Gary's Corner
-
Gary Childress
- Posts: 13620
- Joined: Sun Sep 25, 2011 3:08 pm
- Location: It's my fault
Re: Gary's Corner
If God presides over an evil world, then I don't want to be with God.
-
Gary Childress
- Posts: 13620
- Joined: Sun Sep 25, 2011 3:08 pm
- Location: It's my fault
Re: Gary's Corner
pm;u smf omdsmr [rtdpm epi;f mpy esmy yp nr eoyj Hpf
-
Gary Childress
- Posts: 13620
- Joined: Sun Sep 25, 2011 3:08 pm
- Location: It's my fault
Re: Gary's Corner
zo s, omdsmr
-
Gary Childress
- Posts: 13620
- Joined: Sun Sep 25, 2011 3:08 pm
- Location: It's my fault
Re: Gary's Corner
zo fpm
y esmy yp nr om yjod ept;f smu,ptr/
y esmy yp nr om yjod ept;f smu,ptr/
-
promethean75
- Posts: 8105
- Joined: Sun Nov 04, 2018 10:29 pm
Re: Gary's Corner
Get a'hold of yourself, Gary!
Evil was put into the world so the good guys can cut loose and stop being so good all the time. What makes it all so exciting is the irony. The evil ones will be thought of as good and vice-versa. For instance, The Mystery Rider (Danny Rolling). Evilest sonofabitch you ever known... and yet... one Danny Rolling is more righteous than a hundred Jesuses, Pauls or Mother Teresas. How so, you aks? Because he is a concentration of all the shit capitalist society creates and therefore infinitely more valuable than those three other clowns.
Fun fact: Danny R. vowed to kill one person for every year or every 'injustice' (can't remember which) he experienced while incarcerated. In one interview, he explains having to eat his meals in a cell flooded with sewer water. You earn some major mana for going through something like that, G.
Evil is the thing that slips in and keeps you distracted from reality. It is your philosophy and metaphysics, your church, your government, everything that bolsters the capitalist's power.
We wave all this babbling aside when we hear it sound out again and again across the emptied halls of a philosophy forum. Everyone is nervously searching for a soul or a heaven, but they haven't even got the material world right yet.
Question: would such philosophical failures even deserve these things they search for? If there were a god, wouldn't he be witness to the whole charade just like we are?
You gotta get the morbid and deranged idea of god that christianity has planted in your head outta there, Gary.
Evil was put into the world so the good guys can cut loose and stop being so good all the time. What makes it all so exciting is the irony. The evil ones will be thought of as good and vice-versa. For instance, The Mystery Rider (Danny Rolling). Evilest sonofabitch you ever known... and yet... one Danny Rolling is more righteous than a hundred Jesuses, Pauls or Mother Teresas. How so, you aks? Because he is a concentration of all the shit capitalist society creates and therefore infinitely more valuable than those three other clowns.
Fun fact: Danny R. vowed to kill one person for every year or every 'injustice' (can't remember which) he experienced while incarcerated. In one interview, he explains having to eat his meals in a cell flooded with sewer water. You earn some major mana for going through something like that, G.
Evil is the thing that slips in and keeps you distracted from reality. It is your philosophy and metaphysics, your church, your government, everything that bolsters the capitalist's power.
We wave all this babbling aside when we hear it sound out again and again across the emptied halls of a philosophy forum. Everyone is nervously searching for a soul or a heaven, but they haven't even got the material world right yet.
Question: would such philosophical failures even deserve these things they search for? If there were a god, wouldn't he be witness to the whole charade just like we are?
You gotta get the morbid and deranged idea of god that christianity has planted in your head outta there, Gary.
-
Gary Childress
- Posts: 13620
- Joined: Sun Sep 25, 2011 3:08 pm
- Location: It's my fault
Re: Gary's Corner
Christianity is the one true religion. God picks his favorites and shits on everyone else. I want no part of the creature that created this miserable world. I hope God rots in his own Hell.
-
promethean75
- Posts: 8105
- Joined: Sun Nov 04, 2018 10:29 pm
Re: Gary's Corner
Well you're just stuck in stage one of the atheist's ascent, then. The first burden is overcoming that Freudian cosmic father-figure thing. If you don't, you .maintain the immature child/parent psychology and will inevitably and up as the emo problem of evil philosopher atheist for the rest of your forsaken life (or so you imagine). That's not rational Spinozizm. That's childish nonsense. We have to get you out of that stage, Gar.
