”) altered or amended certain established views would a possibility open.

By “logical reasoning” I am referring to 1) having developed or allowed the initial intuited position as a first step, then 2) reading those who have crossed out of the zone in which you say you abide. That is, according to your own statements here. There is a “logic process” of developing a new perspective. I mean, it is built on ideas based in sound reasoning.

Re: God and morality

Posted: Wed Nov 11, 2026 5:21 pm
by phyllo
Alexis Jacobi wrote: ↑Wed Nov 11, 2026 5:08 pm Yes, your position is subjective: it arises from your premises. If the premises were to change, it could follow that the subjective stance might change.

The “question” may have been around since ancient times, but our positions are supported by modern pre-suppositions.
Your version of subjectivity is trivial because literally everything is based on some premises. Therefore, objectivity would be completely eliminated.

But do tell me what premises I am using or what modern "presuppositions".

Re: God and morality

Posted: Wed Nov 11, 2026 5:27 pm
by phyllo
Alexis Jacobi wrote: ↑Wed Nov 11, 2026 5:15 pm
phyllo wrote: ↑Wed Nov 11, 2026 4:53 pm Okay, go ahead and show the "logical reasoning".
No one shows anything to you, i.e. there is no verbal configuration that can move Phyllo.

Solution? Only if Phyllo (our “modern”) altered or amended certain established views would a possibility open.

By “logical reasoning” I am referring to 1) having developed or allowed the initial intuited position as a first step, then 2) reading those who have crossed out of the zone in which you say you abide. That is, according to your own statements here. There is a “logic process” of developing a new perspective. I mean, it is built on ideas based in sound reasoning.
You are so clueless.

As soon as anyone asks to you explain or go into detail, you bring out the tired replies ... "you're not really interested", "you're not open to change your mind".

Re: God and morality

Posted: Wed Nov 11, 2026 5:30 pm
by Alexis Jacobi
phyllo wrote: ↑Wed Nov 11, 2026 5:21 pm Your version of subjectivity is trivial because literally everything is based on some premises. Therefore, objectivity would be completely eliminated.
Well, except the functionally the subjectivity I describe is powerful and determining, so the result is not trivial, but consequential. So what I say, and what you say, concord: if the premises stay the same, then by definition no interpretation could change.
But do tell me what premises I am using or what modern "presuppositions".
That would be a project requiring your participation

Re: God and morality

Posted: Wed Nov 11, 2026 5:33 pm
by Alexis Jacobi
phyllo wrote: ↑Wed Nov 11, 2026 5:27 pm As soon as anyone asks to you explain or go into detail, you bring out the tired replies ... "you're not really interested", "you're not open to change your mind".
No, what I say is entirely sound. No verbal description will cause you, nor can cause you, to change the position you hold. It is ingrained in you. My view? You should see this and admit it.

Re: God and morality

Posted: Wed Nov 11, 2026 5:39 pm
by Alexis Jacobi
You must understand: I am *interpreting* the position I have gathered is held by a contingent on this forum: Flash, Gary, Promethean, you and others. I do not exclude myself however. And I see our positions as largely informed by the same processes. These are “modern” and we all are exponents of these processes and the odd metaphysics of our day.

Do you imagine I can present a verbal argument that will, by way of some mystery, cause you-plural to think and see differently? Is that even possible? I don’t think so.

The core pre-suppositions are determinant.

Re: God and morality

Posted: Wed Nov 11, 2026 5:40 pm
by phyllo
Alexis Jacobi wrote: ↑Wed Nov 11, 2026 5:30 pm
phyllo wrote: ↑Wed Nov 11, 2026 5:21 pm Your version of subjectivity is trivial because literally everything is based on some premises. Therefore, objectivity would be completely eliminated.
Well, except the functionally the subjectivity I describe is powerful and determining, so the result is not trivial, but consequential. So what I say, and what you say, concord: if the premises stay the same, then by definition no interpretation could change.
But do tell me what premises I am using or what modern "presuppositions".
That would be a project requiring your participation
Since you know my premises and presuppositions, I don't see why I would need to participate.

You could just say, if you knew.

You certainly don't know what subjectivity is, so I won't waste more time on that bit.

Re: God and morality

Posted: Wed Nov 11, 2026 5:40 pm
by MikeNovack
This discussion is ignoring the elephant in the room.

For a moment, forget the atheists. Consider just the believers.

They will disagree about "the gods". Many of them will consider theirs the only true God and the rest of the believers equivalent to non-believers.

They will receive their own revelations about God, using the evidence they recognize. Consider the evidence used by the others false evidence, false revelation.

Since we are discussing how this relates to morality, they will consider the others as acting without a moral basis for their actions.

SOME of the believers will at least consider that it doesn't matter. They will judge by the choices of actions, considering it irrelevant WHY the "other" is behaving rightly (what basis). They won't care if the others believe in false gods, just whether they are "god-fearing" (conduct themselves as if God mattered -- THEIR god, not the "right" God)

I personally fall into this latter group.

Re: God and morality

Posted: Wed Nov 11, 2026 5:42 pm
by Alexis Jacobi
Oh dear: the Elephant has returned. And the Blind Men?

Re: God and morality

Posted: Wed Nov 11, 2026 5:43 pm
by phyllo
Alexis Jacobi wrote: ↑Wed Nov 11, 2026 5:39 pm You must understand: I am *interpreting* the position I have gathered is held by a contingent on this forum: Flash, Gary, Promethean, you and others. I do not exclude myself however. And I see our positions as largely informed by the same processes. These are “modern” and we all are exponents of these processes and the odd metaphysics of our day.

Do you imagine I can present a verbal argument that will, by way of some mystery, cause you-plural to think and see differently? Is that even possible? I don’t think so.

The core pre-suppositions are determinant.
Like Mr Can, you are an amateur mind reader who believes he knows what others on this forum are thinking.

Re: God and morality

Posted: Wed Nov 11, 2026 5:45 pm
by Alexis Jacobi
MikeNovack wrote: ↑Wed Nov 11, 2026 5:40 pm SOME of the believers will at least consider that it doesn't matter. They will judge by the choices of actions, considering it irrelevant WHY the "other" is behaving rightly (what basis). They won't care if the others believe in false gods, just whether they are "god-fearing" (conduct themselves as if God mattered -- THEIR god, not the "right" God)

I personally fall into this latter group.
That is why I propose that a clarifying metaphysics is needed for people, let’s say, in our predicament. (I find the Gita very helpful for this reason, and that is why I cite from it).