God and morality

Is there a God? If so, what is She like?

Moderators: AMod, iMod

User avatar
Alexis Jacobi
Posts: 9244
Joined: Tue Oct 26, 2021 3:00 am

Re: God and morality

Post by Alexis Jacobi »

Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Thu Nov 19, 2026 2:47 pm So what you just characterized as a pejorative, you even use of yourself. So if it's an insult, it's you insulting yourself. The label was quite descriptively correct, apparently.
No, for you it is exclusively a pejorative term. And it is certainly pejoratively employed within Christian/Catholic history.

Your entire argumentation is built on the application of pejorative designations. Mine is not. My approach or method involves knowledge (gnosis). Yours involves absolutely solid dogmatism.

What I write is incomprehensible to you. You cannot even entertain the ideas. Or rather any ideas that seems mildly non-doctrinal must ipso facto be rejected.

And you are entirely free to do this. I cannot go along with you however.

So I have no other option but to work out ideation (in respect to the core issues) that is non-conforming. I have no problem with this. It is “the right thing to do”.

The label is right: gnosis. The label is wrong if it is Gnosticism.
User avatar
Immanuel Can
Posts: 30600
Joined: Wed Sep 25, 2013 4:42 pm

Re: God and morality

Post by Immanuel Can »

Alexis Jacobi wrote: ↑Thu Nov 19, 2026 3:07 pm
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Thu Nov 19, 2026 2:47 pm So what you just characterized as a pejorative, you even use of yourself. So if it's an insult, it's you insulting yourself. The label was quite descriptively correct, apparently.
No, for you it is exclusively a pejorative term.
No, I'm just using it descriptively. You were wrong.
The label is right: gnosis. The label is wrong if it is Gnosticism.
Yes, the label is right. But "Gnosticism" is simply the broad, ideological category for those who see themselves as having "gnosis."
User avatar
phyllo
Posts: 3425
Joined: Sun Oct 27, 2013 5:58 pm
Location: Victory in Ukraine

Re: God and morality

Post by phyllo »

Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Thu Nov 19, 2026 3:02 pm
phyllo wrote: ↑Thu Nov 19, 2026 2:49 pm
Anybody who opts for mind-body dualism, especially with the physical being regarded as a "trap" and negative, as something to be escaped, as you do, is by definition, channelling some kind of Gnosticism. That's just definitionally the case.
All Christianity believes in mind-body dualism. At least in the modern age.
Nope. We don't.
You don't believe in a soul separate and separable from the body?

What happens when the body dies? The soul remains intact in some way even as the body decomposes. No?
User avatar
Alexis Jacobi
Posts: 9244
Joined: Tue Oct 26, 2021 3:00 am

Re: God and morality

Post by Alexis Jacobi »

Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Thu Nov 19, 2026 2:29 pm Anybody who opts for mind-body dualism, especially with the physical being regarded as a "trap" and negative, as something to be escaped, as you do, is by definition, channelling some kind of Gnosticism. That's just definitionally the case.
Christianity is grounded in a certain dualism, though it confounds its definitions. The Fall is resulted in man suffering a fate that is defined like a trap. It’s a bizarre idea since man’s fall brought fown the entire created world along with him. So, that condition is not “good” in the sense that it is fallen, rife with death, troubles, enmity and all the rest.

Christians regard The Fall as negative: the result of bad choices. And man’s fate is negative until the Second Adam came along.

And the Mythic Picture is that a process was begun that eventuates in the restoration of the world — and Nature — to Edenic perfection, peace and harmony.

It is an odd phantasy, a mythic picture, to which you (as Bible literalist) have committed yourself.

I do not personally see “escape” as an option. But Eastern schools certainly do, at least the current does exist. But not in all (Eastern) schools. And anyway I am not an Oriental I am an Occidental. So if I define metaphysics they take shape within “my reality”. Not in some other.

