Page 75 of 94

Re: God and morality

Posted: Tue Nov 10, 2026 9:32 pm
by Immanuel Can
phyllo wrote: ↑Tue Nov 10, 2026 8:12 pm
Oh, that's easy. Because He's God. The whole reason for our existence is relationship to Him.
That doesn't explain why somebody should be punished for refusing to do what God wants.
What God wants is right...always.

What you don't seem to be adding up is that the only reason you exist is God. You have no other purpose or destiny but to know Him...or to refuse to, if you choose to use your freedom for the wrong purpose.

It's funny: skeptics accuse God of being too lenient, because He allows evil; then they accuse Him of being too harsh, because He promises that in spite of present leniency, He will eventually establish justice.

Which is it you want? Mercy? Or justice? God will establish both: His mercy now, and His justice to come. You can't get more fair than that.

Re: God and morality

Posted: Tue Nov 10, 2026 9:41 pm
by Immanuel Can
promethean75 wrote: ↑Tue Nov 10, 2026 8:56 pm
"But why should we obey men?"
Because a bro can actually be dangerous
So...power. Because I can hurt you, you must obey me? Nothing more than that?

You know, a lot of people would say that's the opposite of moral. To make somebody do something, with no justification, just by leveraging power...doesn't sound particularly moral, actually.
...while a non-existent god and its threats of an imaginary hell can not be dangerous.
I agree. But the real God, and the real Hell would be quite a different matter, of course.
He commits to save his own ass and to get a piece of a reward.
There are probably people who think that way. I've met a lot of Christians, but I can't say I've met many -- or any-- who think that, though. The usual incentive is the love of God. If you catch a glimpse of that, it's awfully hard to turn away.

Re: God and morality

Posted: Tue Nov 10, 2026 10:06 pm
by MikeNovack
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Tue Nov 10, 2026 7:17 pm
Let's pretend that eviction, not execution, is the chosen punishment. Still, the question remains: why should somebody be punished for refusing to do what some group of others wants them to do?
I am ignoring the rest of what you wrote as nonsense, willful twisting.

Punished? If you won't co-operate with the group the group choosing to exclude you is punishment? The group isn't saying you can't do what you want on your own. It is allowing them the freedom to do that. It is simply saying if you want to be part of the group you play by the rules of the group. If you don't want to be part of the group, go your own way.

OF COURSE ---- when I was speaking of "primitive societies" I meant how all humans lived up to say 10,000 years ago. Small groups. And exile WAS essentially equivalent to a death sentence. Just not a sentence carried out by them (sentence carried out by Nature, other human bands, etc. the exiling band ONLY if the person refused to leave -- and thus no longer "murder" since not a member of the band)

To wake you up from your nonsense about Muslims all being alike --- homework -- obtain/read some books on Hui culture. I could perhaps of chosen one of the others, Tatars, Tajiks, etc. But I'll stick you with Hui.

Re: God and morality

Posted: Tue Nov 10, 2026 10:13 pm
by Immanuel Can
MikeNovack wrote: ↑Tue Nov 10, 2026 10:06 pm
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Tue Nov 10, 2026 7:17 pm
Let's pretend that eviction, not execution, is the chosen punishment. Still, the question remains: why should somebody be punished for refusing to do what some group of others wants them to do?
Punished? If you won't co-operate with the group the group choosing to exclude you is punishment?
Banishment is usually considered punishment, given that we are social creatures. It's awfully hard to get by if your society has evicted you...particularly in "primitive" conditions. In some situations, it might even amount to a death sentence...certainly a sentence of a lot of toil, aloneness and misery. I think "punishment" fits, don't you?
To wake you up from your nonsense about Muslims all being alike...
You'll have to point out where I said they were, first. You'll find I didn't. There are all kinds.

But Islam does pride itself on being one "Ummah." Of course, it's never been that, but it loves to present that story.