-
promethean75
- Posts: 8105
- Joined: Sun Nov 04, 2018 10:29 pm
Re: Gary's Corner
So, it looks like you're going to Hell, Gary, so I'm gonna give you some survival tips on how to master your environment.
First, meditate carefully on the foundations of your atheism and get your arguments ready. The same insights, complaints, and criticisms you have here you will use against God in court. They will stand just as they stand now. No amount of divine decor will change any of the facts. Here's one for you. It's a god killer. Put in the form of one of Anslem's joints.
If eternal life after a mortal life of less pain (x) is superior and more perfect than eternal life after a mortal life of a lot of pain (y), and, it is not necessary to experience a lot of pain to get to heaven, God chose to do the less perfect thing on purpose and is therefore somewhat of a sadist. Clearly, x is better than y unless God wants arbitrary pain to exist. And neither does the 'that's all history... you're in eternal bliss now' argument hold. IT STILL HAPPENED. Rosanne still had her baby ripped from her arms in a tsunami and lived forty more years in a deep depression.
That's one argument that you're gonna smash em with. Go back to Astro Cat's thread on the gratuitous nature of suffering to sharpen up on the idea.
At the end of your trial, you will be sent to Hell by a god you just humiliated. But now it gets better. If you can keep your wits about you, no amount of torment will phase you because you would have been right. You would have beaten god, Gary. What does it matter what happens next? And, wouldn't you just become stronger and develop even more tolerance for pain (look what you already went through back on erf FFS). Alls you gotta do is remember you beat the sonofabitch and the rest of eternity will be a cake walk wherever you are. Gary the God Slayer afraid of demons? C'mon, Sate... with your scary ass. Where's the fuckin water fountain in this bitch, anyway?
First, meditate carefully on the foundations of your atheism and get your arguments ready. The same insights, complaints, and criticisms you have here you will use against God in court. They will stand just as they stand now. No amount of divine decor will change any of the facts. Here's one for you. It's a god killer. Put in the form of one of Anslem's joints.
If eternal life after a mortal life of less pain (x) is superior and more perfect than eternal life after a mortal life of a lot of pain (y), and, it is not necessary to experience a lot of pain to get to heaven, God chose to do the less perfect thing on purpose and is therefore somewhat of a sadist. Clearly, x is better than y unless God wants arbitrary pain to exist. And neither does the 'that's all history... you're in eternal bliss now' argument hold. IT STILL HAPPENED. Rosanne still had her baby ripped from her arms in a tsunami and lived forty more years in a deep depression.
That's one argument that you're gonna smash em with. Go back to Astro Cat's thread on the gratuitous nature of suffering to sharpen up on the idea.
At the end of your trial, you will be sent to Hell by a god you just humiliated. But now it gets better. If you can keep your wits about you, no amount of torment will phase you because you would have been right. You would have beaten god, Gary. What does it matter what happens next? And, wouldn't you just become stronger and develop even more tolerance for pain (look what you already went through back on erf FFS). Alls you gotta do is remember you beat the sonofabitch and the rest of eternity will be a cake walk wherever you are. Gary the God Slayer afraid of demons? C'mon, Sate... with your scary ass. Where's the fuckin water fountain in this bitch, anyway?
-
promethean75
- Posts: 8105
- Joined: Sun Nov 04, 2018 10:29 pm
Re: Gary's Corner
Oh wait, it develops further?!
If in order to be you in heaven, you must have with you the memories of your lived life, and those memories are shit, then it's possible for you to recall, remember and almost suffer it all over again in doing so. Now, what kind of eternal bliss is that? You're sitting in the golden garden like you do every morning, and sure enough, you think of that horrible day the tsunami came, and a chill runs down your back. This is not good times, mate. Eternal bliss means NO BAD SHIT... not even a memory of bad shit.
Wait, wait. You are a new person, and none of those memories exist now? Is that it? Well then, what was the point of the first you if that you Isn't the you in heaven? You followin' me?
We must therefore conclude a) eternal bliss is impossible, or b) you don't go to heaven (somebody else does).