And in fact since I refer to Aurobindo his view is not escapist in this sense. His view is that realization — conversion — is essentially a spiritual process. His views are bridging views.
User avatar
FlashDangerpants
Posts: 9356
Joined: Mon Jan 04, 2016 11:54 pm

Re: God and morality

Post by FlashDangerpants »

Alexis Jacobi wrote: ↑Thu Nov 19, 2026 2:10 pm
FlashDangerpants wrote: ↑Thu Nov 19, 2026 12:06 am Wow, the dude posing with the conspiracy-theorist book about "white genocide" there appears to be notorious white-supremacist hate preacher Joel Webbon, author of the far-right conspiracy book in question.
If I have understood correctly, you are the Forum representative of “philosophy”. You know the ropes, you got it all worked out and your purpose is to jump in and make it plain that all those you confront have got it wrong. They just cannot think as you can.
Please try to be less of a whiny piss-bitch.
User avatar
Immanuel Can
Posts: 30600
Joined: Wed Sep 25, 2013 4:42 pm

Re: God and morality

Post by Immanuel Can »

phyllo wrote: ↑Thu Nov 19, 2026 3:16 pm
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Thu Nov 19, 2026 3:02 pm
phyllo wrote: ↑Thu Nov 19, 2026 2:49 pm
All Christianity believes in mind-body dualism. At least in the modern age.
Nope. We don't.
You don't believe in a soul separate and separable from the body?
Gnostic dualism, the kind AJ is asserting, involves much more. It involves the belief that the physical world is inherently evil, or delusory, or a trap for the "higher" soul. The "god," such as there is, is a "demiurge" an evil or stupid entity, one that has trapped the noble soul within the physical realm, and holds it there. Gnosis is supposed to be the means by which the noble soul escapes the body permanently, and transcends to the pure spiritual from which it allegedly came.

Christianity does not hold to that view. It affirms both the goodness of the spiritual and the goodness of the physical, and a coordination between them. Unlike in Gnosticism, the body is not a trap or a burden place on the soul; rather, it is the instrument of action, the means by which the spiritual is put into practice. Even in its' fallen state, the human body is seen as a gift and an opportunity -- as well as something to be redeemed and made eternal, eventually.

None of that fits Gnostic dualism.
User avatar
Immanuel Can
Posts: 30600
Joined: Wed Sep 25, 2013 4:42 pm

Re: God and morality

Post by Immanuel Can »

Alexis Jacobi wrote: ↑Thu Nov 19, 2026 3:27 pm
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Thu Nov 19, 2026 2:29 pm Anybody who opts for mind-body dualism, especially with the physical being regarded as a "trap" and negative, as something to be escaped, as you do, is by definition, channelling some kind of Gnosticism. That's just definitionally the case.
Christianity is grounded in a certain dualism
Only if by "dualism" you mean something extremely broad, like "believing in body and soul." Beyond that, no. It's not at all Gnostic. It's not your kind of "dualism."

See my answer to phyllo for the details.
User avatar
Alexis Jacobi
Posts: 9244
Joined: Tue Oct 26, 2021 3:00 am

Re: God and morality

Post by Alexis Jacobi »

Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Thu Nov 19, 2026 3:12 pm Yes, the label is right. But "Gnosticism" is simply the broad, ideological category for those who see themselves as having "gnosis."
Sure, if one accepts your framing. My notions transcend your limiting framing. I explain your limitations though with a certain intellectual compassion.
User avatar
Immanuel Can
Posts: 30600
Joined: Wed Sep 25, 2013 4:42 pm

Re: God and morality

Post by Immanuel Can »

Alexis Jacobi wrote: ↑Thu Nov 19, 2026 3:30 pm
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Thu Nov 19, 2026 3:12 pm Yes, the label is right. But "Gnosticism" is simply the broad, ideological category for those who see themselves as having "gnosis."
Sure, if one accepts your framing.
Like the dictionaries do? Sure.
User avatar
Alexis Jacobi
Posts: 9244
Joined: Tue Oct 26, 2021 3:00 am

Re: God and morality

Post by Alexis Jacobi »

This sums it up nicely:
If soneone asks: Does conventional Christianity contain gnostic elements, the answer is yes, but the answer depends on what is meant by containing Gnostic elements, because the Bible itself is not a Gnostic book, and traditional literal Christianity explicitly rejected Gnosticism as heresy in the early centuries of the Church.

Yet the Gnostics did not invent their ideas from nothing. They were quoting the Bible, and they were quoting the parts that sound the most like them, which is why the debate has never fully ended.

