Page 73 of 94
Re: God and morality
Posted: Wed Oct 28, 2026 6:35 pm
by Immanuel Can
Alexis Jacobi wrote: ↑Wed Oct 28, 2026 3:59 am
Is there a third option?
Like?
Re: God and morality
Posted: Sun Nov 08, 2026 7:59 am
by osgart
Nature itself is not moral. It's a morality trap. If there is a God then God created a moral farce. Discovering morality makes existence tolerable.
Re: God and morality
Posted: Sun Nov 08, 2026 4:14 pm
by promethean75
Only if you try to square the biblical god with the world would you come up with such a bleak conclusion. And rightly so, friend, for to think otherwise would be insane!
Might we cleanse the world of all its horrors along with god? How terrified and confused have we become by these tales of angels and demons plotting among us? Be gone! We have had enough of it for thousands of years and still the bells toll!
Re: God and morality
Posted: Sun Nov 08, 2026 4:24 pm
by Immanuel Can
promethean75 wrote: ↑Sun Nov 08, 2026 4:14 pm
Might we cleanse the world of all its horrors along with god?
This is the Socialist utopian dream, alright...and it's robbed, tortured and killed far more people than any other force throughout history. So I think we'd be unwise to keep trying that option.
Re: God and morality
Posted: Sun Nov 08, 2026 4:37 pm
by Impenitent
wise man says: invest in armaments
-Imp
Re: God and morality
Posted: Sun Nov 08, 2026 6:03 pm
by promethean75
Can we be Christian socialists, then?
Re: God and morality
Posted: Sun Nov 08, 2026 6:04 pm
by FlashDangerpants
promethean75 wrote: ↑Sun Nov 08, 2026 6:03 pm
Can we be Christian socialists, then?
Jebus was
Re: God and morality
Posted: Sun Nov 08, 2026 11:37 pm
by Immanuel Can
promethean75 wrote: ↑Sun Nov 08, 2026 6:03 pm
Can we be Christian socialists, then?
Well, according to Marx, Socialism requires Atheism.
Re: God and morality
Posted: Sun Nov 08, 2026 11:58 pm
by MikeNovack
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Sun Nov 08, 2026 11:37 pm
promethean75 wrote: ↑Sun Nov 08, 2026 6:03 pm
Can we be Christian socialists, then?
Well, according to Marx, Socialism requires Atheism.
Nevertheless, there have been and still are Christian socialists. You, IC, might consider them neither Christian noir socialist, and Marx perhaps might have said not socialist.
Re: God and morality
Posted: Mon Nov 09, 2026 4:58 am
by Immanuel Can
MikeNovack wrote: ↑Sun Nov 08, 2026 11:58 pm
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Sun Nov 08, 2026 11:37 pm
promethean75 wrote: ↑Sun Nov 08, 2026 6:03 pm
Can we be Christian socialists, then?
Well, according to Marx, Socialism requires Atheism.
Nevertheless, there have been and still are Christian socialists.
There have also been moral Atheists. Inconsistency is not rare in the human race.
The more important question is, can Christianity itself BE Socialist, or are their only inconsistent "Christian Socialists"?
Re: God and morality
Posted: Mon Nov 09, 2026 5:40 am
by MikeNovack
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Mon Nov 09, 2026 4:58 am
The more important question is, can Christianity itself BE Socialist, or are their only inconsistent "Christian Socialists"?
OK IC, in what way are the Catholic Workers inconsistent
<< your possible claim that Catholics are not consistent Christians is rejected --- MANY Christian sects consider the Christians of other sects "not real Christians" >>
<<your likely claim "not following Marx" and so inconsistent socialists rejected -- among other things Christian socialists existed before Marx and lots of other socialists don't follow Marx. >>
Re: God and morality
Posted: Mon Nov 09, 2026 10:27 am
by popeye1945
Believing in god or gods is simplistic; is that perhaps the attraction, and perhaps the fact that it cannot change? When these mythologies were conveyed through language and not the written word, they did change over time, incorporating new knowledge. Writing changed all that. Without the benefit of the supernatural, we flounder with reason. In a world where the only source of meaning is the conscious subject, we must conclude that religious mythologies were all created by man. That being the case, the only rational foundation to build a morality system upon is that of the well-being and survival of its subject, the human organism and its common biology. As a non-believer, I believe those who do believe in gods hold back human evolutionary intellectual progress. In a time when so much more is known about the world and our place within it than our ancestors could have imagined, we stick to what an ancient shepherd might have known about the world. This is intellectual stagnation; the horizons of the shepherd were perhaps the mountain valley he lived within; man's intellectual journey has expanded his horizons; the entire world is known to the average citizen, and humanity is reaching into the horizon of all horizons, the cosmos.