Did I slay it, or did I slay it? Bruh... has any philosopher ever even presented an argument like that?
Kidding. I got this argument from Gustave Vonhamsonshmidt.
If in order to be you in heaven, you must have with you the memories of your lived life, and those memories are shit, then it's possible for you to recall, remember and almost suffer it all over again in doing so. Now, what kind of eternal bliss is that? You're sitting in the golden garden like you do every morning, and sure enough, you think of that horrible day the tsunami came, and a chill runs down your back. This is not good times, mate. Eternal bliss means NO BAD SHIT... not even a memory of bad shit.
Wait, wait. You are a new person, and none of those memories exist now? Is that it? Well then, what was the point of the first you if that you Isn't the you in heaven? You followin' me?
We must therefore conclude a) eternal bliss is impossible, or b) you don't go to heaven (somebody else does).
Did I slay it, or did I slay it? Bruh... has any philosopher ever even presented an argument like that?
Kidding. I got this argument from Gustave Vonhamsonshmidt.
-
promethean75
- Posts: 8105
- Joined: Sun Nov 04, 2018 10:29 pm
Re: Gary's Corner
It'll finally be argued that the tsunami nightmare is irrelevant now that you and your kid are together in heaven, and I would effectively lose the argument. Still, I stand by my claim that ANY amount of cognitive dissonance or spine shivering falls short of eternal bliss.
-
promethean75
- Posts: 8105
- Joined: Sun Nov 04, 2018 10:29 pm
Re: Gary's Corner
Okay. How about this then. Wherever I am in the universe, the memory of my dog dying in 1990 sucks. Heaven or not. The only way to prevent this would be to reunite me with my dog. Now, are you tellin' me we even get our pets back in heaven?
-
MikeNovack
- Posts: 1453
- Joined: Fri Jul 11, 2025 1:17 pm
Re: Gary's Corner
As somebody into comparative religion I will refer you to any number of poems devoted to just this. IC might not consider it "religion" but I would classify belief in "The Rainbow Bridge" etc. to fall into the category "religious beliefs".promethean75 wrote: ↑Sat Nov 14, 2026 5:39 am Okay. How about this then. Wherever I am in the universe, the memory of my dog dying in 1990 sucks. Heaven or not. The only way to prevent this would be to reunite me with my dog. Now, are you tellin' me we even get our pets back in heaven?
In the meadow before the bridge, you will reunite with your pet, and then cross the bridge together.
We have evidence ~10,000 years old (much older also, but then not certain "dog" yet) of dogs buried as if people. For example, one ~84000 years old with the usual grave goods of the culture.
YOU decide what to believe. If you believe in heaven, no harder to also believe you will reunite with your dog there.
-
promethean75
- Posts: 8105
- Joined: Sun Nov 04, 2018 10:29 pm
Re: Gary's Corner
"YOU decide what to believe. If you believe in heaven, no harder to also believe you will reunite with your dog there."
This is interesting. Are there logical limits for what is possible within a fantasy construct such as heaven? To aks: at what point do you have an unreasonable inference if the whole set in which it is seated is unreasonable?
Heaven. Reasonable. Reunite with your dog there. Not as reasonable but not horribly unreasonable, either. Have a few margaritas with your dog once you reunite. Unreasonable?
Wait, why, though? How do you determine what is unreasonable from within a wholly unreasonable framework of understanding?
This is interesting. Are there logical limits for what is possible within a fantasy construct such as heaven? To aks: at what point do you have an unreasonable inference if the whole set in which it is seated is unreasonable?
Heaven. Reasonable. Reunite with your dog there. Not as reasonable but not horribly unreasonable, either. Have a few margaritas with your dog once you reunite. Unreasonable?
Wait, why, though? How do you determine what is unreasonable from within a wholly unreasonable framework of understanding?
-
Gary Childress
- Posts: 13620
- Joined: Sun Sep 25, 2011 3:08 pm
- Location: It's my fault
Re: Gary's Corner
Going to try harder to contain my anger. It doesn't seem to be helping me approach things thoughtfully. But experiencing anger helps me better understand why justice is important to all of us in a society.
-
promethean75
- Posts: 8105
- Joined: Sun Nov 04, 2018 10:29 pm