Re: God and morality

Posted: Wed Nov 11, 2026 3:29 am
by phyllo
What God wants is right...always.
No. God has done awful things, wrong things.

And historically gods have done wrong. So nothing new.
What you don't seem to be adding up is that the only reason you exist is God. You have no other purpose or destiny but to know Him...or to refuse to, if you choose to use your freedom for the wrong purpose.
I'm not God's chair. I'm not God's slave. Maybe you are, but that's on you.
It's funny: skeptics accuse God of being too lenient, because He allows evil; then they accuse Him of being too harsh, because He promises that in spite of present leniency, He will eventually establish justice.

Which is it you want? Mercy? Or justice? God will establish both: His mercy now, and His justice to come. You can't get more fair than that.
I can't say that I want either of those options. Are those the only two options?

Re: God and morality

Posted: Wed Nov 11, 2026 5:02 am
by Immanuel Can
phyllo wrote: ↑Wed Nov 11, 2026 3:29 am
What God wants is right...always.
No. God has done awful things, wrong things.
Well, somebody has, for certain...but why blame God? Human beings are quite capable of making a mess all by themselves. That much is abundantly apparent from history. Our most secular century was by far our bloodiest.
It's funny: skeptics accuse God of being too lenient, because He allows evil; then they accuse Him of being too harsh, because He promises that in spite of present leniency, He will eventually establish justice.

Which is it you want? Mercy? Or justice? God will establish both: His mercy now, and His justice to come. You can't get more fair than that.
I can't say that I want either of those options. Are those the only two options?
They seem to be the main ones the skeptics complain about.

Re: God and morality

Posted: Wed Nov 11, 2026 9:37 am
by Gary Childress
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Wed Nov 11, 2026 5:02 am They seem to be the main ones the skeptics complain about.


Do you ever speak for yourself and stop speaking for other people that you don't understand or know?

Re: God and morality

Posted: Wed Nov 11, 2026 12:11 pm
by Alexis Jacobi
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Mon Nov 09, 2026 2:14 pm Catholicism shares an unfortunate naiveté with Socialists -- namely, the belief in human perfectibility through institutional reform. Both have an unrealistic anthropology.
This claim is quite false, just for the record. Traditional Catholicism does state that by genuine work on the self, the work of seeing how far one drifts into the errors of sin (essentially sensuous materialism), that one can choose to drop these, and in that way be granted “Grace”. And if the Catholic Worker Movement is referenced, one primary ‘mitzvah’ on might say is charity (which implies social service). Catholicism in truth defines a holistic focus on both spiritual life (Mass, personal spiritual practices, charity) that does not imply “perfectibility” but rather the elimination of those habits that block “Grace” (which is always seen as a gift given by God).

In many ways the “anthropology” of strict Catholicism is more harsher and more demanding than many Protestant paths. At the very least it is a total program for living life and conducting oneself socially, in the family, and economically.

To equate the Catholic social doctrines with “socialism” is rather devious because Catholic doctrine is strictly and fundamentally opposed to Marxian principles and praxis. But it very definitely critiques the errors in, say, “unbridled capitalism” and very definitely the turning of individuals, families and communities into mere instruments of economic transactions.

Re: God and morality

Posted: Wed Nov 11, 2026 12:33 pm
by phyllo
No. God has done awful things, wrong things.
Well, somebody has, for certain...but why blame God? Human beings are quite capable of making a mess all by themselves. That much is abundantly apparent from history. Our most secular century was by far our bloodiest.
Well, God has created some horrific diseases which cause terrible suffering. Nobody is responsible for that except the creator God.

And the Bible describes the awful things that God has done. Of course, you can't believe anything written in the Bible. :D

Re: God and morality

Posted: Wed Nov 11, 2026 12:33 pm
by Alexis Jacobi
phyllo wrote: ↑Tue Nov 10, 2026 7:50 pm Why should somebody be punished for refusing to do what God wants them to do?
If in a given society it were composed of people who a) did agree on what God’s will is in a social and political sense, and b) had become convinced that those ethics were right, good and proper, then it would not be hard to c) recognize malefaction and malefactors, and d) punish them.