There are passages in the New Testament that sound strikingly Gnostic because they speak the same language. Paul speaks of a wisdom that is hidden, a mystery concealed before the ages, and he uses the very words that later Gnostics would make central to their system, gnosis and mysterion.

John speaks of God as light in whom there is no darkness at all, and Paul speaks of a conflict between flesh and Spirit, a dualism that would become the backbone of Gnostic thought, in which the material world is lower and the spiritual world is higher and true.

John opens his Gospel with the Logos, the Word that was with God and was God, a passage that Gnostic teachers such as Valentinus claimed as their own. And there are sayings that speak of awakening rather than mere belief, of the kingdom of God being within, of the sleeper rising from the dead while Christ shines upon him. Read on their own, these passages can sound like an invitation to remember who one really is, rather than to believe a doctrine from outside.

Traditional literal Christianity kept those verses but drew a hard line against the core doctrines of Gnosticism, and it rejected them as incompatible with the story of Scripture. Where Gnostic teaching held that the material world was made by an evil or ignorant god, a lesser creator called the Demiurge, the book of Genesis insists that God saw everything he had made and declared it very good.

Where Gnostic teaching held that Jesus only seemed to have a body, that his suffering was an appearance, the Gospel of John insists that the Word became flesh, that he ate and bled and died and rose bodily. And where Gnostic teaching held that salvation comes through secret knowledge given only to the few who are capable of receiving it, traditional Christianity held that salvation comes through faith and grace, preached openly to all. In other words, the language is often similar, but the story is opposite. For the Gnostic, creation is a prison to be escaped. For the literal Christian, creation is good, though fallen, and is to be redeemed rather than abandoned.

Scholars have tended to explain this tension in two different ways. The orthodox view holds that the Bible uses mystical language but is not Gnostic, and that the Gnostics took Christian terms such as Logos, gnosis, light, and mystery and forced them into a different system. Early writers such as Irenaeus argued precisely this, that the heretics were stealing the vocabulary of the Church. The historical critical view holds that early Christianity was far more diverse than later orthodoxy suggests, and that Paul, John, and some early communities did hold proto-Gnostic ideas, so that what we now call traditional Christianity is simply the version that won and was then able to define Gnosticism as outside.

Most historians today land somewhere between these positions, holding that the New Testament contains the raw material from which Gnosticism was built, but does not itself contain Gnosticism as a system.

That is why both sides could keep quoting the same book at each other. If John is read alone, it is possible to sound like a Gnostic. If Genesis is read alone, it is not.
User avatar
Immanuel Can
Posts: 30600
Joined: Wed Sep 25, 2013 4:42 pm

Re: God and morality

Post by Immanuel Can »

Alexis Jacobi wrote: ↑Thu Nov 19, 2026 3:39 pm This sums it up nicely:
It gets it wrong. Gnosticism is actually older than Christianity, starting with paganism, and capable of being articulated in association with religions that are NOT Christianity, like Vedantism or Extropianism, which have nothing to do with Christianity.
the Gnostics did not invent their ideas from nothing. They were quoting the Bible,
The Gnostics, like the Islamists later, would try to steal credibility by borrowing Christian imagery and using it to their own purposes. This is apparent in all sorts of early Gnostic writings. But that didn't make them Christian; and it definitely did not signify that they were merely "quoting the Bible." They were coopting, rewriting and reinterpreting in ways that were not at all Christian.
There are passages in the New Testament that sound strikingly Gnostic because they speak the same language. Paul speaks of a wisdom that is hidden, a mystery concealed before the ages, and he uses the very words that later Gnostics would make central to their system, gnosis and mysterion.
This is true; but only because Paul is explicitly refuting and rejecting Gnosticism. He's turning their own concepts against them, and pointing out that all the "wisdom" they seek is not to be found in their "mysteries," but in the unfolded truth of Jesus Christ Himself.

If you read it, you'll find that's how it is.