I believe necessarily that believers of these archaic religions are stifling social evolution. I can understand that the demands of the world do not for most leave a lot of time for contemplation, and these archaic religions are the fast food of a spiritual life, and require little in the way of thought. I think the Christian Martin Luther stated is best, "Reason is the enemy of faith." for some reason he was ok with that, throw your power of reason out, no thinking allowed here. That is the tadition you believers are maintaining. The seed from which morallity grows is when one individual recognizes himself in other creatures, with identification arises compassion , and compassion creates morality. Take what is valuable from these ancient religions and formulate a modern mythology, adequate to taking us into the future. These old religions are the water of a stagnet pond, to drink from them in urnest is do deny the present and blind us to a future.
Re: God and morality
Posted: Mon Nov 09, 2026 2:14 pm
by Immanuel Can
MikeNovack wrote: ↑Mon Nov 09, 2026 5:40 am
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Mon Nov 09, 2026 4:58 am
The more important question is, can Christianity itself BE Socialist, or are their only inconsistent "Christian Socialists"?
OK IC, in what way are the Catholic Workers inconsistent
Catholicism shares an unfortunate naivete with Socialists -- namely, the belief in human perfectability through institutional reform. Both have an unrealistic anthropology.
We might ask, what's bad about optimism about human potential? And the answer is,
"Nothing -- so long as it does not involve becoming blind to the inevitability that some humans will always behave badly, and that all humans will sometimes behave badly." But naive failure to safeguard against human fallenness and sinfulness opens up society to exploitation, crime, abuses, corruption and even full-on totalitarianism. And this is exactly what we have seen happen in all perfectionistic and utopian social plans. Inevitably, along come people who will not play by the idealistic expectations of the social plan, and who recognize the opportunity to take advantage, and who do so.
100%. That's the failure rate of Socialism. That should say something.
Re: God and morality
Posted: Mon Nov 09, 2026 2:17 pm
by Immanuel Can
popeye1945 wrote: ↑Mon Nov 09, 2026 10:27 am
I believe necessarily that believers of these archaic religions are stifling social evolution.
Here's a problem for your belief. The last century was the most secular yet in history. It was also the most bloody. None of the wars in it had any religious cause...and yet it killed more human beings than had died in wars in all previous human history
combined.
So just how did secularization de-stifle "social evolution"?
Re: God and morality
Posted: Mon Nov 09, 2026 4:29 pm
by MikeNovack
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Mon Nov 09, 2026 2:14 pm
We might ask, what's bad about optimism about human potential? And the answer is,
"Nothing -- so long as it does not involve becoming blind to the inevitability that some humans will always behave badly, and that all humans will sometimes behave badly." But naive failure to safeguard against human fallenness and sinfulness opens up society to exploitation, crime, abuses, corruption and even full-on totalitarianism. And this is exactly what we have seen happen in all perfectionistic and utopian social plans. Inevitably, along come people who will not play by the idealistic expectations of the social plan, and who recognize the opportunity to take advantage, and who do so.
100%. That's the failure rate of Socialism. That should say something.
You are ignoring that a society need not be helpless in the face of "people who will not play by the rules" nor need it be totalitarian dealing with them.
You don't understand the difference between a system and the components of a system. A perfectionist SOCIETY does not depend on having perfect people. Note that this is true even at the lowest "theoretical" level << a "perfect" message need not be free of errors -- look up "Hamming distance" >>