Alexis Jacobi wrote: ↑Tue Oct 27, 2026 12:56 pm
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Mon Oct 26, 2026 8:42 pm
Alexis Jacobi wrote: ↑Mon Oct 26, 2026 7:36 pm
That is, of course, the answer by way of Christian understanding.
Of course. Did it need stating?
Christianity inherits from Judaism a range of imperatives that deal on “social justice”.
Hmmm...partly. But the Christian conception of justice isn't really "social" primarily, as it is in modern Judaism. It's personal. Christians do not believe in "social justice" because "society" can never be expected to be "just." All they can do is encourage their society to do the right thing, but they can't seize the political machinery and expect it to issue in justice.
You say that, or state it in that way, because of your Protestant commitments.
No, I say it that way because that's what the Bible says. I don't care about being a "Protestant." I'm not tribal.
...you make the mistake of not including Catholic social doctrine...
That was no mistake; it was deliberate. The Catholic social doctrine isn't Biblical. If you wish to take the word of popes and prelates instead, that's your option, of course. I choose not to.
You can be “saved” and still carry out injustice but suffer no consequence.
That's not how the Bible tells the story.
Christian Zionism...the over-zealous mythological machinations of forcing a “return” to Israel as initial stages of the desired “return of Jesus”...
Again, this isn't what the Bible says. Rather, it says that though Israel will return, as she has chosen of her own free will to do, no human hand can cause any of that; and most definitely, that no hand but the hand of God Himself can effect the return of Jeshua. The timing is entirely His. So there's no point, from a genuinely Biblical perspective, in trying to make it happen. Rather, I think you're mistaking the enthusiasm of Christians for seeing the prophecies of the Bible unfold for some impossible political desire to make it happen. Christians support Israel because the Bible says Israel has a right to exist and a right to its land. They don't support it to make something happen.
I think that the critique of religion generally by some members of this forum is due to a concern about how the religious mentality short-circuits a capability of seeing clearly and distinguishing accurately.
Some may feel that way. It can't be helped. They are making a very obvious mistake, though: they're not spending the time actually to know the difference among various religions and ideologies. So their ignorance is leading them to conclusions that have nothing to do with the truth.
You can
explain things to people; but you can't
understand for them. And if they're ignorant of these things, and are dedicated to remaining so (usually because it offers them the comfort of believing there's nothing to know there, and abates concern and allows them to be intellectually lazy) then you can't stop them. That's what they're going to do.
Thus, the believer and belief are fused into a mass — as in America where there is a vast Christian voting block that reflexively responds to and is seduced by appeals to enthusiasms that coalesce into political positions having nothing to do religious principles.
The statistics actually tell the opposite story: that there are sizeable contingents of the (at least nominally) "Christian" constituencies that vote Democrat. In fact, about 58% ofr registered Democrats self-identify as "Christian." So while it seems the Republicans are more popular, because their agenda tends to be less radical and less Socialist, there are large numbers of "Christians" who are not voting in any such "block" at all.
You really need to check your statistics. I'm afraid that the simplistic portrait with which you're apparently enchanting yourself fails the real-world test at the first hurdle. But again, one cannot stop a person who's determined not to know. They make their own choices.