It has to be understood that for the largest part we do not live in societies where there is any agreement about any of this. Indeed it should be seen that we live in essential atheism in this sense. There are entirely separate rules and ethics which define the societies we live in now.

And in your case — you are largely in a class of men that does not recognize “divine authority” and are functionally atheistic — the entire notion of a social system that could or would ‘correct’ men for anti-social activities and therefore of activities understood to be “contrary to God’s will”, appears to you and feels tyrannical and dictatorial.

Your argument that those who deviate should be left to themselves is, in fact, the root of social degeneration. But again it requires a population that ‘agrees on the terms’ in order for there to be a society that enacts “God’s will”.

And we live in times in which myriad forces act against any such wide-ranging moral unity and agreement. And when the essential and basic moral commitments are broken, it is at that point that genuine tyranny is probable, because there is no longer an individual who can even recognize “justice”.

Re: God and morality

Posted: Wed Nov 11, 2026 12:47 pm
by Alexis Jacobi
phyllo wrote: ↑Wed Nov 11, 2026 3:29 am No. God has done awful things, wrong things.
This statement reminds me why a fulsome metaphysical explanation of what sort of Reality we live in (such as that offered by the Bhagavad Gita) is necessary to understand “what God is”. You cannot get it by way of ultra-simplistic Christian metaphysics.

EXISTENCE itself (the possibility that there is existence) is an outcome of God’s being. And in this sense we are in God’s being, except that we are in an area of God’s being that is in a marginal “zone” so to speak. Is God awful because such a zone exists and that we suffer in it? And we do suffer (often very much). That’s always the complaint, isn’t it? (That is Gary’s core and abiding complaint for example).

So how can God be conceived of as “absolutely good” and not as a “demonic entity” who created and maintains a perversion of the perfected world that we conceive of in our imagination?

Here it is:
Well, God has created some horrific diseases which cause terrible suffering. Nobody is responsible for that except the creator God.

Re: God and morality

Posted: Wed Nov 11, 2026 1:10 pm
by phyllo
If in a given society it were composed of people who a) did agree on what God’s will is in a social and political sense, and b) had become convinced that those ethics were right, good and proper, then it would not be hard to c) recognize malefaction and malefactors, and d) punish them.
That's a society agreeing on what ought to be punished. They can leave God out of it entirely. God didn't say that what He wills. God is remarkably quiet.
It has to be understood that for the largest part we do not live in societies where there is any agreement about any of this. Indeed it should be seen that we live in essential atheism in this sense. There are entirely separate rules and ethics which define the societies we live in now.
In fact, we live in societies with multiple religious traditions and the people don't agree on God's will. It's not "essential atheism" at all.
And in your case — you are largely in a class of men that does not recognize “divine authority” and are functionally atheistic — the entire notion of a social system that could or would ‘correct’ men for anti-social activities and therefore of activities understood to be “contrary to God’s will”, appears to you and feels tyrannical and dictatorial.
You forgot to mention 'irrational' and 'impractical'.
Your argument that those who deviate should be left to themselves is, in fact, the root of social degeneration. But again it requires a population that ‘agrees on the terms’ in order for there to be a society that enacts “God’s will”.
That would depend on the nature of the deviation, would it not?

Lots of deviations are harmless or beneficial.

One may even call deviation 'freedom'.

How much freedom can a society tolerate? No easy answer to that.
And we live in times in which myriad forces act against any such wide-ranging moral unity and agreement. And when the essential and basic moral commitments are broken, it is at that point that genuine tyranny is probable, because there is no longer an individual who can even recognize “justice”.
How much "wide-ranging moral unity and agreement" to we want? At some point it's oppressive and stultifying. And certainly, people do not agree on what is "essential", or a "basic moral commitment".

