That's a society agreeing on what ought to be punished. They can leave God out of it entirely. God didn't say that what He wills. God is remarkably quiet.
Again, you simply put do not accept the core premise that God (metaphysical reality) exists. And “the silence of God” certainly appears real — to you.
In fact, we live in societies with multiple religious traditions and the people don't agree on God's will. It's not "essential atheism" at all.
This is true, except that most people even who live in a tradition, live fairly inauthentically in that tradition, and in a larger platform (civilized life) that is atheistic in feeling and outlook.
I agree that “agreements differ” but also that there are similarities (between ethical systems in religion).
But I am attempting to speak (hypothetically) of a culture in which there were substantial agreement.
You forgot to mention 'irrational' and 'impractical'.
Depends on your basic definitions.
That would depend on the nature of the deviation, would it not?
Lots of deviations are harmless or beneficial.
One may even call deviation 'freedom'.
How much freedom can a society tolerate? No easy answer to that.
When there are clear definitions (about God’s will) there is by definition agreement. When there is no agreement, obviously, there can be no enactment of “justice”.
Deviance is definitely freedom in the sense of “possible to do”. But in a defined metaphysics freedom is not license to act lawlessly, irresponsibly and unethically. (And all these require solid not vague definitions).
There are some theorists who point out that the abuse of freedom, and the establishment of immorality (and thus disobedience to God’s will) has extremely consequential results. (Obviously I am in this camp, at least conceptually).
How much "wide-ranging moral unity and agreement" to we want? At some point it's oppressive and stultifying. And certainly, people do not agree on what is "essential", or a "basic moral commitment".
I realize that you would like to have such an agreement and not surprisingly agreement to the kinds of social, political and ethical structure that you prefer.
No, I can only make choices for myself. My view: the general trajectory tends in directions with evermore negative results and consequences. But that is in “the nature of things”.
Thus: Earth is a place where craziness and error play out. It requires a metaphysical interpretation to understand life here in this sense. For this reason, and in the Gita for example, life here is defined as in a marginal state. We can continue to deviate because we are free. Or, and this depends on inner realization, we can respond (to God’s will) and move from marginality back toward the center. This requires an Act of Will and of choice. Also “free” but guided (theoretically) by intelligence (
gnosis, buddhi, intellectus). (Greek, Vedic and Latin terms respectively).