And the same goes with the reference to John. John isn't affirming Gnosticism; he's replacing it.
User avatar
phyllo
Posts: 3425
Joined: Sun Oct 27, 2013 5:58 pm
Location: Victory in Ukraine

Re: God and morality

Post by phyllo »

Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Thu Nov 19, 2026 3:29 pm
phyllo wrote: ↑Thu Nov 19, 2026 3:16 pm
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Thu Nov 19, 2026 3:02 pm
Nope. We don't.
You don't believe in a soul separate and separable from the body?
Gnostic dualism, the kind AJ is asserting, involves much more. It involves the belief that the physical world is inherently evil, or delusory, or a trap for the "higher" soul. The "god," such as there is, is a "demiurge" an evil or stupid entity, one that has trapped the noble soul within the physical realm, and holds it there. Gnosis is supposed to be the means by which the noble soul escapes the body permanently, and transcends to the pure spiritual from which it allegedly came.

Christianity does not hold to that view. It affirms both the goodness of the spiritual and the goodness of the physical, and a coordination between them. Unlike in Gnosticism, the body is not a trap or a burden place on the soul; rather, it is the instrument of action, the means by which the spiritual is put into practice. Even in its' fallen state, the human body is seen as a gift and an opportunity -- as well as something to be redeemed and made eternal, eventually.

None of that fits Gnostic dualism.
When you responded to AJ, you used the broad term "anybody" and Gnosticism was just an extreme case. ("Anybody who opts for mind-body dualism, especially with the physical being regarded as a "trap" and negative, as something to be escaped, as you do, is by definition, channelling some kind of Gnosticism. That's just definitionally the case.")

So now you changed your mind. You were always only talking about Gnosticism. Okay.
User avatar
Alexis Jacobi
Posts: 9244
Joined: Tue Oct 26, 2021 3:00 am

Re: God and morality

Post by Alexis Jacobi »

You are a hardcore doctrinaire Bible literalist with a pretty resilient ego!

If you ask me (you do not!), I do not care much for your entire approach. I reject this ultra-formalist approach. And I place emphasis where you do not.

You are entirely free to carry on as you wish!

The more interesting part here is how Christian docrines — Christianesque if you wish — are being expressed in our modern culture and landscape.

If you desire to defend a chemically pure Christian doctrine, have at it. I am more interested in how people operate their beliefs.
User avatar
Immanuel Can
Posts: 30600
Joined: Wed Sep 25, 2013 4:42 pm

Re: God and morality

Post by Immanuel Can »

phyllo wrote: ↑Thu Nov 19, 2026 3:56 pm
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Thu Nov 19, 2026 3:29 pm
phyllo wrote: ↑Thu Nov 19, 2026 3:16 pm
You don't believe in a soul separate and separable from the body?
Gnostic dualism, the kind AJ is asserting, involves much more. It involves the belief that the physical world is inherently evil, or delusory, or a trap for the "higher" soul. The "god," such as there is, is a "demiurge" an evil or stupid entity, one that has trapped the noble soul within the physical realm, and holds it there. Gnosis is supposed to be the means by which the noble soul escapes the body permanently, and transcends to the pure spiritual from which it allegedly came.

Christianity does not hold to that view. It affirms both the goodness of the spiritual and the goodness of the physical, and a coordination between them. Unlike in Gnosticism, the body is not a trap or a burden place on the soul; rather, it is the instrument of action, the means by which the spiritual is put into practice. Even in its' fallen state, the human body is seen as a gift and an opportunity -- as well as something to be redeemed and made eternal, eventually.

None of that fits Gnostic dualism.
When you responded to AJ, you used the broad term "anybody" and Gnosticism was just an extreme case. ("Anybody who opts for mind-body dualism, especially with the physical being regarded as a "trap" and negative, as something to be escaped, as you do, is by definition, channelling some kind of Gnosticism. That's just definitionally the case.")

So now you changed your mind. You were always only talking about Gnosticism. Okay.
No mind change. Christianity doesn't fit that description at all. It doesn't regard the physical as a "trap." As I said, it sees value in both body and soul, and coordination between them. That's two features that make it unlike Gnostic dualism.
User avatar
Immanuel Can
Posts: 30600
Joined: Wed Sep 25, 2013 4:42 pm

Re: God and morality

Post by Immanuel Can »

Alexis Jacobi wrote: ↑Thu Nov 19, 2026 4:01 pm If you desire to defend a chemically pure Christian doctrine, have at it.
A "chemically pure" thing is the best and clearest form of anything. Indeed, I will happily "have at it." And I'll use the source, the Bible itself, as the basis of testing for chemical purity, as well.

On we go. :D
Post Reply