I realize that you would like to have such an agreement and not surprisingly agreement to the kinds of social, political and ethical structure that you prefer.

Re: God and morality

Posted: Wed Nov 11, 2026 1:45 pm
by Alexis Jacobi
That's a society agreeing on what ought to be punished. They can leave God out of it entirely. God didn't say that what He wills. God is remarkably quiet.
Again, you simply put do not accept the core premise that God (metaphysical reality) exists. And “the silence of God” certainly appears real — to you.
In fact, we live in societies with multiple religious traditions and the people don't agree on God's will. It's not "essential atheism" at all.
This is true, except that most people even who live in a tradition, live fairly inauthentically in that tradition, and in a larger platform (civilized life) that is atheistic in feeling and outlook.

I agree that “agreements differ” but also that there are similarities (between ethical systems in religion).

But I am attempting to speak (hypothetically) of a culture in which there were substantial agreement.
You forgot to mention 'irrational' and 'impractical'.
Depends on your basic definitions.
That would depend on the nature of the deviation, would it not?
Lots of deviations are harmless or beneficial.
One may even call deviation 'freedom'.
How much freedom can a society tolerate? No easy answer to that.
When there are clear definitions (about God’s will) there is by definition agreement. When there is no agreement, obviously, there can be no enactment of “justice”.

Deviance is definitely freedom in the sense of “possible to do”. But in a defined metaphysics freedom is not license to act lawlessly, irresponsibly and unethically. (And all these require solid not vague definitions).

There are some theorists who point out that the abuse of freedom, and the establishment of immorality (and thus disobedience to God’s will) has extremely consequential results. (Obviously I am in this camp, at least conceptually).
How much "wide-ranging moral unity and agreement" to we want? At some point it's oppressive and stultifying. And certainly, people do not agree on what is "essential", or a "basic moral commitment".

I realize that you would like to have such an agreement and not surprisingly agreement to the kinds of social, political and ethical structure that you prefer.
No, I can only make choices for myself. My view: the general trajectory tends in directions with evermore negative results and consequences. But that is in “the nature of things”.

Thus: Earth is a place where craziness and error play out. It requires a metaphysical interpretation to understand life here in this sense. For this reason, and in the Gita for example, life here is defined as in a marginal state. We can continue to deviate because we are free. Or, and this depends on inner realization, we can respond (to God’s will) and move from marginality back toward the center. This requires an Act of Will and of choice. Also “free” but guided (theoretically) by intelligence (gnosis, buddhi, intellectus). (Greek, Vedic and Latin terms respectively).

Re: God and morality

Posted: Wed Nov 11, 2026 2:04 pm
by Alexis Jacobi
Thus: everything depends on one’s basic definitions. If there are none (if the individual has none or relinquishes them) they will be framed by mechanical or ‘industrial’ forces outside of the individual and these are quite determining in our world.

Re: God and morality

Posted: Wed Nov 11, 2026 2:24 pm
by Alexis Jacobi
The very basic delineation is, I think it is obvious, essential. You have to have a larger, encompassing, metaphysical definition of “what life is”. That is, a cosmology. If at the very base of your definition there is a description that expresses life’s object in conjunction with a “definition of God”, then “what God is” can be conceived of as a huge process in which we find ourselves. There is also in this sense a “personality of God” in a similar sense that there is a human personality.

Possibly this all seems hieroglyphic but Aurobindo wrote.
Therefore it follows that in action the effort of the human individual must be to get back to his true spiritual personality and to make all his works flow from the power of its “supernal Shakti”, to develop action through the soul and the inmost intrinsic being, not through the mental idea and vital desire, and to turn all his acts into a pure outflowing of the will of the Supreme, all his life into a dynamic symbol of the Divine Nature.
Supernal Shakti means “heavenly will” or you could relate it with the idea of the Paraclete. A spirit with which one can align one’s will because it exists.